Israel at war

I guess it went over your head.

Israel is attacking much more in the north than the south.

The north is a more dangerous area.

The south is a less dangerous area.

Hence the south is safer than the north for Gazan civilians.

Israel warned them to go south since there would be LESS bombing, not NO bombing.

Yet Hamas did not want them to go to the south.

Is any of this registering with you frank or do you still not get it?

There are close to 10,000 dead, shack.
Israel is clearly not avoiding civilians.

 
Using civilians as shields is a war crime and it precedes a bullet being fired or a bomb being dropped.

Hamas thought that doing that would help them be protected, because they are cowards. Israel is calling their bluff. Hamas is sacrificing their people at every turn. And the people of Gaza are coming to that realization.

How do you think this works, shack?
Do they march around with civilians at gunpoint?
Do you think Hamas has a tunnel underneath every single building destroyed?

Why would Hamas use human shields, Israel is bombing the shit out of Gaza regardless of what is there.

You push a really stupid argument to idiocy daily.
All to defend Jewish supremacy.

The red cross says there were no Hamas near the ambulances.
Your just justifying genocide.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
How do you think this works, shack?
Do they march around with civilians at gunpoint?
Do you think Hamas has a tunnel underneath every single building destroyed?

Why would Hamas use human shields, Israel is bombing the shit out of Gaza regardless of what is there.

You push a really stupid argument to idiocy daily.
All to defend Jewish supremacy.

The red cross says there were no Hamas near the ambulances.
Your just justifying genocide.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76
This is not about Hamas. This is about the civilians killed.
Sorry. In this particular situation, Hamas is inextricably linked to the Gazan civilians killed.

Hamas triggered Israeli retaliation on Oct 7 which has resulted in death and suffering.

Yes or no, do you think that so many Gazans would have been killed in the last 4 weeks if Hamas had not launched their attack on Oct. 7.

I know that frank would never answer such a question, but at this point I consider you be much more honourable and a more honest debater than frank, so I hope that you will do me the courtesy. Feel free to expound on your reasoning, but I'd like to hear a yes or no.
 
WW2 was one big clusterfuck of a war crime everywhere. I don't believe such standards for war even existed at that time, did it?
Quite possibly not, but I'm using that as an example of a historical reality. The loser of war has more casualties. And the corollary is that having more casualties is what causes one side to lose the war.

I don't think that will ever change. You're not going to win a war by keeping things proportional.
 
I know that frank would never answer such a question, but at this point I consider you be much more honourable and a more honest debater than frank, so I hope that you will do me the courtesy. Feel free to expound on your reasoning, but I'd like to hear a yes or no.

You are the most dishonest person on this board, shack.
You make repeated demands that everyone answer your questions, then change the terms so you can say they didn't answer.
You refuse to answer any questions or to make even basic statements.

Like your refusal to say you shouldn't kill children.
So you'll get something like this for every post until you do.

Here's one of your failures, shack. A couple of terrorists who lived.
You better send more money for bombs.

 
Yes, Hamas' plan all along was to force Israel to put them in a concentration camp and turn it into a death camp.
For profit.
Do you think that so many Gazans would be dead in the last 4 weeks if Hamas had not launched their attack on Oct 7? Yes or no.

Clearly the answer is no yet you still support that attack. You obviously don't care how many Gazans die.
 
Doesn't matter what Hamas did, or didn't do. Israel has a choice every time they release a bomb. They should follow the rules of war and not commit war crimes
Hamas arent following the rules either by using civilians as human shields
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76
It started in places like the Warsaw ghetto, the yellow stars. This was before the gas chambers.

Yes. But you didn't call that out. You called out the slaughter of the Jews by Hitler and said it was opposed by now. Which is ridiculous. Millions died opposing it.

Even after the war the world didn't care. Look at the story of the ship The Exodus, where countries refused to allow the ship to dock and take in Jewish refugees.
The same way neither Israel nor anyone else wants to take in Palestinian refugees and you defend that? Bit hypocritical, no? Also not what you called out either. Kind of unfair to act like I implied Jews never suffered except at the hands of Hitler when I all I did was point out the folly of your statement claiming "the slaughter of Jews by Hitler was opposed by no one." 🤷‍♂️
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
You are the most dishonest person on this board, shack.
You're the one that has that honour all locked up. I think they'll name that trophy after you.

Like your refusal to say you shouldn't kill children.
Starting Oct. 8, you have refused to say that Hamas' attack on Israeli citizens of Oct. 7 was an act of terror.

You set the rules of engagement and I'm following your precedent. It's funny how you don't like someone using the same tactics that you initiated. That is so typical of you. You like to dish it out, but you clearly can't take it.
 
Unfortunately, that is not the case. Israel is deliberately targeting Hamas. Hamas are the ones putting them in harms way deliberately and directly in front of the target.
Under the rules of war, that's not how it works. If you blow up a hospital to kill a bad guy hiding inside the hospital, you still need to establish proportional proportionality or it's a war crime.

When you blow up an enemy base and the bits of burning rubble land on the school a block over and it catches on fire, that's called collateral damage. There were no civilians in your sights when you dropped your bombs and it's a tragedy that some died from the fallout.

When you bomb a place you know it's filled with civilians, it doesn't matter if there may be some bad guys there, the laws of war classify it as the deliberate targeting of civilians. You aren't hoping your bombs miss them, you know your bombs are going to hit them. So it doesn't matter what other targets are there, you've deliberately targeted them too, and so you have to establish proportional proportionality in order for it not to be a war crime.

It's very straightforward and very cut and dry. You're trying to play semantics with international law related to preserving human life.
 
You've lost all pretence of morality and are now saying its all about power.
You turned into everything you hate and you didn't even notice.
Not true at all. And it's very ironic hearing about hate when it's coming from you.

But I will say that you have a way of bringing out the worst in people.

That is also why I say that you create more discord on TERB than anyone else and you are a detriment to the board.