Making to the playoffs in baseball is not that hard anymore. 1/3rd of the teams make it in. It's not like 92 & 93 when only 4 teams made it in. If you have a payroll he's had, you need do to more then make it to the playoffs a bunch of years and not win a single game. I was a huge supporter of these guys for the first 5 years, especially in 2021when they were literally the best team in baseball the last two months but it was too little too late.
Since then, they let Semien walk, completely depleted the farm system which Shapiro blasted AA for, and basically went on record to say they will always a good farm system going forward. Now here we are 9 years later with a terrible farm system and team that's in last place in the AL with a very bleak future. 9 years with zero playoff wins, and now last place team with bleak future that is 8th payroll is simply unacceptable. I'm not sure how else you can look at it.