It was not an ethnic cleansing which is what I thought you alluded to when you said the Palis want the Jews gone.
Israel at war
- Thread starter Butler1000
- Start date
When has that identity begun? In Soviet UN speeches around 1947 two parties are called Jews and arabs. Palestinians would have meant both of those.
Atleast as early as 1920 when the entire region was called Mandatory Palestine.
Mandatory Palestine - Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org
Palestine (region) - Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org
That’s meaningless because it includes Jews and arabs and christians who lived in Levant.Atleast as early as 1920 when the entire region was called Mandatory Palestine.
The first written records referring to Palestine emerged in the 12th-century BCE Twentieth Dynasty of Egypt, which used the term Peleset for a neighboring people or land.Mandatory Palestine - Wikipedia
Palestine (region) - Wikipedia
The issue is when Palestinian arabs become different from other arabs?
Maybe we can agree on 1964 when the PLO was formed? Which makes for atleast 3 generations of Palestinians. We can also agree that it exists today in a very real sense?
A point to note, which you said in your prior post as well is that the Palestinian tag is for Jews, Christians and Muslims who lived in the region. But not for the Jewish immigrants from Europe. So if you were to accept a new Israeli identity, or apply the Palestinian identity to all Jews in present day Israel, then the issue with Palestinian identity being new does not arise.
I think on the grand scheme of things it don’t really matter at this point who is more indigenous and whose temples are more ancient.
Once again, you simply have millions of jews who don’t want to leave and millions of Palestinians and other various arabs who want them to be gone from the river to the sea.
All the talk about who came from Poland or who doesn’t have their own language or fairytales or culture is, if not hate speech, at least not helping bringing peace.
Last edited:
Is it not equally fair to say that you simply have millions of Palestinians who don't want to leave, and millions of Israelis who want them to be gone from river to the sea.
Absolutely and manifestly wrong.
Israelis gave gaza back to Gazans almost 20 years ago. Israel forcefully removed their citizens from gaza at the time. Gazans could have built Singapore but they chose to build terror tunnels.
Oatmeal’s response went way over your head. He provided some quality insights.
Same reason.
You gonna declare its also ancestral land?
Well, the facts on the ground are that there is a genocidal ethnic cleansing going on in Gaza, and spreading to the West Bank and Lebanon.
Do the 233 settler terrorist attacks in 2023 before Oct 7 count?
Does the attack on Al Aqsa on Oct 6 count?
