Muslim terror attack in New Orleans today

Nothing you provide overrides the conclusions of the DHS and the FBI that in the US, right wing, white supremacy domestic terrorism is the most dangerous.
In this matter, their word is gospel.
Why is it that lefties hold government agencies as the source of the almighty truth? Could it be that maybe your government isn't being honest or at the very least being biased about their findings. Or does that only apply when its a Trump administration? The fact of the matter is that you can do your own research if you have half a brain and you will see that from 2002-2023 there have been 202 deaths on U.S. soil due to official terrorist incidents. Broken down as follows:

99 at the hands of Islamic extremists
75 at the hands of 'right-wing' extremism (white supremacists/anti-Semites/anti-Abortion/Sovereign citizen movement)
9 at the hands of left-wing extremism (anti-police/anti-white racism)
19 due to non-political reasons

I put 'right-wing' in quotes because I think they are being a little too presumptive in labeling some of these incidents right wing extremism. Not all anti-Semites/anti-immigrant/white supremacists are right wingers.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Phil C. McNasty
Or does that only apply when its a Trump administration?
With Trump, this is called into question because the entire MAGA movement is based on lies, racism etc.,
This is one of the dangers of the Trump administration where they place cronies and crooks in these agencies to push the MAGA agenda rather than do their job, which severely undermines these agencies and the way they function.
This was not the case with these agencies even under Republican rule previously.
 
With Trump, this is called into question because the entire MAGA movement is based on lies, racism etc.,
This is one of the dangers of the Trump administration where they place cronies and crooks in these agencies to push the MAGA agenda rather than do their job, which severely undermines these agencies and the way they function.
This was not the case with these agencies even under Republican rule previously
Oh hi, Kautilya 👋
 
  • Haha
Reactions: JuanGoodman and RZG
Because they have the expertise and you don't.

Like WMD's in Iraq? You want a list of other falsehoods, false flags, lies by omission these agencies are responsible for?

Remember they also want FUNDS. They need threats to maintain and expand budgets. In some cases they even manufacture threats by enabling them in sting operations. And these are easy, low threat busts.

If they were this expert they would prevent more. They do their best. But cripes if the Trump shooter didn't show you they aren't as competent as everyone thinks, what will?
 
Like WMD's in Iraq? You want a list of other falsehoods, false flags, lies by omission these agencies are responsible for?
They lied about that to start a war for regime change.
Why would they lie about domestic terrorism?
Also to call it a lie you'd need to know more than the FBI or DHS, which I dont believe anyone else does.
 
but you have been expressing your somewhat partisan views in almost all of your post
I am against the MAGA movement.
Many others are as well like squeezer, mandrill, jalimon.
You, Phil, Douglas are supporters of MAGA.
You have been expressing your partisan views on all your posts too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chintu3873
The report says attacks since 9/11. True, more right wing attacks since then. But 9/11 had 3k+ fatalities.
Thus, depending upon when one wishes to tally the dead...could explain the disagreement.

Also the Wikipedia lists worldwide attacks. Not just USA. The issue i thought was framed by usa.
The hiding of data is wrong. These numbers are confirmed by scientific methods which meams the reporting people have to show all their data, their means of collection, their decision rules for collection, and so forth.
This is what makes science better than punditry.
 
Last edited:
The report says attacks since 9/11. True, more right wing attacks since then. But 9/11 had 3k+ fatalities.
Thus, depending upon when one wishes to tally the dead...could explain the disagreement.

Also the Wikipedia lists worldwide attacks. Not just USA. The issue i thought was framed by usa.
The hiding of data is wrong. These numbers are confirmed by scientific methods which meams the reporting people have to show all their data, their means of collection, their decision rules for collection, and so forth.
This is what makes science better than punditry.
# of fatalities should be the barometer, not the number of incidents. And given that Islamic extremism is a bigger threat than so called right wing extremism.
 
and I wish you many more years

but if some members are suggesting that your posting style resembles Kautilya"s

then maybe there is something to it

Grasping at straws.
 
# of fatalities should be the barometer, not the number of incidents. And given that Islamic extremism is a bigger threat than so called right wing extremism.
This is always the conundrum. Low frequency/high cost VS higher frequency/lower cost.
But, articulating what should the criteria is the way to go.
 
and I wish you many more years

but if some members are suggesting that your posting style resembles Kautilya"s

then maybe there is something to it
That's where I believe the difference is.

Kaut was inarticulate, illogical and routinely flew off the handle. Shaq seems, more intelligent, more measured in his replies and is capable of partaking in an intelligible conversation without resorting to insults, name-calling and ad hominem attacks. Kaut never once displayed (to me) that he was ever capable of being involved in a civil discussion.

I think that they're different because their styles are very, very different, but I've been fooled before.
 
That's where I believe the difference is...I think that they're different because their styles are very, very different, but I've been fooled before.
My thoughts as well. Shack and I disagree on many topics, but we try to keep it civil. Kautilya did not.

Welcome back Shack!
 
I hope that your loathing of Trump is not clouding your judgment
No.
I actually support some of Trump's foreign policy positions about not getting into wars, or giving aid to Ukraine and so on.
I do not support some of Trump's domestic policies but those are also some of his most important policy positions.
And then there is his character.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JuanGoodman
I'm not 100% sure, but I think he left the forum voluntarily and had all his posts deleted
Not quite. He came back with another handle to say goodbye in his characteristically pleasant manner.

It was quite funny. He insulted everyone for being on an escort review board. Apparently he was better than the rest of us who pay for sex.