MLB HOF

I thought the Boys of Summer were the guys from Brokeback Mountain...

Yankees were a juggernaut in that era.......

Even Billy Martin was a main cog hitting .333 with 5 hr's and 19 rbi's in 99 ab's against Brooklyn in 5 World series.....
 
Fate and/or bad luck derailed what could have been a great career. One just never know in this life. Just a reminder to not sweat the small stuff.
Tony Conigliaro - Wikipedia

Tony Conigliaro was hit in the head by the most useless head hunter in baseball history, Jack Hamilton, who ruined Tony's budding career with a high fast ball to the head. He also blamed Conigliaro for not even trying to get out of the way. His wild fast ball also wrecked Paul Blair's career, smashing his skull and turning a fine right-handed hitter into a part-time hitter against left-handed pitching only and late inning defensive replacement,
 

Glanville - Why I'm glad Bonds wasn't elected to the Hall of Fame


while as a fan I don’t agree, it’s a thought provoking argument from a former player.
Thanks for sharing this link.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
Bonds and Clemens were both assholes, especially to reporters.


The interesting thing about Clemens is after his career, he was super nice. I heard many interviews with him after kid was drafted into the Toronto farm system, and he spoke very highly of Toronto, both city and organization.
 
As Bob McCown said. Barry Bonds was the best juiced up player on the planet.

Roger's career was wavering after arm problems with the Red Sox. Enter a little GH and he signs with the Jays and then shazam he's rejuvenated and has several stellar years. Without the GH how would his career have panned out?


I think this is the real issue right here. While many players take them strictly to help performance, many took them to help injuries and the better performance came with it.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
The interesting thing about Clemens is after his career, he was super nice. I heard many interviews with him after kid was drafted into the Toronto farm system, and he spoke very highly of Toronto, both city and organization.

Damage control. He needed to get baseball writers (HOF voters) on his side by showing he is a great guy but was just ultra competitive during his playing days, “so if I offended anyone that was just my game face”
 
Anyone think Carlos Delgado should be in?

I do...... along with Fred McGriff. Looking at Freds career numbers, makes me say wtf?!

Philip
 
  • Like
Reactions: tml
I do...... along with Fred McGriff. Looking at Freds career numbers, makes me say wtf?!

Philip
When you consider that neither Delgado or McGriff has ever had a sniff of being mentioned with the PED guys they should definitely being considered when you take them out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tml
Anyone think Carlos Delgado should be in?

Although Carlos Delgado did not have the numbers that Ruth, Gehrig or Musial amassed, he did hit a total of 473 home runs. Unfortunately, this was just short of the magic 500, which would guarantee a Cooperstown bust. The fine player Fred McGriff, at 493 career homers, also shared the same boat. Carlos did manage to hit 30 home runs for 10 consecutive years, however, which was a feat that only a handful of players have done. His figures were similar to such Hall luminaries as Jeff Bagwell, Willie McCovey, Willy Stargell and more lately, Jim Thome and David Ortiz.
I believe that Carlos should be in the Hall of Fame. He was, arguably, the best Jay that ever played. It's too bad that 27 home runs will separate him from making a speech at Cooperstown, while players with similar or lesser numbers like Eddie Murray and Orlando Cepeda have made it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tml
Although Carlos Delgado did not have the numbers that Ruth, Gehrig or Musial amassed, he did hit a total of 473 home runs. Unfortunately, this was just short of the magic 500, which would guarantee a Cooperstown bust. The fine player Fred McGriff, at 493 career homers, also shared the same boat. Carlos did manage to hit 30 home runs for 10 consecutive years, however, which was a feat that only a handful of players have done. His figures were similar to such Hall luminaries as Jeff Bagwell, Willie McCovey, Willy Stargell and more lately, Jim Thome and David Ortiz.
I believe that Carlos should be in the Hall of Fame. He was, arguably, the best Jay that ever played. It's too bad that 27 home runs will separate him from making a speech at Cooperstown, while players with similar or lesser numbers like Eddie Murray and Orlando Cepeda have made it.

It's silly that some base it on an exact number. 500 HR or 300 W...... there's so many variables that could impact a player's ability to achieve that. Stats can't be discounted of course but the stats are just evidence to help make the case. Delgado was a player teams centered on in the pitching strategy. He was the bat opponents feared and no matter how you pitched him, he could still make you pay because he was that good. For the majority of his career he was considered among the top 10-15 hitters at worse, and definitely top 5-10 at his position.
If you asked me this morning how many HRs he has, I really had no memory if he got to 500 or not. But he definitely should be in HOF, more so IMO that Bagwell or Thome. I would say Ortiz too but I recognize that his post season success is hard to overlook.
To keep him out of the HOF because he is a few HRs shy, when there is no evidence or even suggestion that he used PED is bewildering.
 
Although Carlos Delgado did not have the numbers that Ruth, Gehrig or Musial amassed, he did hit a total of 473 home runs. Unfortunately, this was just short of the magic 500, which would guarantee a Cooperstown bust. The fine player Fred McGriff, at 493 career homers, also shared the same boat. Carlos did manage to hit 30 home runs for 10 consecutive years, however, which was a feat that only a handful of players have done. His figures were similar to such Hall luminaries as Jeff Bagwell, Willie McCovey, Willy Stargell and more lately, Jim Thome and David Ortiz.
I believe that Carlos should be in the Hall of Fame. He was, arguably, the best Jay that ever played. It's too bad that 27 home runs will separate him from making a speech at Cooperstown, while players with similar or lesser numbers like Eddie Murray and Orlando Cepeda have made it.
I don't dispute anything you've written here. Just another factor that voters probably considered when evaluating Carlos.

I forget all the details, but there was a controversy when he was with the Mets and he refused to honour the American national anthem. Maybe he didn't remove his cap or he didn't stand, I forget what. But he was protesting some political issue, maybe regarding blacks or Puerto Rico, whatever.

The point is that he took a lot of flak from many corners regarding his form of protest. You know, don't fuck with our flag, or our anthem etc. I'm sure the HoF voters all remembered and some did/would refuse to vote for him because of that. And he did it in NYC, the biggest stage, so it maximized the attention he received.