Is Carey Price

Surprised no one mentioned Martin Brodeur. Most wins, most shutouts, 2 Olympic Gold Medals, eight 40-win seasons, four time Vezina, five Jennings, three Stanley Cups, ten time All Star, Rookie of the Year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Archer2012
Surprised no one mentioned Martin Brodeur. Most wins, most shutouts, 2 Olympic Gold Medals, eight 40-win seasons, four time Vezina, five Jennings, three Stanley Cups, ten time All Star, Rookie of the Year.
Isn't Martin from the previous generation of goalies?
 
Hasek. The Gumby style. He thought of things no one else thought of before. Behind the back opposite arm stop.
Andrei Vasilevskiy incorporates that into his game as well now.

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Archer2012
Vasilevskiy behind-the-back save

 
I think Henrik Lundqvist is in that same conversation


Tuukka Rask as well

And you could add Pekka Rinne to that list. Those 3 all clearly have better career stats than Price.

Price: 2.49GAA, .573 winning percentage, .917 save%, 1 shutout/14.0 games
Lundqvist: 2.43GAA, .586 winning percentage, .918 save%, 1 shutout/13.5 games
Rinne: 2.42GAA, .625 winning percentage, .917 save%, 1 shutout/10.2 games
Rask: 2.26GAA, .630 winning percentage, .922 save%, 1 shutout/10.9 games

I will concede that he is the best goalie to have played for Montreal in the last 15 years. I don't think that he has had an HOF career/stats, especially with no cup wins. Although the NHL does have low standards for HOF.

Dryden is much better known for having played with Cornell, becoming one of the first players to come to the NHL from a US college program. They retired his number.

Rather than play for the Canadiens in 1964, Dryden pursued a Bachelor of Arts degree in History at Cornell University, where he also played hockey until his graduation in 1969. He backstopped the Cornell Big Red to the 1967 National Collegiate Athletic Association championship and to three consecutive ECAC tournament championships, and won 76 of his 81 varsity starts. At Cornell, he was a member of the Quill and Dagger society.[8] He also was a member of the Canadian amateur national team at the 1969 World Ice Hockey Championships tournament in Stockholm.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
Isn't Martin from the previous generation of goalies?
They have eight seasons of concurrency in the league. Guess it depends on where/how you're defining 'a generation' and generational boundaries.
 
They have eight seasons of concurrency in the league. Guess it depends on where/how you're defining 'a generation' and generational boundaries.
Martin Brodeur's Calder season was about 14 seasons before Carey Price's first season...
 
LOL! Way before my time but I heard that Johnny "The China Wall" Bower was pretty good as well.

I heard that Terry Sawchuk was even better and won the last two games for the Leafs against the Habs in 1967.

Carey Price's goaltending fundamentals are rock solid but he's had some very crappy teams in front of him. If he had pulled a Roy he would have won at least two Stanley Cups by now.
 
From what I've read Bower and Sawchuk were polar opposites, Sawchuk was five years younger. Bower was a model citizen while Sawchuk was a mean sob. I've been meaning to read Sawchuk's biography, he was a troubled man who drank too much and had a violent temper.

Montreal fought back to even the series at 2-2 in 1967. In games 3 and 4, Bower was beginning to show his 42 years. Sawchuk replaced him, the Leafs were outshot but Sawchuk stoned the Habs to just two goals in two games.

 
I heard that Terry Sawchuk was even better and won the last two games for the Leafs against the Habs in 1967.

Carey Price's goaltending fundamentals are rock solid but he's had some very crappy teams in front of him. If he had pulled a Roy he would have won at least two Stanley Cups by now.
A cap hit of $10.5 million a season for six more seasons make's Carey Price close to untradeable.
 
A cap hit of $10.5 million a season for six more seasons make's Carey Price close to untradeable.

They used to say that about Luongo in Vancouver. Still he was able to be traded back to where he wanted, Florida.

I would have been great if we had found a way to trade him to Vancouver or some west coast team (where he really want's to be).
 
They used to say that about Luongo in Vancouver. Still he was able to be traded back to where he wanted, Florida.

I would have been great if we had found a way to trade him to Vancouver or some west coast team (where he really want's to be).
It's possible...
 
Mr. Price isn't going anywhere unless he wants to leave.
 
Sawchuk was a mean sob. I've been meaning to read Sawchuk's biography, he was a troubled man who drank too much and had a violent tempe
I saw this film when it first aired last year.

"Goalie
'Goalie' is set to open March 1 in Toronto and Vancouver
A biopic tracing the brutal life and extraordinary career of goaltender Terry Sawchuk is hitting the big screen in March.Jan 15, 2019"
 
Carey Price's goaltending fundamentals are rock solid but he's had some very crappy teams in front of him. If he had pulled a Roy he would have won at least two Stanley Cups by now.
Carey Price played on some poor Montreal teams. Roy played on some good Montreal teams that he made great. Dryden had the good fortune to play on some of the greatest Montreal teams ever.
 
It wouldn't surprise me if he wanted to go play with a contender but his contract makes it tough to move.

Me neither. I think the decision are actually made by Mrs Price ;) And Angela Price is from the west coast. I would not be surprised to see Price go play for Seattle.
 
Me neither. I think the decision are actually made by Mrs Price ;) And Angela Price is from the west coast. I would not be surprised to see Price go play for Seattle.
I'd be surprised at that...I was thinking a contending team that need's a goalie with some cap space.