Desantis Gets a History Lesson from a Historian

Yes, they have part of the blame, as do the Arab leaders who launched the war and refused to give refugees any rights.

But no surprise that you refuse to actually talk about history. Is Rashid Khalidi too much of a zionist stooge for you to discuss his works?

Tomorrow is Nabka day.

75 years later and people are still trying to further the Nabka.
 
Tomorrow is Nabka day.
...
And still you refuse to discuss actual history and instead just want to whine about how evil the Jewish conspiracy is.

The reality is that this conflict like most other lengthy ethnic conflicts has a long history and there is plenty to condemn on both sides, both historically and in the modern world. Sadly unlike actual historians and rational observers, you simply push an agenda that everything Israel and Jews have done in the region must be bad and you keep pushing an imperialistic trope that Arabs are too far beneath you to deserve any blame or condemnation.
 
And still you refuse to discuss actual history and instead just want to whine about how evil the Jewish conspiracy is.

The reality is that this conflict like most other lengthy ethnic conflicts has a long history and there is plenty to condemn on both sides, both historically and in the modern world. Sadly unlike actual historians and rational observers, you simply push an agenda that everything Israel and Jews have done in the region must be bad and you keep pushing an imperialistic trope that Arabs are too far beneath you to deserve any blame or condemnation.

This is a 53 year old occupation.
Its not a conflict.

75 years since the Nabka and 75 years of settler colonialism, ethnic cleansing and now apartheid.
There is no history that justifies this any more than any history justifies terrorism.

Only racist scum think self defence includes attacking civilians who were not engaged in acts of violence.



 
Last edited:
This is a 53 year old occupation.
Its not a conflict.
...
It's a 104 year old conflict from the first time Arabs in Jerusalem were incited to attack the longstanding Jewish population over anti-immigrant hatred.

As I said, you try to completely avoid discussing history because it would force you to admit that yes, Arab leadership have played a huge role in the conflict.
 
It's a 104 year old conflict from the first time Arabs in Jerusalem were incited to attack the longstanding Jewish population over anti-immigrant hatred.

As I said, you try to completely avoid discussing history because it would force you to admit that yes, Arab leadership have played a huge role in the conflict.

You mean the foreign zionists who took over Palestine and ethnically cleansed the population and stole their land?

 
You mean the foreign zionists who took over Palestine and ethnically cleansed the population and stole their land?
...
Ah, the anti-immigrant screed of a true racist.

And yes, the Arab riot attacking Jews in 1919 (and 1929) were attacking long standing Jewish communities in Jerusalem and Hebron because they didn't like the fact that the Ottoman (and later British) authorities were allowing legal Jewish immigration (not mentioning that some of the same Arab leaders inciting violence were also profiting by selling land to Jews at extremely inflated rates).

But again, that would involve actually discussing history and admitting that Arab leadership have a huge culpability for the events. Instead you just want to post tweets by random people.
 
Ah, the anti-immigrant screed of a true racist.

And yes, the Arab riot attacking Jews in 1919 (and 1929) were attacking long standing Jewish communities in Jerusalem and Hebron because they didn't like the fact that the Ottoman (and later British) authorities were allowing legal Jewish immigration (not mentioning that some of the same Arab leaders inciting violence were also profiting by selling land to Jews at extremely inflated rates).

But again, that would involve actually discussing history and admitting that Arab leadership have a huge culpability for the events. Instead you just want to post tweets by random people.

Same thing that Ben Gurion said, you think he was a racist as well?
(of course he was, he was a zionist, colonial settler engaged in terrorism)

 
346303860_1287924125465788_7690845315332703339_n.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Keep on posting random tweets. All it shows is you are incapable of discussing actual history.

Why is it you think that Arab leaders in the past 100 years don't deserve any blame for their choices?

I gave you the quotes that made the case.
You provided nothing.
 
I gave you the quotes that made the case.
You provided nothing.
Tweets vs historians.

In this thread I've made repeated statements based on numerous historians which you claim are all lies and instead of actually backing up your claims, you just post random tweets and memes.
 
Tweets vs historians.

In this thread I've made repeated statements based on numerous historians which you claim are all lies and instead of actually backing up your claims, you just post random tweets and memes.

Tweets from historians, tweets with direct quotes from Israeli leaders.
All you provide are your own very biased statements while denying what Ben Gurion said.

Ben Gurion also warned Israel that if they kept the occupied territories Israel would become apartheid.

Tweets like these are legit:

As are these:
 
Tweets from historians, tweets with direct quotes from Israeli leaders.
...
The anti-semite Jeremy Corbin is a historian? Another interesting fact.

Do you deny:
- that Jews made up well over 1% of the Ottoman empire between 1850 and 1919 and that Israel is around 1% of former Ottoman land?
- that Wealth Arabs sold land to Jews out from under the Arab tenants (who could have had rights to the land under 1858 Ottoman land reform?
- that many Jews were either indigenous to the Palestine Mandate or were legal immigrants under both the Ottomans and Brits?
- that Arab leaders incited mob violence against indigenous Jewish communities in 1919 and 1929?
- that Jerusalem had a significant Jewish population before Zionism was ever discussed?
- that Arab and Palestinian leaders rejected the idea of any land sharing with Jews and chose to go to war over it?
- that those same Arab leaders locked refugees in camps without rights instead of treating them with the respect and chance to assimilate the UN expects?
- That the Palestinian identity was part of a pan-Arab Levantine identity unto the late 50's-early 60's?
- that very few Palestinian refugees and their descendants want to be Israelis?
- that in the same time frame that 750,000 Arabs fled the war zone, 1,000,000 Jews were chased out of their Arab homelands because of anti-semitism and a conflict they had no part of?
- that wealthy Palestinians simply moved to their other homes in Damascus, Beirut, Amman, or Riyad while poor Palestinians were left without support?


Of course you won't even attempt to discuss any of these facts because it's far easier for you to post some random tweets than admit that Arab leaders have significant culpability in this conflict.
 
The anti-semite Jeremy Corbin is a historian? Another interesting fact.

Do you deny:
- that Jews made up well over 1% of the Ottoman empire between 1850 and 1919 and that Israel is around 1% of former Ottoman land?

So they should have been given 1% of the Ottoman empire or 1% of Palestine.
 
Actually, there has never been a Palestinian state nor Palestinian people.
Why would one expect anything but the continuation of the standard hasbara crap about "a land without a people for a people without a land."
Here's one view of the origins of the term Palestinian; I stress there are many others. History existed long before Arafat.



ACADEMIA
Letters
The Origins of the term “Palestinian” (“Filasṭīnī”) in lateOttoman Palestine, 1898–1914
Emanuel Beška, Research Fellow, The Institute of Oriental Studies of the SlovakAcademy of SciencesZachary Foster, Ph.D, Near Eastern Studies, Princeton University Director of Product, Academia
Introduction
When did Arabs start to use the word Palestinian, or “Filasṭīnī” to refer to the people of Pales-tine? The question has attracted a great deal of interest among the general public. Ted Cruz,Mike Huckabee, Sheldon Adelson and Newt Gingrich have all expressed their opinions aboutthe historical usage of the word, “Palestinian.” Media brands like Arutz Sheva, Haaretz, FoxNews, AJ+, the Guardian and the Washington Post have chimed in as well, while social mediaplatforms abound with misinformation on the topic. Thus, in this paper, we explain when andin what contexts the word “Palestinian” spread in the 20th century.The word “Palestinian” gained acceptance as a description of Palestine’s Arabic speak-ers during the rst decade and a half of the 20th century. Khalīl Baydas rst used the termin 1898, followed by Salīm Qub‘ayn and Najīb Naṣṣār in 1902. Then, after the 1908 Ot-toman Constitutional Revolution eased press censorship laws, dozens of periodicals appearedin Palestine, and the term “Palestinian” exploded in usage as result. The newspapers
al-Quds
(1908–14),
al-Munādī
(1912–1913),
Filasṭīn
(1911–1914),
al-Karmal
(1908–1914) and
al- Nafīr
(1908–1914) use the term “Filasṭīnī” (in the available issues) about 170 times in morethan 110 articles from 1908–1914 (see Appendix 1). The phrases “the people of Palestine”(“ahl/ahālī Filasṭīn”) and “sons of Palestine” (“abnā’ Filasṭīn”) appeared dozens of times as
Academia Letters, July 2021
Corresponding Author:
Emanuel Beška, emanbe@gmail.com
Citation:
Beška, E., Foster, Z. (2021). The Origins of the term “Palestinian” (“Filasṭīnī”) in late OttomanPalestine, 1898–1914.
Academia Letters
, Article 1884.
https://doi.org/10.20935/AL1884
.
1
©2021 by the authors — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0
1-b14c179558.jpg
1-b14c179558.jpg


well. The “Palestinians” surfaced in articles about Zionism, migration and politics, the printmedia and the Orthodox Renaissance. The writers themselves came from a range of Muslims,Christians and Jews from Palestine, Palestinian expatriates, and Arabs from Lebanon, Egyptand elsewhere. Moreover, these newspapers circulated around the region and played a keyrole in explaining the emergence of a modern Palestinian identity.
Before the Revolution
In 1898, the Nazarene Khalīl Baydas translated
A Description of the Holy Land
from Russianto Arabic. “The Arabic geography books on the topic were insucient,” he believed, and “thepeople of Palestine needed a geography book about their country.” As Baydas explained, thebook was “a description of the land of Palestine,” referring to the people of Palestine as Pales-tinians in multiple places. “The ancient inhabitants of Palestine used limestone to whitewashthe walls of their buildings,” Baydas wrote, “while the modern Palestinians also whitewashthe inside, and occasionally the outside, of their homes with it as well.” Soon enough, though,“modern Palestinians” became simply Palestinians. “The Palestinian peasant,” Baydas notedelsewhere, “waitsimpatientlyforwintertocome, fortheseason’sraintomoistenhisfossilizedelds” after many rainless months following the May summer wheat and barley harvest. Thebook was likely taught in classrooms across the region from the late 19th century onwards,although details on its usage and circulation are unknown. By the turn of the 20th century,the Palestinian peasant was born.
1
In 1902, Salīm Qub‘ayn and Najīb Naṣṣār both published articles titled “A PalestinianDescribes Palestinian Towns” in Faraḥ Anṭūn’s
al-Jāmi‘a
, a magazine printed in Alexandria,Egypt. Qub‘ayn compared his observations of the towns Kafr Kanā and Tiberias to those of the famous French scholar Ernest Renan three decades earlier. Qub‘ayn agreed with Renanthat Tiberias was a thriving city during Biblical times but was as pitiful (circa 1902) as it wasa few decades earlier when Renan observed it. A few months later, Najīb Naṣṣār published anarticleinthesamemagazinewiththesametitle: “APalestinianDescribesPalestinianTowns.”Naṣṣār similarly compared his own observations to Ernest Renan’s, reviewing the geography,demography and current state of Wādī Mūsā. Although
al-Jāmi‘a
’s circulation gures are notavailable, similar publications attracted between 1,000–1,500 subscribers. By the early 20thcentury, a Palestinian identity was spreading.
2
1
Akim Aleksyeevich Olesnitskii, Khalīl Baydas (trans.),
Kitāb al-rawḍa al-mu’nisa  waṣf al-Arḍ al-muqaddasa
(Ba‘abdā, Lebanon: al-Maṭba‘a al-‘uthmānīya, 1898), 2.
2
Salīm Afandī Qub‘ayn, “Buldān lasṭīnīya yaṣifuhā Filasṭīnī,”
al-Jāmi‘a
3:6 (1902), 404–6; Najīb Naṣṣār,“Buldān lasṭīnīya yaṣifuhā Filasṭīnī,”
al-Jāmi‘a
3:9 (1902), 612–5; On circulation gures of similar papers,
Academia Letters, July 2021
Corresponding Author:
Emanuel Beška, emanbe@gmail.com
Citation:
Beška, E., Foster, Z. (2021). The Origins of the term “Palestinian” (“Filasṭīnī”) in late OttomanPalestine, 1898–1914.
Academia Letters
, Article 1884.
https://doi.org/10.20935/AL1884
.
2
©2021 by the authors — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0
2-62a4859925.jpg


Baydas, Qub‘ayn and Naṣṣār were the rst three Arabs in modern history to use the termPalestinian, and each of them attended the Russian Teacher’s Training Seminary in Nazarethin the late 19th century. The boarding school emphasized the Arabic language, encouragedArab dress, taught the history and geography of Palestine and took students on trips to theHoly Land’s pilgrimage sites. Young Arabs from around Palestine were taken out of theirhome, learned to take pride in their heritage and were exposed to stories and images thatmade Palestine seem real and important. No surprise that many of school’s graduates wereamong the earliest to use the term Palestinian.
3
After the Revolution
The 1908 Ottoman Constitutional Revolution brought with it press freedoms in Palestine, anddozens of Arabic periodicals appeared on the scene. The most successful papers attractedsome 1,000–1,500 subscribers, circulated once or twice a week and were sent to small townsand villages around Jerusalem, Bethlehem, Ramallah, Haifa, Jaa, Gaza, Nablus, Safed andTiberias. These gures might seem modest, but consider that some 2% of the population wasliterate in 1914, or about 12,000 people.
4
The bi-weekly
al-Quds
(“Jerusalem”), published a dozen some articles that included theword “Palestinian.”
Al-Quds
is the best preserved of all the newspapers published in Pales-tine during this period, and in the 382 extant issues, we found 12 articles mentioning theterm “Palestinians,” written by 7 authors (see appendix 1). The writers used phrases such asthe Palestinians (“al-Filasṭīnīyūn”), the Palestinian people (“al-sha‘b al-lasṭīnī”, “al-umma
al-Jinān
(Beirut, 1870–1879) boasted 1,500 subscribers. See Fruma Zachs and Sharon Halevi, “From Difa‘ al-Nisa’ to Mas’alat al-Nisa’ in Greater Syria: Readers and Writers Debate Women and Their Rights, 1858–1900,”
International Journal of Middle East Studies
41:4 (2009), 619; Yusuf al-Dibs’s bi-weekly paper,
al-Najāḥ
, printedsome 1,000 copies; See Fouad Zouki-Haklany, “Yusuf al-Dibs (1833-1907): Archeveque De Beyrouth, Historienat Homme de Culture,”
Journal of Eastern Christian Studies
61:3-4 (2009), 251.
3
See Zachary Foster,
The Invention of Palestine
(Ph.D Dissertation, Princeton University), 155–164.
4
al-Quds
(Jerusalem, 1908–1914) printed around 1,500 copies;
al-Karmal
(Haifa, 1908–1914) claimed 1,000subscribers; al-Akhbār circulated 600 copies; the Jewish paper
Ha-Ḥerut
(Jerusalem) reported 1,500–2,000subscribers. The ‘Īsā cousins’
Filasṭīn
(Jaa, 1911–1914) boasted more than 1,100 subscribers. See Ya‘qubYehoshua,
Tārīkh al-Ṣiḥāfa al-‘Arabīya  Filasṭīn l-‘Ahd al-‘Uthmani, 1908–1918
(Jerusalem: Maṭba’at al-Ma’ārif, 1974), 44; Michelle Campos,
Ottoman Brothers: Muslims, Christians, and Jews in Early Twentieth-CenturyPalestine
(Stanford, CA:StanfordUniversityPress, 2011), 282; AmiAyalon,
ReadingPalestine: Printingand Literacy, 1900–1948
(Austin: University of Texas Press, 2004), 170, n.69; Emanuel Beška,
From Ambiva-lence to Hostility: The Arabic Newspaper Filasṭīn and Zionism, 1911–1914
(Bratislava: Slovak Academic Press,2016), 18
–
23; on
al-Karmal
, see
al-Karmal
20 February 1914, 1; on the 2% literacy gure, see Yehoshua,
Tārīkhal-Ṣiḥāfa,
24 and Ayalon, “Modern Texts and their Readers in Late Ottoman Palestine,”
Middle Eastern Studies
,38:4 (2002), 17.
Academia Letters, July 2021
Corresponding Author:
Emanuel Beška, emanbe@gmail.com
Citation:
Beška, E., Foster, Z. (2021). The Origins of the term “Palestinian” (“Filasṭīnī”) in late OttomanPalestine, 1898–1914.
Academia Letters
, Article 1884.
https://doi.org/10.20935/AL1884
.
3
©2021 by the authors — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0
3-71a97f0470.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Why would one expect anything but the continuation of the standard hasbara crap about "a land without a people for a people without a land."
Here's one view of the origins of the term Palestinian; I stress there are many others. History existed long before Arafat.



ACADEMIA
Letters
The Origins of the term “Palestinian” (“Filasṭīnī”) in lateOttoman Palestine, 1898–1914
Emanuel Beška, Research Fellow, The Institute of Oriental Studies of the SlovakAcademy of SciencesZachary Foster, Ph.D, Near Eastern Studies, Princeton University Director of Product, Academia
Introduction
When did Arabs start to use the word Palestinian, or “Filasṭīnī” to refer to the people of Pales-tine? The question has attracted a great deal of interest among the general public. Ted Cruz,Mike Huckabee, Sheldon Adelson and Newt Gingrich have all expressed their opinions aboutthe historical usage of the word, “Palestinian.” Media brands like Arutz Sheva, Haaretz, FoxNews, AJ+, the Guardian and the Washington Post have chimed in as well, while social mediaplatforms abound with misinformation on the topic. Thus, in this paper, we explain when andin what contexts the word “Palestinian” spread in the 20th century.The word “Palestinian” gained acceptance as a description of Palestine’s Arabic speak-ers during the rst decade and a half of the 20th century. Khalīl Baydas rst used the termin 1898, followed by Salīm Qub‘ayn and Najīb Naṣṣār in 1902. Then, after the 1908 Ot-toman Constitutional Revolution eased press censorship laws, dozens of periodicals appearedin Palestine, and the term “Palestinian” exploded in usage as result. The newspapers
al-Quds
(1908–14),
al-Munādī
(1912–1913),
Filasṭīn
(1911–1914),
al-Karmal
(1908–1914) and
al- Nafīr
(1908–1914) use the term “Filasṭīnī” (in the available issues) about 170 times in morethan 110 articles from 1908–1914 (see Appendix 1). The phrases “the people of Palestine”(“ahl/ahālī Filasṭīn”) and “sons of Palestine” (“abnā’ Filasṭīn”) appeared dozens of times as
Academia Letters, July 2021
Corresponding Author:
Emanuel Beška, emanbe@gmail.com
Citation:
Beška, E., Foster, Z. (2021). The Origins of the term “Palestinian” (“Filasṭīnī”) in late OttomanPalestine, 1898–1914.
Academia Letters
, Article 1884.
https://doi.org/10.20935/AL1884
.
1
©2021 by the authors — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0
1-b14c179558.jpg
1-b14c179558.jpg


well. The “Palestinians” surfaced in articles about Zionism, migration and politics, the printmedia and the Orthodox Renaissance. The writers themselves came from a range of Muslims,Christians and Jews from Palestine, Palestinian expatriates, and Arabs from Lebanon, Egyptand elsewhere. Moreover, these newspapers circulated around the region and played a keyrole in explaining the emergence of a modern Palestinian identity.
Before the Revolution
In 1898, the Nazarene Khalīl Baydas translated
A Description of the Holy Land
from Russianto Arabic. “The Arabic geography books on the topic were insucient,” he believed, and “thepeople of Palestine needed a geography book about their country.” As Baydas explained, thebook was “a description of the land of Palestine,” referring to the people of Palestine as Pales-tinians in multiple places. “The ancient inhabitants of Palestine used limestone to whitewashthe walls of their buildings,” Baydas wrote, “while the modern Palestinians also whitewashthe inside, and occasionally the outside, of their homes with it as well.” Soon enough, though,“modern Palestinians” became simply Palestinians. “The Palestinian peasant,” Baydas notedelsewhere, “waitsimpatientlyforwintertocome, fortheseason’sraintomoistenhisfossilizedelds” after many rainless months following the May summer wheat and barley harvest. Thebook was likely taught in classrooms across the region from the late 19th century onwards,although details on its usage and circulation are unknown. By the turn of the 20th century,the Palestinian peasant was born.
1
In 1902, Salīm Qub‘ayn and Najīb Naṣṣār both published articles titled “A PalestinianDescribes Palestinian Towns” in Faraḥ Anṭūn’s
al-Jāmi‘a
, a magazine printed in Alexandria,Egypt. Qub‘ayn compared his observations of the towns Kafr Kanā and Tiberias to those of the famous French scholar Ernest Renan three decades earlier. Qub‘ayn agreed with Renanthat Tiberias was a thriving city during Biblical times but was as pitiful (circa 1902) as it wasa few decades earlier when Renan observed it. A few months later, Najīb Naṣṣār published anarticleinthesamemagazinewiththesametitle: “APalestinianDescribesPalestinianTowns.”Naṣṣār similarly compared his own observations to Ernest Renan’s, reviewing the geography,demography and current state of Wādī Mūsā. Although
al-Jāmi‘a
’s circulation gures are notavailable, similar publications attracted between 1,000–1,500 subscribers. By the early 20thcentury, a Palestinian identity was spreading.
2
1
Akim Aleksyeevich Olesnitskii, Khalīl Baydas (trans.),
Kitāb al-rawḍa al-mu’nisa  waṣf al-Arḍ al-muqaddasa
(Ba‘abdā, Lebanon: al-Maṭba‘a al-‘uthmānīya, 1898), 2.
2
Salīm Afandī Qub‘ayn, “Buldān lasṭīnīya yaṣifuhā Filasṭīnī,”
al-Jāmi‘a
3:6 (1902), 404–6; Najīb Naṣṣār,“Buldān lasṭīnīya yaṣifuhā Filasṭīnī,”
al-Jāmi‘a
3:9 (1902), 612–5; On circulation gures of similar papers,
Academia Letters, July 2021
Corresponding Author:
Emanuel Beška, emanbe@gmail.com
Citation:
Beška, E., Foster, Z. (2021). The Origins of the term “Palestinian” (“Filasṭīnī”) in late OttomanPalestine, 1898–1914.
Academia Letters
, Article 1884.
https://doi.org/10.20935/AL1884
.
2
©2021 by the authors — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0
2-62a4859925.jpg


Baydas, Qub‘ayn and Naṣṣār were the rst three Arabs in modern history to use the termPalestinian, and each of them attended the Russian Teacher’s Training Seminary in Nazarethin the late 19th century. The boarding school emphasized the Arabic language, encouragedArab dress, taught the history and geography of Palestine and took students on trips to theHoly Land’s pilgrimage sites. Young Arabs from around Palestine were taken out of theirhome, learned to take pride in their heritage and were exposed to stories and images thatmade Palestine seem real and important. No surprise that many of school’s graduates wereamong the earliest to use the term Palestinian.
3
After the Revolution
The 1908 Ottoman Constitutional Revolution brought with it press freedoms in Palestine, anddozens of Arabic periodicals appeared on the scene. The most successful papers attractedsome 1,000–1,500 subscribers, circulated once or twice a week and were sent to small townsand villages around Jerusalem, Bethlehem, Ramallah, Haifa, Jaa, Gaza, Nablus, Safed andTiberias. These gures might seem modest, but consider that some 2% of the population wasliterate in 1914, or about 12,000 people.
4
The bi-weekly
al-Quds
(“Jerusalem”), published a dozen some articles that included theword “Palestinian.”
Al-Quds
is the best preserved of all the newspapers published in Pales-tine during this period, and in the 382 extant issues, we found 12 articles mentioning theterm “Palestinians,” written by 7 authors (see appendix 1). The writers used phrases such asthe Palestinians (“al-Filasṭīnīyūn”), the Palestinian people (“al-sha‘b al-lasṭīnī”, “al-umma
al-Jinān
(Beirut, 1870–1879) boasted 1,500 subscribers. See Fruma Zachs and Sharon Halevi, “From Difa‘ al-Nisa’ to Mas’alat al-Nisa’ in Greater Syria: Readers and Writers Debate Women and Their Rights, 1858–1900,”
International Journal of Middle East Studies
41:4 (2009), 619; Yusuf al-Dibs’s bi-weekly paper,
al-Najāḥ
, printedsome 1,000 copies; See Fouad Zouki-Haklany, “Yusuf al-Dibs (1833-1907): Archeveque De Beyrouth, Historienat Homme de Culture,”
Journal of Eastern Christian Studies
61:3-4 (2009), 251.
3
See Zachary Foster,
The Invention of Palestine
(Ph.D Dissertation, Princeton University), 155–164.
4
al-Quds
(Jerusalem, 1908–1914) printed around 1,500 copies;
al-Karmal
(Haifa, 1908–1914) claimed 1,000subscribers; al-Akhbār circulated 600 copies; the Jewish paper
Ha-Ḥerut
(Jerusalem) reported 1,500–2,000subscribers. The ‘Īsā cousins’
Filasṭīn
(Jaa, 1911–1914) boasted more than 1,100 subscribers. See Ya‘qubYehoshua,
Tārīkh al-Ṣiḥāfa al-‘Arabīya  Filasṭīn l-‘Ahd al-‘Uthmani, 1908–1918
(Jerusalem: Maṭba’at al-Ma’ārif, 1974), 44; Michelle Campos,
Ottoman Brothers: Muslims, Christians, and Jews in Early Twentieth-CenturyPalestine
(Stanford, CA:StanfordUniversityPress, 2011), 282; AmiAyalon,
ReadingPalestine: Printingand Literacy, 1900–1948
(Austin: University of Texas Press, 2004), 170, n.69; Emanuel Beška,
From Ambiva-lence to Hostility: The Arabic Newspaper Filasṭīn and Zionism, 1911–1914
(Bratislava: Slovak Academic Press,2016), 18
–
23; on
al-Karmal
, see
al-Karmal
20 February 1914, 1; on the 2% literacy gure, see Yehoshua,
Tārīkhal-Ṣiḥāfa,
24 and Ayalon, “Modern Texts and their Readers in Late Ottoman Palestine,”
Middle Eastern Studies
,38:4 (2002), 17.
Academia Letters, July 2021
Corresponding Author:
Emanuel Beška, emanbe@gmail.com
Citation:
Beška, E., Foster, Z. (2021). The Origins of the term “Palestinian” (“Filasṭīnī”) in late OttomanPalestine, 1898–1914.
Academia Letters
, Article 1884.
https://doi.org/10.20935/AL1884
.
3
©2021 by the authors — Open Access — Distributed under CC BY 4.0
3-71a97f0470.jpg
Quite a post for a strawman. ROTFLMFAO!!! I never said "land without people ". That's the problem with Jew haters- they abandon reason when they cross the line.
 
Quite a post for a strawman. ROTFLMFAO!!! I never said "land without people ". That's the problem with Jew haters- they abandon reason when they cross the line.

That was the motto, as you know.
What you do is the same, cultural genocide, trying to claim Palestinians aren't a people so its ok to steal their land, wall them up and declare yourself the most moral army in the world.