trump sent $20 billion to Argentina to help a populist zionist.
He won't send anything to Alaska.
He won't send anything to Alaska.
You're delusional. Corporatism exploded under Obama's watch. That's what creates monster corporations and monopolies/oligopolies. Its done through the regulatory process. Musk has no vested interest in cuts to social services or defunding cities. Your hatred of anyone who has succeeded financially is morbid. Its not a zero sum game.You really don't know?
- Politicians pass bills that favour the rich, because they are funded by the rich
- this allows them to establish monopolies across major industries or control by 2 or 3 corporations that set prices together
- this allows them to attack unions and lower wages all around you
- this allows the rich to get bills cutting social services cut all around you
- this creates more poverty and more desperate people which creates more crime
- this allows the rich to pass deregulation bills that take away industry protections
- this allows people like Mariam Adelson to get trump take away citizens rights and send billions in cash to Israel and Argentina
- this defunds cities and states and contributes to the rotting infrastructure in america
- this results in the most expensive and worse health care in the western world, the only one with a declining mortality
I'd go on, but you won't consider this as possible.
You're delusional. Corporatism exploded under Obama's watch. That's what creates monster corporations and monopolies/oligopolies. Its done through the regulatory process. Musk has no vested interest in cuts to social services or defunding cities. Your hatred of anyone who has succeeded financially is morbid. Its not a zero sum game.
You are correct. The vast majority of Elon's wealth is in stock options. So, he isn't necessarily liquid (as in, has ready access to just billions in cash), and if he sold those options, he would be crushed by income and capital gains taxes. So, instead, he uses his stock options as collateral and borrows money from lenders. This is not considered income, and in some circumstances can be written off from his actual income tax. So, he can buy Twitter without having to tap into his actual fortune and pay income tax on that...
Yes, this pledging of assets to access money bothers me too. I would like to see an effort to minimize essentially using unrealized capital gains to borrow money.
I've tried to answer this problem in my own mind but I am not a tax attorney. Beyond let's tax the billionaires more, there's the matter that this type of borrowing is far more common then people realize. People use appreciated stocks and real estate to borrow money all the time. In fact, it's rather easy for anyone to borrow against the appreciated value of stocks. Real estate requires an appraisal and some paperwork. I think this also works under Canadian tax law as well.
or he/ she could borrow against unrealized gains, buy a company and turn it around , employing thousandsThere should be better efforts to tax all wealthy individuals and deal with those complexities. However, buying Twitter with borrowed money is a tricky example. An extremely wealthy individual can likely walk into a sales office at the mega yacht marina and sail away with a big ass yacht with a downpayment and no income tax consequences.
its their money and as long as they earned it legally and assumed the risk to earn it they should get to keep itThere should be better efforts to tax all wealthy individuals
i do not agree with its their money and as long as they earned it legally and assumed the risk to earn it they should get to keep it
exactly what does the government do and exactly wk=hat risks does a government assume in order to claim 50%+ of the profit ?
nothing
once claimed the govt just wastes much of it
I personally think that taxing individuals based on theirThat might be all true, but we all live in societies that require taxation. I personally think that taxing individuals based on their wherewithal to pay makes sense.
One can always debate tax rates.
Yes, this pledging of assets to access money bothers me too. I would like to see an effort to minimize essentially using unrealized capital gains to borrow money.
I've tried to answer this problem in my own mind but I am not a tax attorney. Beyond let's tax the billionaires more, there's the matter that this type of borrowing is far more common then people realize. People use appreciated stocks and real estate to borrow money all the time. In fact, it's rather easy for anyone to borrow against the appreciated value of stocks. Real estate requires an appraisal and some paperwork. I think this also works under Canadian tax law as well.
There should be better efforts to tax all wealthy individuals and deal with those complexities. However, buying Twitter with borrowed money is a tricky example. An extremely wealthy individual can likely walk into a sales office at the mega yacht marina and sail away with a big ass yacht with a downpayment and no income tax consequences.
That might be all true, but we all live in societies that require taxation. I personally think that taxing individuals based on their wherewithal to pay makes sense.
One can always debate tax rates.
Yes, this pledging of assets to access money bothers me too. I would like to see an effort to minimize essentially using unrealized capital gains to borrow money.
I've tried to answer this problem in my own mind but I am not a tax attorney. Beyond let's tax the billionaires more, there's the matter that this type of borrowing is far more common then people realize. People use appreciated stocks and real estate to borrow money all the time. In fact, it's rather easy for anyone to borrow against the appreciated value of stocks. Real estate requires an appraisal and some paperwork. I think this also works under Canadian tax law as well.
There should be better efforts to tax all wealthy individuals and deal with those complexities. However, buying Twitter with borrowed money is a tricky example. An extremely wealthy individual can likely walk into a sales office at the mega yacht marina and sail away with a big ass yacht with a downpayment and no income tax consequences.
Progressive taxation was the norm until Reagan and neoliberalism.
That kept the rich from becoming all powerful and allowed the government to pay for services.
It goes beyond just that. About 10 years or so ago, France tried to make the billionaire class pay more in taxes. Sounds great on paper. But, as mentioned, these people have the best tax lawyers and accountants, so they could find loopholes so large that, if I recall correctly, the French government actually saw law tax revenue from these people.
There are no easy answers. And, to be honest, if you have THAT much cash, the taxes probably don't really even hurt that much. I mean, think of a regressive tax jurisdiction like Texas. Sure, the wealthy pay less, but the poor are the ones that have a much higher tax rate. Which also feels very unfair...
I'm not sure if that's true in France but it is true that in other places like Denmark and Norway they tax the rich the way Canada and the US used to and they can afford to take care of their own people.
I used to know a guy who was an auditor at the CRA. He dealt with companies, not individuals. From his experiences, he told me the way the tax code is written, companies are able to interpret to try and get the maximum breaks. His job was to try and push back on that, and get them to pay what they're owed. The language used in the tax code is broad and can be ambiguous, allowing a lot of different interpretations. I think part of that is on purpose, to allow it to appear strong, but give corporate Canada the ability to push boundaries...
I used to know a guy who was an auditor at the CRA. He dealt with companies, not individuals. From his experiences, he told me the way the tax code is written, companies are able to interpret to try and get the maximum breaks. His job was to try and push back on that, and get them to pay what they're owed. The language used in the tax code is broad and can be ambiguous, allowing a lot of different interpretations. I think part of that is on purpose, to allow it to appear strong, but give corporate Canada the ability to push boundaries...
MAGA: