Is Carey Price

Even without a Stanley Cup, Carey Price is one of the best Montreal has ever had"
With Montreal Canadiens goaltenders I'd put him behind Patrick Roy, Jacques Plante, Ken Dryden and Bill Durnan.
 
With Montreal Canadiens goaltenders I'd put him behind Patrick Roy, Jacques Plante, Ken Dryden and Bill Durnan.
And for sure behind Georges Vezina and possibly George Hainsworth.

Vezina:
Joseph Georges Gonzague Vézina After being signed by the Canadiens in 1910, Vézina played in 327 consecutive regular season games and a further 39 playoff games, before leaving early during a game in 1925 due to illness.

The only goaltender to play for the Canadiens between 1910 and 1925, Vézina helped the team win the Stanley Cup in 1916 and 1924, while reaching the Stanley Cup Finals three more times. When the Hockey Hall of Fame opened in 1945, Vézina was one of the original nine inductees, and in 2017 the NHL included him on their list of the 100 greatest players in league history.

Hainsworth:
winning the Vezina Trophy for the 1926–27, 1927–28 and 1928–29 NHL seasons. In 1928–29, he set an all-time record with 22 shutouts and a 0.92 goals against average while playing all 44 games.[4] In 1930 he set an NHL record that still stands, going 270 minutes and 8 seconds without allowing a goal during the playoffs for the Canadiens. He backstopped the Canadiens to back to back Stanley Cups in 1930 and 1931. Hainsworth served as the Canadiens' captain during 1932–33, becoming the second of only eight goalies to serve as an NHL team's captain.
 
Even without a Stanley Cup, Carey Price is one of the best Montreal has ever had"
Regardless of where he stands in the pantheon of Montreal hockey, the discussion is how he compares to the best goalies he competed against. As such this article is not germane to the discussion.

BTW, Joe Namath is one of the best QB's to ever play for the Jets.
 
Last edited:
Regardless of where he stands in the pantheon of Montreal hockey, the discussion is how he compares to the best goalies he competed against. As such this article is not germane to the discussion.

Can you use your own words or analyze the stats besides referring to his contract? On what basis did you start this thread?
I think he may be overrated and definitely over paid...but he’s been as good as any goalie he’s had to compete against, he has been hampered by weak teams.
How would have Rask done in Montreal...how would have Price done in Chicago...
 
I think he may be overrated and definitely over paid...but he’s been as good as any goalie he’s had to compete against, he has been hampered by weak teams.
How would have Rask done in Montreal...how would have Price done in Chicago...
How would Brady and Peyton done if they'd switched organizations? Impossible to answer.
 
Nobody has brought up Vachon yet as well.

He did along with the Gumper win a Vezina in 68 I believe.

And there was also Theordore for a short time also.
 
Nobody has brought up Vachon yet as well.

He did along with the Gumper win a Vezina in 68 I believe.

And there was also Theordore for a short time also.
...and Steve Penney.

Who are we kidding, everybody that’s played for Montreal has been great...they all belong in the Hall of Fame.
 
He had a future hall of famer defenseman in front of him every night to help him out.
Wild guess. Was that D man Denis Potvin? I vaguely remember Larocque. I think he passed way too young at around age 40.

The value of a goalie to his team can only be partially measured in stats. For example, Patrick "Saint Patrick" Roy had a 2.78 GAA and a .904 SV% .
(Price is 2.49 and .917.) I think Roy is generally considered better than Price.
 
The best playoff goalie the Scabs have had in the last 20 years was Jaroslav Halak,

Yes. Imagine keeping Halak and trading Price for 2-3 great player. That would have made the Habs a much better team in the last 5 years! Initially I was one who though it was best to keep Price and trade Halak but now I realize how wrong I was I am sure Bergevin thinks the same.
 
Yes. Imagine keeping Halak and trading Price for 2-3 great player. That would have made the Habs a much better team in the last 5 years! Initially I was one who though it was best to keep Price and trade Halak but now I realize how wrong I was I am sure Bergevin thinks the same.

Yeah Lars Eller while a competent NHL'er didn't really work out the way they thought he would.

I do remember that 4 goal game had however and he does have a cup.
 
Yeah Lars Eller while a competent NHL'er didn't really work out the way they thought he would.

I do remember that 4 goal game had however and he does have a cup.

Price would hAve been trade for much better player then Eller!!!!