MLB HOF

Another player who should be in the Hall of Fame; Harvey Kuenn. He had a lifetime .303 average and was involved in a blockbuster trade in the sixties, Kuenn to Cleveland for the Rock, Rocky Colavito. It didn't help either team. He bounced from Cleveland to the Giants and maintained a high average until age 31 or so. He was an eight-time All-Star. Kuenn was an under-rated and effective player who was given short shrift by the HOF selection process. Several times, he led the AL in hits and runs. After his career was over, he became a decent field manager.
 
Last edited:
Did he compare MLB owners to slave owners too?
Not sure about Carlos but I vaguely remember Curt Flood saying sometime like that when he challenged the reserve clause.

"Curt Flood, Photo by Louis Requena / MLB // The Nation urt Flood belongs in baseball’s Hall of Fame. An outstanding hitter and outfielder during the 1950s and ’60s, he sacrificed his career to challenge the control of baseball’s corporate plutocracy over players’ lives and livelihoods."
 
Although Carlos Delgado did not have the numbers that Ruth, Gehrig or Musial amassed, he did hit a total of 473 home runs. Unfortunately, this was just short of the magic 500, which would guarantee a Cooperstown bust. The fine player Fred McGriff, at 493 career homers, also shared the same boat. Carlos did manage to hit 30 home runs for 10 consecutive years, however, which was a feat that only a handful of players have done. His figures were similar to such Hall luminaries as Jeff Bagwell, Willie McCovey, Willy Stargell and more lately, Jim Thome and David Ortiz.
I believe that Carlos should be in the Hall of Fame. He was, arguably, the best Jay that ever played. It's too bad that 27 home runs will separate him from making a speech at Cooperstown, while players with similar or lesser numbers like Eddie Murray and Orlando Cepeda have made it.
Ask Vernon Wells how valuable Delgado was. He regularly hit in front of him.
 
Another player who should be in the Hall of Fame; Harvey Kuenn. He had a lifetime .303 average and was involved in a blockbuster trade in the sixties, Kuenn to Cleveland for the Rock, Rocky Colavito. It didn't help either team. He bounced from Cleveland to the Giants and maintained a high average until age 31 or so. He was an eight-time All-Star. Kuenn was an under-rated and effective player who was given short shrift by the HOF selection process. Several times, he led the AL in hits and runs. After his career was over, he became a decent field manager.
Decent player but just short of Hall of Fame consideration.
 
On an early fall evening in Toronto in 2003, specifically September 25, Carlos Delgado plastered four home runs against the Tampa Bay Rays. Yours truly did not witness this feat in person, but I do recall an even greater feat in Detroit just a few weeks before. Carlos Delgado hammered a rope line drive off the centre field upper deck and struck the advertising sign some 466 feet from home plate. This was further accentuated by the fact that the line drive was still rising. One wonders how far that home run would have traveled. Later on, Delgado, a left-handed hitter, swung late at a fast ball and powered it down the third base line. I watched it go over the fence and nail an inattentive lady in the noggin. They took her away. Always keep your eye on the ball whether you are a player or spectator.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
On an early fall evening in Toronto in 2003, specifically September 25, Carlos Delgado plastered four home runs against the Tampa Bay Rays.
Don't remind me. I went to the game the night after. Delgado went 0 for 4, and the Jays lost 2-1. High expectations and anticipation at the beginning of the game, major disappointment at the end.
 
On an early fall evening in Toronto in 2003, specifically September 25, Carlos Delgado plastered four home runs against the Tampa Bay Rays. Yours truly did not witness this feat in person, but I do recall an even greater feat in Detroit just a few weeks before. Carlos Delgado hammered a rope line drive off the centre field upper deck and struck the advertising sign some 466 feet from home plate. This was further accentuated by the fact that the line drive was still rising. One wonders how far that home run would have traveled. Later on, Delgado, a left-handed hitter, swung late at a fast ball and powered it down the third base line. I watched it go over the fence and nail an inattentive lady in the noggin. They took her away. Always keep your eye on the ball whether you are a player or spectator.

 
....and when you bet on baseball, especially as manager of a team, you are totally putting the integrity of the game at risk, as in the Black Sox. It matters not even if you never bet against your own team. You are leaving yourself open to becoming beholden to the gamblers and once you get in deep enough, they can tell you what outcome they want.

IMO, the gambling is even a greater transgression than PEDs.


There's no evidence that Shoeless Joe Jackson was part of the fix in the 1919 World Series, and his postseason numbers give no indication that he was trying to throw games:

sjj1.png

sjj ps.png

Deserves to be in: Dick Allen, Tommy John, Todd Helton, Jim Kaat
Deserves to be out: Fred McGriff, Scott Rolen
 
Don't remind me. I went to the game the night after. Delgado went 0 for 4, and the Jays lost 2-1. High expectations and anticipation at the beginning of the game, major disappointment at the end.

Carlos probably used the same bat the next night. All baseball people know that each bat only contains only so many hits, doubles and home runs. Evidently, that bat had used up its quota of hits the day before.
 
Carlos probably used the same bat the next night. All baseball people know that each bat only contains only so many hits, doubles and home runs. Evidently, that bat had used up its quota of hits the day before.
Probably wore the same underwear, too. That's an old superstition when a guy is on a roll.
 
Probably wore the same underwear, too. That's an old superstition when a guy is on a roll.

On the contrary, tml. If Carlos had worn the same underwear that he wore the day before and used a new bat, he would have continued to hit. The clubhouse manager probably washed his underwear inadvertently. Aaaargh.
During their record start of the season in 1984, when the Tigers went a phenomenal 35-5, including a Jack Morris no-hitter, Sparky Anderson wore the same underwear until they lost the next day. He wore the same unwashed underwear for 40 games. It was a good thing that he was the manager and not an active player, and early in the season, the weather was a little cooler.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: tml
"Gary Sheffield, one of the most feared sluggers in baseball for 22 years, is on the BBWAA (Baseball Writers Association of America) Hall of Fame ballot for the 8th time. For 14 years (a remarkably long time for a player’s “peak”), Sheffield posted a slash line of a.304 batting average,.411 on-base percentage, and.551 slugging percentage."
 
"Gary Sheffield, one of the most feared sluggers in baseball for 22 years, is on the BBWAA (Baseball Writers Association of America) Hall of Fame ballot for the 8th time. For 14 years (a remarkably long time for a player’s “peak”), Sheffield posted a slash line of a.304 batting average,.411 on-base percentage, and.551 slugging percentage."

I agree that Sheffield should automatically be in the Hall in light of his 509 home runs and 22 year career. He was a 9 time AllStar and hit .300 many times. In spite of his career controversies and relationship to bad boys Dwight Gooden and Darryl Strawberry, he should be in the Hall. I think that his admission to using PEDs killed his chances.
 
Of the current players in MLB, I think that Miguel Cabrera, currently toiling with the Detroit Tigers, should be a shoo-in for the Hall of Fame. His lifetime average of .310 over 19 seasons and still counting, along with 509 homers, mainly in a pitchers' park in Detroit, should be an instant Cooperstown bust and plaque. He is an eleven time All Star, two time MVP and Triple Crown winner in 2012, the first in the AL for 45 years. Also, he is an affable friendly guy with a ready smile. He has no history of PEDs, drugs or other unsavoury practices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: silentkisser
There's no evidence that Shoeless Joe Jackson was part of the fix in the 1919 World Series, and his postseason numbers give no indication that he was trying to throw games:

View attachment 123305

View attachment 123306

Deserves to be in: Dick Allen, Tommy John, Todd Helton, Jim Kaat
Deserves to be out: Fred McGriff, Scott Rolen

Jim Kaat is in the Hall of Fame.

I had a personal experience with Richie Allen. I refuse to call him Dick Allen. When he played for the Sox in the early 70s, my girlfriend and I went to the game in Detroit. My babe, being in her twenties, tall and blonde, attracted many of the players when she went over to the rail for autographs during batting practice. Richie Allen did not take practice. It was his habit to show up for the game, play it and leave just after the final out. He did not talk to journalists, fans, staff or any other warm bodies. We sat in the first row by the on-deck circle. While most of the players smiled and chatted with us, Richie just scowled and glared at us. He would never be my choice for HOF. One of his more dubious stats was that he struck out over 100 times in 10 seasons.
 
Last edited: