I'm speaking more about the extremists within the caucus, but in the end controlling the caucus is essential to controlling the Party. Yes, every leader enforces party discipline - some do it better than others. Harper had the very difficult challenge of trying to enforce discipline on a very diverse caucus. Most people expected the extremists (especially the social conservatives) to be in the ascendance within the Harper government. Remember the scare tactics of "the secret agenda." There was no secret agenda. Harper had a very clear agenda. It wasn't to outlaw abortion; it wasn't to end same sex marriage; it wasn't to be fiscally prudent. His agenda was to weaken the federal government by limiting its scope and returning power to the provinces. You could call him a "constitutionalist." To do that he needed the social conservative/extreme right with him and he handled them brilliantly. Every now and then he'd let them off their leash so to speak, and they'd get to make some outrageous statement in Parliament and everybody on the other side would latch on to it and start to cry about the "secret agenda" but then nothing would happen, so it became more and more obvious that Harper had no secret agenda and people in the centre became less and less afraid of him. End result? Majority government in 2011 after 2 minorities. Harper was a master at holding the diverse interests in the Conservative (or PC) Party together. Diefenbaker couldn't do it. Stanfield couldn't win. Clark got ousted. Mulroney won two big majorities but his time in office also gave us the Reform Party as the PC Party split apart. I was not a big fan of the man but the Conservative Party needs another Stephen Harper at the helm - someone with conservative credentials, who's politically pragmatic, who has a very clear understanding of what his agenda is and who knows how to manage a potentially contentious caucus by giving every enough room but not too much room.