MLB HOF

If you do PED's you're out of consideration for the hall. Plain and simple.

You did not compete on a level playing field with your contemporaries. You had a competitive advantage.

Your statistics are an aberration. Grossly exaggerated. You tainted the spirit of fair play.

Give me Fred McGriff, Carlos Delgado, Scott Rolen any day.......
What the dude said. ^^^^^^

IDGAF that Roger was an asshole. In fact, I enjoyed every asshole moment that roid-ass dickhead engaged in. When he shut down the Bosox and then death-stared Dan Duquette as he stalked off the diamond, I laughed like a fucker all afternoon. He could have been twice as big an asshole and I would have loved Roger even more. But those stats aren't real. Nor are Bonds' or Sosa's.

Fair is fair.
 
Then why do them if they didn't need them?
My guess is it's an ego thing. They were already great but wanted to be even greater maybe even the greatest ever. PED or no PED not too many (none?) players hit 762 HR's.

"On the official website of Major League Baseball, he is immortalized as owner of the sport’s most cherished record, atop the all-time home run list: Barry Bonds, 762. There is no asterisk by his name, even though steroids enhanced his performance enough for him to squeak past the revered Hank Aaron, who hit 755 home runs."
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
If you do PED's you're out of consideration for the hall. Plain and simple.

You did not compete on a level playing field with your contemporaries. You had a competitive advantage.

Your statistics are an aberration. Grossly exaggerated. You tainted the spirit of fair play.

Give me Fred McGriff, Carlos Delgado, Scott Rolen any day.......
How did Ortiz get in despite testing positive? Faulty logic by some of ya’ll he got in over manny Ramirez.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Male4Strapon
Bonds being around clubhouses as a child knew how the media operates. He and Clemens did themselves no favours by giving them dust their entire careers. You’re telling me Ortiz who’s on record for taking roids gets in cause he was a nice guy?

do y’all know certain players use TUE’s to circumvent the rules and use peds? I bet they’re getting or how about all the guys who went under the radar? This stuff is a joke.
 
If you do PED's you're out of consideration for the hall. Plain and simple.

You did not compete on a level playing field with your contemporaries. You had a competitive advantage.

Your statistics are an aberration. Grossly exaggerated. You tainted the spirit of fair play.

Give me Fred McGriff, Carlos Delgado, Scott Rolen any day.......

but Ortiz got in
 
My guess is it's an ego thing. They were already great but wanted to be even greater maybe even the greatest ever. PED or no PED not too many (none?) players hit 762 HR's.

"On the official website of Major League Baseball, he is immortalized as owner of the sport’s most cherished record, atop the all-time home run list: Barry Bonds, 762. There is no asterisk by his name, even though steroids enhanced his performance enough for him to squeak past the revered Hank Aaron, who hit 755 home runs."

As Bob McCown said. Barry Bonds was the best juiced up player on the planet.

Roger's career was wavering after arm problems with the Red Sox. Enter a little GH and he signs with the Jays and then shazam he's rejuvenated and has several stellar years. Without the GH how would his career have panned out?
 
If you do PED's you're out of consideration for the hall. Plain and simple.

You did not compete on a level playing field with your contemporaries. You had a competitive advantage.

Your statistics are an aberration. Grossly exaggerated. You tainted the spirit of fair play.

Give me Fred McGriff, Carlos Delgado, Scott Rolen any day.......
....and when you bet on baseball, especially as manager of a team, you are totally putting the integrity of the game at risk, as in the Black Sox. It matters not even if you never bet against your own team. You are leaving yourself open to becoming beholden to the gamblers and once you get in deep enough, they can tell you what outcome they want.

IMO, the gambling is even a greater transgression than PEDs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Male4Strapon
I heard today that when Ortiz tested positive, it was not yet illegal under the rules of baseball. Once the rules changed, he never tested positive.

his positive test was never actually announced by baseball, it leaked from the Mitchell Report, so technically he was never caught using but neither were Bonds or Clemens.
Jeff Bagwell, Mike Piazza and Ivan Rodriguez were all suspected to be users and each were inducted.
The HOF should be based on merit, not based on grudges and not on suspicion no matter how much evidence there is outside the game. If a player tested positive and was suspended by MLB then fine, he was caught cheating by the authority that matters as far as his career is concerned. But if MLB doesn’t officially recognize him as a known cheater then the writers have no business declaring themselves the Gods of the sanctity of the hall.
OJ Simpson was a media darling and look how that turned out.
 
As Bob McCown said. Barry Bonds was the best juiced up player on the planet.

Roger's career was wavering after arm problems with the Red Sox. Enter a little GH and he signs with the Jays and then shazam he's rejuvenated and has several stellar years. Without the GH how would his career have panned out?

if we accept the steroid timeline as being post strike in ‘94, both were already on a HOF trajectory.
I forget the name of the book about Bonds and Balco but that pointed to jealousy from Bonds towards McGwire and Sosa that they got all the adoration when they weren’t anywhere near his level. His ego made him want to show that he was the superior player if put on a level playing field with them. Irony aside, he was right.
As for Clemens, he could have retired rather than joined the Jays and would have been a first ballot hall of famer. He was the most dominant pitcher of his generation. His surliness notwithstanding, the writers would have had no excuse to keep him out. Suspected steroid use gave writers an excuse to get revenge on these guys who they didn’t like.
 
I heard today that when Ortiz tested positive, it was not yet illegal under the rules of baseball. Once the rules changed, he never tested positive.

This is true but you know he never had a legal prescription for said compounds did he?

I say this because some individuals will state that what he was doing wasn't against the rules in baseball.
 
I've never actually heard PED accusations for Henderson or Ryan TBH but to your point, neither Bonds nor Clemens were ever "caught" either. It's suspected and I completely believe they did but neither failed a PED test.

When it comes to Rickey Henderson, I’m just judging him on longevity and his astronomical base stealing numbers and power. Plus he played on a late 80’s bash brother A’s

Nolan Ryan on the other hand, presents a pretty interesting story. Aside from his longevity and velocity, Tom House his pitching coach openly admits to trying to tackle and understand the science of PED‘s how it applied to pitching. Plus he himself was caught during his playing days. They also had quite a business relationship, and they even published books together.

But aside from all of this, what I posted is completely speculative on my end.

Philip
 
....and when you bet on baseball, especially as manager of a team, you are totally putting the integrity of the game at risk, as in the Black Sox. It matters not even if you never bet against your own team. You are leaving yourself open to becoming beholden to the gamblers and once you get in deep enough, they can tell you what outcome they want.

IMO, the gambling is even a greater transgression than PEDs.

No argument from here......
 
Bonds played in only 49 playoff games in 22 fucking years. He was a shitty teammate and an asshole. He made his team's worse.
Guy had 9 homers and batted .245 in those games. Nobody choked like him when he was on the Pirates. He would have been a great Leaf if he played hockey.

With the pressure on, Ortiz was money.
 
Bonds played in only 49 playoff games in 22 fucking years. He was a shitty teammate and an asshole. He made his team's worse.
Guy had 9 homers and batted .245 in those games. Nobody choked like him when he was on the Pirates. He would have been a great Leaf if he played hockey.

With the pressure on, Ortiz was money.

Agreed 100%.......Of course he was clean when he was with the Pirates as well.....
 
Glad to see that former Dodger great Gil Hodges will also be inducted into the HOF this year. He was a member of the famed Boys of Summer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle