Anyway, what do you think of this thought
Buy index funds, with no consideration of dividends, because of three reasons
1 they are free compared to mutual funds which give no value in return
2 stock picking is a horrible idea as you assume you know more than the market, which you do not
3 if you buy only dividend stock you are factor investing and the factor dividend stocks has no history of beating the
market like the factor of small caps do, for example
If market plumments switch some index money into a dividend index as you are selling low but also buying low so that is a wash then live of those dividends until market rebounds
Reasoning is dividends underperform the market as a whole because of lack of diversification IE you are ignoring over half the market -
so you can always sell stock when needed but by switching to dividend stock when market is in bear you are not selling low
But now that I think of it, dividends force you to sell when market is low anyways so maybe that is not a good idea
But they also force you to sell when market is high so that is a good idea
but my idea means market timing which cannot be done
So why not ... oh nevermind ....
This is too complex for me LOL
What you buy should depend on what you are looking for. Some people shouldn't be in the market at all. If every little move and shake will cause you to stroke out, don't do it.
1: Index mutual funds and ETFs are not free, just have a lower management expense ratio, much lower. BTW you are comparing actively traded mutual funds vs index mutual funds [and then you have ETFs] the two former are still mutual funds.
2: Stock picking at least for seeking capital gains is, well even the experts don't beat the market so what chance do you have. Yes I select the stocks I own, but I am only interested in the dividend stream, and that is a much simpler process. I am also not trying to beat out anyone. Again different strokes for different folks. If you are seeking gains, indexs either Mutual Funds or ETFs are the way to go. Or just put all your money in Dutch Tulips like a boss.

3: If that's important to you, fine. It isn't for me.
4: Again it's been said that Canadian Banks are a proxy for index funds because they are into everything, and in the past few decades it would have done really well. Also again, if you only care about an income stream, who cares about underperforming and overperforming. There is a risk involved in seeking gains. Also if you have index funds you have plenty of financials and utilities in there just saying.
5: The whole point for me with dividends is that I am never forced to sell. I live off the dividends. I only sell to switch to the crappiest bank at the end of the year or to capture some capital gains to avoid them getting to high and then reinvesting * You are no more forced to sell dividend stocks than any other when the market is low. However if you rely on your investments to live on as opposed to work income, pensions, pimping and drug dealing etc than you are forced to sell more when prices are low with low dividend stocks than high. I get about 37K dividends every year plus GST checks HST checks etc, I only need 25K a year for important expenses. If I were 100% into low dividend stocks, when the market drops I'd have to sell low whenever the market is down.
6: I do plan on taking out some capital gains should my dividends grow beyond the inflation rate. If I get 100 in dividends and it goes to 105 by the basket of goods I buy is only 102, I can sell roughly 3% use that for more whoring money and still be able to finance my lifestyle. In a sort of way it's kinda sell high, just not exact in that dividend growth and stock price should mostly but not always be correlated. Likewise if my stocks are sucking the big ones and the dividend increases are not there, I live off the dividends and hold my dick tight.
I am not suggesting anyone do what I do. My plan is based on my very particular financial situation and is also for someone who knows the idea behind it and what they are doing. It's not the worst thing in the world for others to do, but still I don't want to be responsible for other people.
If you are young and need gains, buy the index, or international indexes. Avril Lavinge was right, it doesn't have to be so complicated. But if you are done with work and need to draw an income, a focus on dividends can isolate you partially from market ups and down, and when you get older, the ability to sleep is important. That is assuming you can generate enough money from dividends to pay your way with a buffer.
When I get really old, depending on my health I'll consider annuities which normally suck balls, but they have their uses.
* I do sell some shares because I want to spend the dividends I make in my TFSA without taking money out of it, also I sell shares to put more money into the TFSA every year. However I consider that not really a net sale but more just a transfer of funds back and forth between two accounts without actually moving the money because CRA reasons.