Desantis Gets a History Lesson from a Historian

No surprise that you think the native population is responsible for starting a war...
Just because it was the Arab leaders who rejected multiple partition plans and declared war.

Oh that's right, you think so lowly of Arabs that you think they don't deserve blame for their actions.


p.s. Want to actually discuss the history or do you simply want to throw around emotionally laden buzz words.
 
Last edited:
LOL!!! The Levantine Arabs were homogenous culturally, linguistically and religiously. The West Bank Arabs didn't become "Palestinians " until Jordan lost the war in 67. ...
Not true. The Palestinian identity was prominent during the Jordanian rule of the West Bank and the PLO was at least as interested in attacking Jordanian rule as they were attacking Jewish neighbours.

I know that it's not interesting for people who like to frame everything as western colonialism but Jordan's rulers are Hashemites who were transplanted from the Hedjaz. 80% of Jordanians (was more when Jordan annexed the West Bank) had far more in common with people in the West Bank than their minority rulers.

But of course, no one wants to admit that Jordan is an ethnically Levantine population ruled over by a monarchy made up of an ethnically distinct 'elite'.

One of the greatest crimes against the Palestinian people was their brother's refusal to accept them after 1949. Almost a million Jews were chased from their Arab homes and Israel went through great economic hardship to integrate them into society. At the same time, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, and Egypt decided to lock 750,000 Palestinian refugees in camps without any rights and solely dependent on UN/Western charity. During the 20th century, there were many ethnic conflicts that involved population transfers, starting with the Greco-Turkish war to the Yugoslav break-up. As far as I'm aware, there is only one conflict where this has happened.
 
So explain why?

And explain why it matters?.... Different populations that are culturally and linguistically homogenous get to have different countries. ...
Sorry but you are arguing against yourself here. The initial argument you made was that Palestinians have a longstanding distinct ethno-cultural identity. That is true now but it wasn't true until some time in the 1950-1070 range (depending on which historian you want to listen to). The fact that you now change the argument to what constitutes the right to a county shows you've had to admit that you were wrong about the history.

But IMO, it depends on the will of the people. I've kept track of polling over the years and neither Palestinians nor Israelis trust each other enough to desire an egalitarian One State peace. That's why I (and the UN) think a Two State peace is the way forward. Decades down the road, neighbours might decide to collaborate (like the current EU) but the sides involved in this conflict aren't there yet.
 
Just because it was the Arab leaders who rejected multiple partition plans and declared war.

Why would they be happy about their British overlords deciding to give away half of their country to a foreign colonial movement?
They were understandably miffed that the Brits broke their promise to them.

Palestinian Arabs, however, believed that Great Britain had promised them independence in the Ḥusayn-McMahon correspondence, an exchange of letters from July 1915 to March 1916 between Sir Henry McMahon, British high commissioner in Egypt, and Ḥusayn ibn ʿAlī, then emir of Mecca, in which the British made certain commitments to the Arabs in return for their support against the Ottomans during the war.

Trying to rewrite history doesn't justify apartheid, basketcase.
Nothing you think happened justifies apartheid anymore than attacks on civilians are justified.

What are you going to do?
You've lost the battle for US support.

You've lost the demographic battle so now you're batshit scared of democracy.

Are you going to double down on apartheid like South Africa did?
 
But IMO, it depends on the will of the people. I've kept track of polling over the years and neither Palestinians nor Israelis trust each other enough to desire an egalitarian One State peace. That's why I (and the UN) think a Two State peace is the way forward. Decades down the road, neighbours might decide to collaborate (like the current EU) but the sides involved in this conflict aren't there yet.

True, trust is low.
But Rwanda got past genocide and I'd like to think Israelis and Palestinians can get past apartheid.

The two state solution is dead, killed by 'facts on the ground'. There isn't enough contiguous land left for a Palestinian state.
The one state apartheid solution is already in place, so the logical thing to do is sanction Israel until apartheid is ended.
 
Why would they be happy about their British overlords deciding to give away...
Again, you need to try reading a book once in a while.

An inconvenient fact for you the Sykes-Picot agreement and the Peace of Paris created a bunch of Arab states including establishing the Hashemite allies as rulers over non-Hashemite lands in Iraq, Syria, and Trans-Jordan. In fact Arab homelands were created in Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Iraq, Kuwait, and Egypt making up some 1.7 million km^2. The Peel Commission plan set aside 10,000 km^2 for a Jewish state and the UN Partition set aside 16,000 km^2.

The 1906 Ottoman census had Jews making up 1.24% of the population. The Ottoman Empire in 1913 had an area of 2.5 million km^2 (not including Egypt). 1.24% of that would mean a Jewish state of 31,000 km^2. Or do you think ottoman Jews deserve to have less than their fair share of land?


And of course you would never want to discuss the Brits/French imposing foreign rulers on Syria, Jordan, and Iraq.
 
True, trust is low.
But Rwanda got past genocide and I'd like to think Israelis and Palestinians can get past apartheid.

The two state solution is dead, killed by 'facts on the ground'. There isn't enough contiguous land left for a Palestinian state.
The one state apartheid solution is already in place, so the logical thing to do is sanction Israel until apartheid is ended.
Not as long as people like you cheer on and endorse Palestinians using ethnic violence. And nice of you to keep telling the Palestinians what's best for them.

p.s. Don't forget that Olmert offered a completely contiguous Palestinian state on the equivalent of 100% of the West bank and Gaza but because the Palestinian leadership have spent 100 years promoting ethnic hatred, Abbas just walked away without even making a counter-proposal.

1683597222624.png
1683597254778.png
1683597281445.png
 
Again, you need to try reading a book once in a while.

An inconvenient fact for you the Sykes-Picot agreement and the Peace of Paris created a bunch of Arab states including establishing the Hashemite allies as rulers over non-Hashemite lands in Iraq, Syria, and Trans-Jordan. In fact Arab homelands were created in Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Iraq, Kuwait, and Egypt making up some 1.7 million km^2. The Peel Commission plan set aside 10,000 km^2 for a Jewish state and the UN Partition set aside 16,000 km^2.

The 1906 Ottoman census had Jews making up 1.24% of the population. The Ottoman Empire in 1913 had an area of 2.5 million km^2 (not including Egypt). 1.24% of that would mean a Jewish state of 31,000 km^2. Or do you think ottoman Jews deserve to have less than their fair share of land?


And of course you would never want to discuss the Brits/French imposing foreign rulers on Syria, Jordan, and Iraq.

Of course you use the Ottoman empire as your land model.
1.24% of Palestine would have been way too little.

(though wasn't the number about 6% or so of Palestine?)
Certainly not the 50% they were given by the Brits.
 
Not as long as people like you cheer on and endorse Palestinians using ethnic violence. And nice of you to keep telling the Palestinians what's best for them.

p.s. Don't forget that Olmert offered a completely contiguous Palestinian state on the equivalent of 100% of the West bank and Gaza but because the Palestinian leadership have spent 100 years promoting ethnic hatred, Abbas just walked away without even making a counter-proposal.

View attachment 231682
View attachment 231683
View attachment 231684

Trust in Abbas and the PA is only slightly higher than trust in Netanyahu and the Israeli government, that's true.
No wonder Palestinians are supporting armed resistance again.
You and Israel are against peace talks, against peaceful demonstrations, against international law, against human rights reports, against going to the UN or ICC and against peace.

Then you turn around and act surprised that they back the only option left.

If you don't want Palestinians to use their legal right to self defence against an illegal, apartheid, occupation you need to support peaceful means.
Support BDS.
Support equal rights and going to the UN/ICC.

Stop supporting colonization and apartheid.
 
Does anyone really think that Desantis will really give a rat's shit about a history lesson, factual or otherwise???

C'mon, people: enough of these shitty news stories....they're trash.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Not true. The Palestinian identity was prominent during the Jordanian rule of the West Bank and the PLO was at least as interested in attacking Jordanian rule as they were attacking Jewish neighbours.

I know that it's not interesting for people who like to frame everything as western colonialism but Jordan's rulers are Hashemites who were transplanted from the Hedjaz. 80% of Jordanians (was more when Jordan annexed the West Bank) had far more in common with people in the West Bank than their minority rulers.

But of course, no one wants to admit that Jordan is an ethnically Levantine population ruled over by a monarchy made up of an ethnically distinct 'elite'.

One of the greatest crimes against the Palestinian people was their brother's refusal to accept them after 1949. Almost a million Jews were chased from their Arab homes and Israel went through great economic hardship to integrate them into society. At the same time, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, and Egypt decided to lock 750,000 Palestinian refugees in camps without any rights and solely dependent on UN/Western charity. During the 20th century, there were many ethnic conflicts that involved population transfers, starting with the Greco-Turkish war to the Yugoslav break-up. As far as I'm aware, there is only one conflict where this has happened.
You're splitting hair on this one. I'm stating that the Levantine Arabs were homogenous religiously, linguistically and culturally and even economically. Why? There was no artificial border in the pre WWI ME that would divide them. And that condition persisted all the way to the Six Day War, and even though there were ramblings among the Arabs of the West Bank during the Jordanian occupation, if you read the writings of the "Palestinians" of that era, they were pretty clear about their aims and ambitions. First- destroy the Jews. Then- we will see.
 
Of course you use the Ottoman empire as your land model.
...
Why not? 1.24% of Ottoman citizens were Jews. The Ottoman empire broke up into a bunch of ethno-states so why should those Jewish citizens be left out? This is especially the case when most of those Arab states used Jews being in the Palestine Mandate as an excuse to attack and chase almost a million Jews out of the lands where their families had been living for many many generations.

750,000 Arabs fled the fighting in 1949. A million Jews fled the racism from their Arab neighbours in this time. In every other ethnic conflict in the 20th century, that would have been the end of it but sadly the Arab states decided to leave their poor Palestinians locked in camps as puppets instead of doing what Canada and most other countries do and give refugees a chance to assimilate.

But understanding that would mean you'd have to accept that someone other than Jews did something bad.

I do understand your confusion though. You cant tell the difference between historical studies and histrionics.
 
You're splitting hair on this one. I'm stating that the Levantine Arabs were homogenous religiously, linguistically and culturally and even economically. Why? There was no artificial border in the pre WWI ME that would divide them. And that condition persisted all the way to the Six Day War, and even though there were ramblings among the Arabs of the West Bank during the Jordanian occupation, if you read the writings of the "Palestinians" of that era, they were pretty clear about their aims and ambitions. First- destroy the Jews. Then- we will see.
Yes, they WERE part of the Levantine pan-Arab identity up until 1950 or so but their rejection by their Arab brethren and their obsessive belief that they can eliminate Israel has created a distinct ethnic identity today.

But yeah, I could see East Bank Jordanians preferring to be part of an extended Palestinian state rather than live under continued monarchy of a minority of outsiders.
 
Trust in Abbas and the PA is only slightly higher than trust in Netanyahu and the Israeli government, that's true.
...
That's right, you've stated you preference is Hamas.

At least Abbas attended a meeting about a peace offer while your Hamas has a long history of using terrorism to derail any peace talks. The conflict is Hamas' whole raison d'etre. if the Palestinian leaders ever agreed to peace, there would be no need for a group like Hamas which is entirely focussed on using violence to eliminate the Jewish presence.

And yes, you've made clear that you oppose peace deals as that would mean Jews would continue living in the region.
 
That's right, you've stated you preference is Hamas.

At least Abbas attended a meeting about a peace offer while your Hamas has a long history of using terrorism to derail any peace talks. The conflict is Hamas' whole raison d'etre. if the Palestinian leaders ever agreed to peace, there would be no need for a group like Hamas which is entirely focussed on using violence to eliminate the Jewish presence.

And yes, you've made clear that you oppose peace deals as that would mean Jews would continue living in the region.

Let me reply to your claims.

no.

no.

no.

You're just bullshitting and posting straw man claims.
Repeatedly.

Why can't you debate honourably?
 
Let me reply to your claims.

no.

no.

no.

You're just bullshitting and posting straw man claims.
Repeatedly.

Why can't you debate honourably?
1683765183427.png

As I said, you should really try to look at some history books insteadof just making shit up that sounds good to you.
 
I know, you got your history from the occupation that banned the term 'Nabka'.
Wow your claims are stupid. But I guess since you have no interest in historical analysis that's all you got.

p.s. Were you aware that Rashid Khalidi has relatives in Toronto (you'll probably have to look up who he is - meanwhile I have a couple of his books)? Of course having come from a wealth Palestinian family, they simply moved to their other homes in Beirut and Saudi Arabia leaving poor Palestinians locked in camps. Also worth mentioning that his family also sold land to Jews out from under Arab tenant farmers.

Of course they're not white so you refuse to hold them accountable for their actions and choices.
 
Wow your claims are stupid. But I guess since you have no interest in historical analysis that's all you got.

p.s. Were you aware that Rashid Khalidi has relatives in Toronto (you'll probably have to look up who he is - meanwhile I have a couple of his books)? Of course having come from a wealth Palestinian family, they simply moved to their other homes in Beirut and Saudi Arabia leaving poor Palestinians locked in camps. Also worth mentioning that his family also sold land to Jews out from under Arab tenant farmers.

Of course they're not white so you refuse to hold them accountable for their actions and choices.

Isn't that charming?

Now you're claiming that Gaza and the refugee camps are the fault of rich Palestinian historians.
How lovely.

Is that supposed to make you look well informed, connected and sympathetic?
 
...

Now you're claiming that Gaza and the refugee camps are the fault of rich Palestinian historians.
How lovely.
...
Yes, they have part of the blame, as do the Arab leaders who launched the war and refused to give refugees any rights.

But no surprise that you refuse to actually talk about history. Is Rashid Khalidi too much of a zionist stooge for you to discuss his works?