MLB HOF

Darts

Well-known member
Jan 15, 2017
22,944
11,295
113
Bonds and Clemens are members of the "last chance" club. Final year of eligibility.
 
Bonds and Clemens are members of the "last chance" club. Final year of eligibility.

I don’t like either of them but the HOF is meaningless if they are not elected. It’s already a sham that they haven’t been inducted to begin with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Toronto Passions
Alex Rodriguez under normal circumstances would be a shoo-in...Pete Rose too.

Rose yes, but he was banned from the hall by MLB. Bonds and Clemens are not, it's just voters who are keeping them out through some misguided vendetta. Same for A-Rod but not as asinine as the other two who had HOF careers long before the steroid scandal came to be.
If media friendly Ortiz gets in after his own steroid controversy then that tells everyone what they need to know.
 
I don’t like either of them but the HOF is meaningless if they are not elected. It’s already a sham that they haven’t been inducted to begin with.

100%

…..meanwhile Rickey Henderson and Nolan Ryan are there. because they were never caught, and they never had negative press. Clemens is an arrogant asshole, which makes them denying him so much more satisfying.

Philip.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Male4Strapon
The greatest hitter and greatest pitcher of their generation and neither is inducted because baseball writers demand purity from the inductees, yet what standards to these voters meet? How do we know if any are into kiddie porn, drive drunk, abuse their spouse or on a professional level, make up quotes from "annonymous" sources or plagerize someone else's work. It's such hypocritical bullshit.
Ortiz couldn't hold a candle to Bonds as a hitter and to either Bonds or Clemens for their impact on the game.
 
…..meanwhile Rickey Henderson and Nolan Ryan are there. because they were never caught, and they never had negative press.

I've never actually heard PED accusations for Henderson or Ryan TBH but to your point, neither Bonds nor Clemens were ever "caught" either. It's suspected and I completely believe they did but neither failed a PED test.
 
I've never actually heard PED accusations for Henderson or Ryan TBH but to your point, neither Bonds nor Clemens were ever "caught" either. It's suspected and I completely believe they did but neither failed a PED test.
I think there has been lots of evidence on Bonds and Clemens...

 
It speaks volumes that when Bonds broke Hank Aaron's home run record, it went largely unnoticed and quiet.

Aaron had a generic conglaturatory recording broadcasted on the scoreboard. Many (if not the majority) of baseball fans
still consider Aaron's record the legitimate one, not Bonds.

When Bond's contract at San Francisco ended, he was still ready and willing to play for at least 2 or 3 years.
Bonds officially filed for free agency on October 29, 2007. His agent Jeff Boris said: "I'm anticipating widespread interest from every Major League team. No team signed him in 2008 AND 2009.

In May 2015, Bonds filed a grievance against Major League Baseball through the players' union arguing that the league colluded in not signing him after the 2007 season. In August 2015, an arbitrator ruled in favor of MLB and against Bonds in his collusion case.

On December 15, 2011, Bonds was sentenced to 30 days of house arrest, two years of probation and 250 hours of community service, for an obstruction of justice conviction stemming from a grand jury appearance in 2003. He appealed, put it through the legal hoops and eventually got overturned.

The stench of the BALCO PED scandal, never left him. It never will. It's believed that Greg Anderson from BALCO, who could have given him up, would receive $2 Million from Bonds for his silence if he did two years in prison.

His arrogant sense of entitlement will always be his legacy, no matter his achievements, forever tainted by deed and word.


It's a great and good thing Bonds does not qualify for the MLB Hall of Fame. Let him be remembered for NOT getting in.
 
It speaks volumes that when Bonds broke Hank Aaron's home run record, it went largely unnoticed and quiet.

Aaron had a generic conglaturatory recording broadcasted on the scoreboard. Many (if not the majority) of baseball fans
still consider Aaron's record the legitimate one, not Bonds.

When Bond's contract at San Francisco ended, he was still ready and willing to play for at least 2 or 3 years.
Bonds officially filed for free agency on October 29, 2007. His agent Jeff Boris said: "I'm anticipating widespread interest from every Major League team. No team signed him in 2008 AND 2009.

In May 2015, Bonds filed a grievance against Major League Baseball through the players' union arguing that the league colluded in not signing him after the 2007 season. In August 2015, an arbitrator ruled in favor of MLB and against Bonds in his collusion case.

On December 15, 2011, Bonds was sentenced to 30 days of house arrest, two years of probation and 250 hours of community service, for an obstruction of justice conviction stemming from a grand jury appearance in 2003. He appealed, put it through the legal hoops and eventually got overturned.

The stench of the BALCO PED scandal, never left him. It never will. It's believed that Greg Anderson from BALCO, who could have given him up, would receive $2 Million from Bonds for his silence if he did two years in prison.

His arrogant sense of entitlement will always be his legacy, no matter his achievements, forever tainted by deed and word.


It's a great and good thing Bonds does not qualify for the MLB Hall of Fame. Let him be remembered for NOT getting in.

All valid points but not reason to exclude him from the Hall. Baseball writers should not be deciding guys don't get in just because they were assholes. Derek Jeter was almost unanimously voted in and the gap between the two was like they were playing two different sports. Jeter deserves to be a Hall of Famer but Bonds and Clemens are the easiest of selections based on their baseball performance.
Ortiz gets in first ballot despite his own steroids asterisks? This is nothing more than the voters waving their dicks around because they have the power in this case over a couple of players who never respected them. This is the baseball hall of fame, not the nice to journalists hall of fame.
I heard one broadcaster make a point today that opposing teams would often intentionally walk him with the bases loaded! They would give up one run rather than risk him driving in two or more. That's how dominant he was.
 
All valid points but not reason to exclude him from the Hall. Baseball writers should not be deciding guys don't get in just because they were assholes. Derek Jeter was almost unanimously voted in and the gap between the two was like they were playing two different sports. Jeter deserves to be a Hall of Famer but Bonds and Clemens are the easiest of selections based on their baseball performance.
Ortiz gets in first ballot despite his own steroids asterisks? This is nothing more than the voters waving their dicks around because they have the power in this case over a couple of players who never respected them. This is the baseball hall of fame, not the nice to journalists hall of fame.
I heard one broadcaster make a point today that opposing teams would often intentionally walk him with the bases loaded! They would give up one run rather than risk him driving in two or more. That's how dominant he was.

It says a lot more that no teams were willing to sign him in '08 and '09 and he had to retire that what any sports writer will say about Bonds then and now.
 
All valid points but not reason to exclude him from the Hall. Baseball writers should not be deciding guys don't get in just because they were assholes.
I believe that there is some kind of integrity/morality provision in the selection criteria. I don't think that it is strictly defined so it is up to the interpretation of each voter. And these voters are not obligated to compare behaviours with existing HOF members.

As well, these voters are human beings with feelings, likes and dislikes etc. As such if guys like Bonds and Clemens were such dickheads and pissed off enough people, then it is their prerogative to not vote for them. Once again, they are not obligated to vote for anybody.

Karma is a bitch, only if you're an asshole.
 
If you do PED's you're out of consideration for the hall. Plain and simple.

You did not compete on a level playing field with your contemporaries. You had a competitive advantage.

Your statistics are an aberration. Grossly exaggerated. You tainted the spirit of fair play.

Give me Fred McGriff, Carlos Delgado, Scott Rolen any day.......
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
If you do PED's you're out of consideration for the hall. Plain and simple.

You did not compete on a level playing field with your contemporaries. You had a competitive advantage.
Bonds and Clemens would have been HOF worthy without the PED. It is the borderline players who need PED to stay in the majors.