All Time Blue Jays Team

Nobody mentioned Dave Winfield either. was only with them for a year but a hall of famer, same with Rickey Henderson.
 
That's because he killed a seagull in Toronto and instantly became persona non grata in this town! :yell:

Perry

Except when driving in the World Series winning RBI.

Actually, his career with the Jays was one season as DH. He didn't need to kill the gull to not be considered. Great career. Not an all-time great Jay.
 
Played really well for us in NY despite what Geoge said. Had that really tough WS. He hit a lot a line outs as I recall.

He was out the season entire 89 with a neck problem.


Your recall wrong. He wasn't bad but wasn't great. Went 5 for 22 with two walks. Had a hit in every game except game 4 and the most important hit of the series.
 
. Not an all-time great Jay.


yeah that's kind of why he didn't make my list. In fact, if I had to choose I go with Paul Molitor but that's why I only gave Molitor honorable mention because it was only one season but it was a great one. Finished second in batting average to Johnny O with a WS MVP to top it off.
 
Last edited:
Catcher: Ernie Whitt
First Base: Carlos Delgado
2nd Base: Roberto Alomar
Short Stop: Tony Fernandez
3rd Base: Josh Donaldson
Left Field: Joe Carter
Centre Field: Devon White
Right Field: Jose Bautista

DH: Edwin Encarnacion

Pitching Rotation:

Dave Stieb
Roy Halladay
Jimmy Key
Roger Clemens
Pat Hengten


Long Relief: Duane Ward
Closer: Tom Henke

Not much argument from me there. Perhaps you could make the argument for Vernon Wells in CF as opposed to Devon White. Mostly due to longevity and overall production. He has 6 points more on his WAR than White. But Whtie has 5 GG and 2 WS rings under his belt as a Blue Jay.
 
Not much argument from me there. Perhaps you could make the argument for Vernon Wells in CF as opposed to Devon White. Mostly due to longevity and overall production. He has 6 points more on his WAR than White. But Whtie has 5 GG and 2 WS rings under his belt as a Blue Jay.

i don't know how you can put Whitt in front of Darrin Fletcher. No comparison in the numbers.
 
Your recall wrong. He wasn't bad but wasn't great. Went 5 for 22 with two walks. Had a hit in every game except game 4 and the most important hit of the series.

My recall is fine. You misread my post. Hint.....I'm a Yankee fan.
 
Thought that was odd in your post. Then I told myself you probably referencing some series he had that year as a Jay.

In the 81 WS with The Yanks he went 1-22.....that's just awful. That's what I was referring to.

Steinbrenner starting calling him Mr. May,lol