All Time Blue Jays Team

unassuming

Well-known member
Feb 11, 2017
14,238
5,463
113
Catcher: Ernie Whitt
First Base: Carlos Delgado
2nd Base: Roberto Alomar
Short Stop: Tony Fernandez
3rd Base: Josh Donaldson
Left Field: Joe Carter
Centre Field: Devon White
Right Field: Jose Bautista

DH: Edwin Encarnacion

Pitching Rotation:

Dave Stieb
Roy Halladay
Jimmy Key
Roger Clemens
Pat Hengten


Long Relief: Duane Ward
Closer: Tom Henke
 
Catcher: Ernie Whitt
First Base: Carlos Delgado
2nd Base: Roberto Alomar
Short Stop: Tony Fernandez
3rd Base: Josh Donaldson
Left Field: George Bell
Centre Field: Devon White
Right Field: Jose Bautista

DH: Edwin Encarnacion

Pitching Rotation:

Dave Stieb
Roy Halladay
Jimmy Key
Roger Clemens
Pat Hengten


Long Relief: Duane Ward
Closer: Tom Henke

I don't think anyone could argue with the team you've assembled.
 
Catcher: Ernie Whitt
First Base: Carlos Delgado
2nd Base: Roberto Alomar
Short Stop: Tony Fernandez
3rd Base: Josh Donaldson
Left Field: George Bell
Centre Field: Devon White
Right Field: Jose Bautista

DH: Edwin Encarnacion

Pitching Rotation:

Dave Stieb
Roy Halladay
Jimmy Key
Roger Clemens
Pat Hengten


Long Relief: Duane Ward
Closer: Tom Henke

Pretty bang on to my team.

Fuck Clemens. He only played 2 years and was a cheat.
I'd replace him with Jim Clancy. Nothing fancy but solid and reliable. He played for some terrible Jays teams right after expansion and was here for 12 years.
Whitt had longevity but I'd take Russell Martin over him.
 
Fuck Clemens. He only played 2 years and was a cheat.
I'd replace him with Jim Clancy. Nothing fancy but solid and reliable. He played for some terrible Jays teams right after expansion and was here for 12 years.
Whitt had longevity but I'd take Russell Martin over him.


I hear what your saying, but who knows how many of them were cheating? Clemens just got caught

I was also sub in Darren Fletcher over Whitt.
 
Catcher: Pat Borders
First Base: Carlos Delgado
2nd Base: Roberto Alomar
Short Stop: Tony Fernandez
3rd Base: Josh Donaldson
Left Field: Joe Carter
Centre Field: Devon White
Right Field: Jose Bautista

DH: Edwin Encarnacion

Pitching Rotation:

Dave Stieb
Roy Halladay
Jimmy Key
Roger Clemens
Pat Hengten

7th: David Wells/Mike Timlin
8th: Duane Ward
9th: Tom Henke
 
I hear what your saying, but who knows how many of them were cheating? Clemens just got caught

I was also sub in Darren Fletcher over Whitt.
I don't think any of the other players selected cheated. Two spectacular seasons but , FUCK THE BASTARD.

Catcher is clearly our weakest position.
 
I hear what your saying, but who knows how many of them were cheating? Clemens just got caught

I was also sub in Darren Fletcher over Whitt.

I don't think any of the other players selected were cheaters. Two spectacular seasons but, FUCK THE BASTARD.

Catcher has clearly been our weakest position.
 
I've changed my left fielder to Joe Carter (he could play all 3 outfields when called upon) from George Bell.

Bell was a defensive liability, just ask Jimy Williams lol
 
Shaker was fun, but no way over Devo. Jays best ever lead-off hitter.

How about Rick Bosetti?

Offensively, they were comparable to one another, but Devo was waaaay better defensively.

Looking at the stats you guys are correct and I am wrong ( the Oracle braces for a Shack onslaught)

White could really steal a base eh? Jesus 346 steals is pretty good and he complimented that with power as well.

Excellent trade by the Jays getting white for essentially Junior Felix. Says on wiki that Felix might have been 10 years older than everybody was told,lol..The old Dominican birth certificate switcheroo trick.
 
Shaker was fun, but no way over Devo. Jays best ever lead-off hitter.

How about Rick Bosetti?

Shaker is a better tipper, but then again, that could apply to most anyone.
White rivalled Pippen for cheapness.

I liked Bosetti, not a great player, but fun to watch.
 
I've changed my left fielder to Joe Carter (he could play all 3 outfields when called upon) from George Bell.

Bell was a defensive liability, just ask Jimy Williams lol

This is a tough one. I think it really depends on what years. Like Bell's core years, he was better and wasn't really a defensive liability, but Carter had a much more consistent career.
 
Catcher is clearly our weakest position.

I think Darrin Fletcher is definitely the most underrated catcher we've every had, and one of the most underrated players we've ever had. There was about a 4 year stretch where he was amazing.
 
Last edited: