Greatest Blue Jays

Dec 22, 2010
5,313
9
0
Greatest Blue Jays by position: must be good defensively and have great offensive numbers

1St Base- Carlos Delgados

2nd base- Roberto Alomar

3rd Base-Josh Donaldson

Short stop- Tony Fernandez (awesome to see him run to his right to snare ball and throw to the left)

Catcher-Russ Martin

DH-Edwin Encarnacion

Outfielders-Jose Bautista, Devon White and Jessie Barfield

Starting Pitchers-Dave Stieb, Roger Clemens, Roy Halladay, David Price and Lefty Jimmy Key

Middle relief pitcher- Duane Ward

Closer- Tom "The Terminator" Henke


To be honest, after the 93 world series win , I really wasn't following the Jays up until 2013, so I may have missed some great players in the years between.
 
Last edited:
Need a couple of more OF.
I always liked Bell ahead of Moseby and Barfield. Even though he did DH near the end.
As for the 3rd OF, maybe Shawn Green? I never much liked Vernon Wells. He had big numbers when Delgado was protecting him, but when CD was let go, VW tanked.
 
Greatest Blue Jays by position: must be good defensively and have great offensive numbers

1St Base- Carlos Delgados

2nd base- Roberto Alomar

3rd Base-Josh Donaldson

Short stop- Tony Fernandez

Catcher-Russ Martin

Outfielder-Jose Bautista

Pitcher-Dave Stieb


To be honest, after the 93 world series win , I really wasn't following the Jays up until 2013, so I may have missed some great players in the years between.

Greatest Blue Jays.....how do you mean, great while Blue Jays, or greatest players to wear Blue Jays uniforms as players?
 
Roy Halladay for pitcher......add Bell and Carter to the outfield and Encarnacion as dh and you got quite a team.

add Price, Cone, Stieb, and one other to the starting rotation (Smith?)....Henke Ward and Osuna in the bullpen...with Cecil and Ryan as lefties...quite a team
 
batting order

Alomar, Donaldson, Bautista, Delgado, Encarnacion, Bell, Carter, Fernandez, Martin
 
Greatest Blue Jays by position: must be good defensively and have great offensive numbers

1St Base- Carlos Delgados

2nd base- Roberto Alomar

3rd Base-Josh Donaldson

Short stop- Tony Fernandez

Catcher-Russ Martin

Outfielder-Jose Bautista

Pitcher-Dave Stieb


To be honest, after the 93 world series win , I really wasn't following the Jays up until 2013, so I may have missed some great players in the years between.
I've done this on my own.

I agree with everyone on your list, but I picked 3 outfielders, 3 starting pitchers (two righties and a lefty), a closer and a DH.

OF is Bautista, Bell and Devon White. Carter and Barfield could not play as good defense as Bautista and could not run the bases as well either. Devo was an all-time great defensive CF, had some pop and was fast on the bases.

Starters are Stieb, Halladay and Key. I was going for one lefty and one righty but it was impossible to choose between Roy and Stieb, both excellent and durable. Key is the lefty.

Closer is Henke and DH is Molitor.
 
Roy Halladay for pitcher......add Bell and Carter to the outfield and Encarnacion as dh and you got quite a team.

add Price, Cone, Stieb, and one other to the starting rotation (Smith?)....Henke Ward and Osuna in the bullpen...with Cecil and Ryan as lefties...quite a team

Roger Clemens should be in that starting rotation.
 
Alomar is the only one in the HOL. Who will be the next Jay HOFer?

What is the HOL?

If you meant Hall of Fame, I believe 6 HoF'ers have represented the club or worn the Blue Jays uniform.

Phil Niekro
Roberto Alomar
Paul Molitor
Pat Gillick
Dave Winfield
Rickey Henderson

Tom Cheek has been honoured with the Ford C. Frick Award

There are a few others who have been Blue Jays who will be, or should be in the Hall.
 
If you are going to include players that have been with Toronto for one year then you are basing it on peak value. And the pitcher then had to be Roger Clemens.
 
Roy Halladay for pitcher......add Bell and Carter to the outfield and Encarnacion as dh and you got quite a team.

add Price, Cone, Stieb, and one other to the starting rotation (Smith?)....Henke Ward and Osuna in the bullpen...with Cecil and Ryan as lefties...quite a team

I am missing 4 other starters, 2 other OFs, a middle relief , a closer and a DH, it was early morning when I started thread, lol

4 other starting pitchers:Roger Clemens, Roy Halladay, David Price and lefty Jimmy Key

2 other outfielders: Devon White and Jessie Barfield (No George Bell, he was a defensive liability)

Middle Relief- Duane Ward

Closer- Tom Henke

DH- Edwin Encartnacion
 
Last edited:
Roy Halladay for pitcher......add Bell and Carter to the outfield and Encarnacion as dh and you got quite a team.

add Price, Cone, Stieb, and one other to the starting rotation (Smith?)....Henke Ward and Osuna in the bullpen...with Cecil and Ryan as lefties...quite a team

batting order

Alomar, Donaldson, Bautista, Delgado, Encarnacion, Bell, Carter, Fernandez, Martin


Now you're talking!
 
If Carlos Delgado makes it the HOF, I hope he goes in as a Blue Jay and not pull an "Andre Dawson".
 
If Carlos Delgado makes it the HOF, I hope he goes in as a Blue Jay and not pull an "Andre Dawson".

What did Dawson do? He is one of 2 players in the HOF wearing the Expo hat. He had very good reasons for being upset with team ownership.
 
What did Dawson do? He is one of 2 players in the HOF wearing the Expo hat.
Andre wanted to go into the HOF as a Chicago Cub (better endorsement potential) but was declined. (Gary Carter, R.I.P., wanted to go into the HOF as a New York Met.)

BTW: I was comparing Joe Carter's stats with those of Jim Rice. Home runs and RBI's are virtually identical but Jim has a .298 BA whereas Joe is at .259.
 
If The hall of fame voters get their collective heads out of their asses, Tim Raines will openly want to go in as an Expo.
 
Dave Parker played for the Jays. Same situation as Barney acquired after the trade deadline can't play in the post season. Roger Clemens played for the Jays was pretty great.