All Time NHL Team?

The old timers say Harvey "Busher" Jackson was Bobby Hull before Bobby Hull.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Busher_Jackson

Where are Jean Beliveau, Doug Harvey and Rocket Richard on your team?

Wayne Gretzky
Bobby Orr
Gordie Howe
Mario Lemieux[10]
Maurice Richard
Doug Harvey
Jean Beliveau
Bobby Hull
Terry Sawchuk[11]
Eddie Shore
Guy Lafleur
Mark Messier
Jacques Plante
Ray Bourque
Howie Morenz
Glenn Hall
Stan Mikita[12] Slovakia
Phil Esposito
Denis Potvin
Mike Bossy
Ted Lindsay

Unfortunately , you can't include everyone , someone will always be left out.

Jean Beliveau- I already have a great , tall centre man with long reach and big strides in Lemieux

Doug Harvey- I already have a great offensive D Man in Bobby Orr

Rocket Richard- I already have a "mean" player in Howe
 
Here's the thing. Expansion has diluted the talent base. Guys who are all-stars in a 31-32 team league would be 3rd liners in the old 6 team league.

I think every good team (emphasis on TEAM) needs at least one grinder and one "enforcer". Who better than Gainey and Ferguson?
 
Interesting that nobody has mentioned Espo. He was anything but graceful, but nobody in the history of the league was better at parking himself in front of the net, screening and knocking in those loose pucks. There's always loose pucks in any era. He still ranks high in a lot of career stats.

Also no mention of Marcel Dionne or Martin Brodeur, not as flashy as Roy or Hasek, but at least as effective as they. As for team, much better teammate than Roy. I'd put Dionne ahead of Makita or Yzerman.
 
Interesting that nobody has mentioned Espo. He was anything but graceful, but nobody in the history of the league was better at parking himself in front of the net, screening and knocking in those loose pucks. There's always loose pucks in any era. He still ranks high in a lot of career stats.

Also no mention of Marcel Dionne or Martin Brodeur, not as flashy as Roy or Hasek, but at least as effective as they. As for team, much better teammate than Roy. I'd put Dionne ahead of Makita or Yzerman.

Espo scored on Orr's rebounds, his points totals was pretty much almost cut in half when he went to the Rangers, no Orr to set him up.

I've got Dionne on my team.
 
Here's the thing. Expansion has diluted the talent base. Guys who are all-stars in a 31-32 team league would be 3rd liners in the old 6 team league.

I think every good team (emphasis on TEAM) needs at least one grinder and one "enforcer". Who better than Gainey and Ferguson?

I disagree the players now are much better than back then. They would skate circles around the 6 team league guys. Back then for a lot of those guys it was a part time job not a full time one. The players now are a lot more athletic, can do more and the goaltending is night and day. The goalies rarely went down, goals were a lot easier to score back then even with the inferior sticks.
 
I disagree the players now are much better than back then. They would skate circles around the 6 team league guys. Back then for a lot of those guys it was a part time job not a full time one. The players now are a lot more athletic, can do more and the goaltending is night and day. The goalies rarely went down, goals were a lot easier to score back then even with the inferior sticks.
And that's the same in every sport. It's like saying that the accomplishments of Babe Ruth, Jim Brown and Roger Bannister can be sloughed off because today's athletes are bigger, stronger and faster. One needs to look at how dominating an athlete was in his era and not compared to current times.
 
Surprised that nobody else has Crosby on their all-time team except me.
Dionne, Trottier and Esposito superior centres to Crosby? I find that hard to believe.
 
And that's the same in every sport. It's like saying that the accomplishments of Babe Ruth, Jim Brown and Roger Bannister can be sloughed off because today's athletes are bigger, stronger and faster. One needs to look at how dominating an athlete was in his era and not compared to current times.

It not just that, it's dedication to the sport. These guys live and breathe their sport, guys back then didn't. The one guy who I think could have played in any era was Jim Brown. I'm not downplaying what they did in their era. I just don't think they could do it in this one. The average fastball during Ruth's era was 80-85 mph. now it's 92-93. That's a big difference where as bats haven't changed all that much.
 
It not just that, it's dedication to the sport. These guys live and breathe their sport, guys back then didn't. The one guy who I think could have played in any era was Jim Brown. I'm not downplaying what they did in their era. I just don't think they could do it in this one. The average fastball during Ruth's era was 80-85 mph. now it's 92-93. That's a big difference where as bats haven't changed all that much.

It's all part of the evolution of all sports.

Actually those old-time guys played for the love of the game because they did not make a lot. The so-called dedication you speak of now is dedication to $$$. That's why they are forced to work so hard.

Of course the old-timers could not compete today IN ANY SPORT. That does not mean that they are not all-time greats and that Kasperi Kapanen is greater than Rocket Richard because he skates faster, is bigger, shoots harder and is a better stickhandler. Or that Giancarlo Stanton is greater than Babe Ruth because Ruth was fat and drank and smoked and Stanton is built like a Greek god.

IMO, it is unfair to compare players from different eras based on their physical attributes as opposed to their accomplishments within their era.
 
It's all part of the evolution of all sports.

Actually those old-time guys played for the love of the game because they did not make a lot. The so-called dedication you speak of now is dedication to $$$. That's why they are forced to work so hard.

Of course the old-timers could not compete today IN ANY SPORT. That does not mean that they are not all-time greats and that Kasperi Kapanen is greater than Rocket Richard because he skates faster, is bigger, shoots harder and is a better stickhandler. Or that Giancarlo Stanton is greater than Babe Ruth because Ruth was fat and drank and smoked and Stanton is built like a Greek god.

IMO, it is unfair to compare players from different eras based on their physical attributes as opposed to their accomplishments within their era.

I'm not saying those guys are greater, I'm saying if you take the greats from each era it's not even close. I would never compare Kapanen to Richard or Stanton to Ruth, but I would Ovechkin to Richard and Bonds to Ruth. That's where the difference is big.
 
I can't disagree with this lineup much. But will say Orr would need to be paired with someone who could keep the opposing players honest.
So I will perhaps suggest one of the toughest defensemen that ever played the game Eddie Shore. The stories Grapes tells about him are legendary.

I think its so hard to put a pre WWII player in the GOAT mix because its really hard to make comparisons to the modern game. They played fewer games per season back then, only one assist was awarded per goal, the league was almost exclusively Canadian born players etc. That said Shore was a giant of those times. 4 Hart Trophies as a D man is an amazing achievement. So I can't really argue much with his inclusion.