Is Carey Price

You can stop saying Marner sucks now since you'll be contradicting yourself.
I never said Marner sucks. Those are your words. You are free to think Marner is worth $11mm or more. Why don't you start your own thread about how Marner is the best player of his generation?



 
I'm not going to knock any other goalie but this article says it all.

 
I'm not going to knock any other goalie but this article says it all.

When I seen written "THE PITTSBURGH PENGUINS ARE AFRAID OF CAREY PRICE"' I stopped reading.
 
All good goalies but there is a reason why Price is the most highly paid.
Carey Price's contract when signed was 14% of the cap.
Henrik Lundqvist's contract when signed was 13.67% of the cap.

00.33% difference.
 
Dart is not good with math. Among many other things.
 
The question isn't whether price is overpaid or not? The question is is he the best goaltender of his generation (not greatest of all time)?

A member suggested that Lundqvist, Rinne and/or Rask might be the best of this generation. If so, I would like to see links to credible sources that support this suggestion.
 
The question isn't whether price is overpaid or not? The question is is he the best goaltender of his generation (not greatest of all time)?

A member suggested that Lundqvist, Rinne and/or Rask might be the best of this generation. If so, I would like to see links to credible sources that support this suggestion.
Price might be, but it’s been an average era for superstar goalies...comparing career stats, Lundqvist compares closely.

Price had a great year in 14-15, take that year away and he’s comparable to several.
 
The question isn't whether price is overpaid or not? The question is is he the best goaltender of his generation (not greatest of all time)?

A member suggested that Lundqvist, Rinne and/or Rask might be the best of this generation. If so, I would like to see links to credible sources that support this suggestion.
Here are credible stats that should be easy to analyze. BTW, I have a name and it is shorter to type than "member", which you keep using. LOL.
Price: 2.49GAA, .573 winning percentage, .917 save%, 1 shutout/14.0 games
Lundqvist: 2.43GAA, .586 winning percentage, .918 save%, 1 shutout/13.5 games
Rinne: 2.42GAA, .625 winning percentage, .917 save%, 1 shutout/10.2 games
Rask: 2.26GAA, .630 winning percentage, .922 save%, 1 shutout/10.9 games

Of the 4, Price is last in GAA.
Of the 4, Price is last in win percentage.
Of the 4, Price is tied for last in save percentage.
Of the 4, Price is last in shutout percentage.

In most of the stats he is way behind. The only one where he hangs tough is in save percentage.

They each have 1 Vezina.
Only 1 Cup between the 4 of them. Rask as a backup to Tim Thomas.
Rask, Lundqvist and Rinne each have at year end 1 1st team All Star and 1 2nd team All Star. Price has 1 1st team and 0 2nd team.
Price does have the one Hart trophy.

Unless I am missing some very important stats in which he excelled above the others, it would take an extremely compelling argument to convince any objective fan that Price is the best of the lot. IMO, as FFA alluded to, he is living off the reputation of that one amazing year. Take that out and he's had a good to very career, but not much more.

Darts, do you consider yourself objective. Personally, I have no horses in this race.
 
Last edited:
Here are credible stats that should be easy to analyze.

Of the 4, Price is last in GAA.
Of the 4, Price is last in win percentage.
Of the 4, Price is tied for last in save percentage.
Of the 4, Price is last in shutout percentage.

In most of the stats he is way behind. The only one where he hangs tough is in save percentage.

Unless I am missing some very important stats in which he excelled above the others, it would take an extremely compelling argument to convince any objective fan that Price is the best of the lot. Darts, do you consider yourself objective. Personally, I have no horses in that race.
A lot of those stats reflect how good the team is, nothing against Rask but his team is a contender every year.
 
Here are credible stats that should be easy to analyze. BTW, I have a name and it is shorter to type than "member", which you keep using. LOL.


Of the 4, Price is last in GAA.
Of the 4, Price is last in win percentage.
Of the 4, Price is tied for last in save percentage.
Of the 4, Price is last in shutout percentage.

In most of the stats he is way behind. The only one where he hangs tough is in save percentage.

They each have 1 Vezina.
Only 1 Cup between the 4 of them. Rask as a backup to Tim Thomas.
Rask, Lundqvist and Rinne each have at year end 1 1st team All Star and 1 2nd team All Star. Price has 1 1st team and 0 2nd team.
Price does have the one Hart trophy.

Unless I am missing some very important stats in which he excelled above the others, it would take an extremely compelling argument to convince any objective fan that Price is the best of the lot. IMO, as FFA alluded to, he is living off the reputation of that one amazing year. Take that out and he's had a good to very career, but not much more.

Darts, do you consider yourself objective. Personally, I have no horses in this race.
A lot of those stats reflect how good the team is, nothing against Rask but his team is a contender every year.

Eddy all the teams playing in front of those goalies had vastly better defenses I think.

So there might an argument for Price there.

I'm sure there is some sort of analytics out there to properly evaluate goaltending alone.

I'll leave to the stats wizards on here to find it.

Personally I've always like Rask. One of the Leafs worst trades I would say.......
 
Eddy all the teams playing in front of those goalies had vastly better defenses I think.

So there might an argument for Price there.

I'm sure there is some sort of analytics out there to properly evaluate goaltending alone.

I'll leave to the stats wizards on here to find it.

Personally I've always like Rask. One of the Leafs worst trades I would say.......
So there might be an argument for Price there.
 
Eddy all the teams playing in front of those goalies had vastly better defenses I think.

So there might an argument for Price there.

I'm sure there is some sort of analytics out there to properly evaluate goaltending alone.

I'll leave to the stats wizards on here to find it.
It's hard to evaluate.

Does the defence make a goalie's stats better or does a good goalie make the defence look better?
 
The only argument Dart has is the player with the higher salary is better
Darts' is a huge Habs fan and is extremely biased. So many of his hockey posts glamorize and refer to only Montreal players, like Steve Shutt.

I doubt if he will find a source, credible or otherwise, who has written a dissertation comparing those 4 goalies, seeing as none of them are all-time greats. (I'd say than Henrik has the most impressive legacy.) He's hoping to find one so that he himself does not have to come with a credible analysis to defend his theory.