All Time NHL Team?

unassuming

Well-known member
Feb 11, 2017
14,238
5,463
113
Goal: Jacques Plante

Defence: Bobby Orr and Serge Savard

Right Wing: Gordie Howe

Centre: Wayne Gretzky

Left Wing: Bobby Hull
 
Goal- Patrick Roy
Defence- Bobby Orr, Paul Coffey

Left wing- Alex Ovechkin
Right wing- Jaromir Jagr
Centre- Wayne Gretzky-Mario Lemieux-tie
 
Goal - Hasek

D - Orr, Lindstrom

LW - Ovechkin

RW - Howe

C - Gretzky

Second team: Brodeur, Chara, Karlsson, Jagr, Crosby, Lemieux.
 
Orr, Howe and Gretzky for sure. The remaining 3 would be a more difficult choice. Below are the top 25 players from the top 100 list. I think the list includes only retired players.

Wayne Gretzky
Bobby Orr
Gordie Howe
Mario Lemieux[10]
Maurice Richard
Doug Harvey
Jean Beliveau
Bobby Hull
Terry Sawchuk[11]
Eddie Shore
Guy Lafleur
Mark Messier
Jacques Plante
Ray Bourque
Howie Morenz
Glenn Hall
Stan Mikita[12] Slovakia
Phil Esposito
Denis Potvin
Mike Bossy
Ted Lindsay
Patrick Roy
Red Kelly
Bobby Clarke
Larry Robinson
Ken Dryden

BTW: If we were to choose the best team ever, I would pick any one of the 1950's or 1970's Montreal Canadien teams.
 
G Patrick Roy

D Lidstrom
D Coffey

W Lemieux
C Crosby
W Ovechkin
 
I guess Shack and I are old enough to be your father, lol

What I love about the Hull/Gretzky/Howe line is how well they would complement each other.

Howe digs the puck out of the corners and is physically dominating and provides protection.
Gretzky is the ultimate playmaker.
And Hull provides speed, a booming shot and an all-time great scorer. Actually, all of them were all-time great scorers.
 
I guess Shack and I are old enough to be your father, lol

I'd be surprised, unless you guys are both OLD.
I slide in right at the end of the baby boomer generation.
 
G - Hasek
D - Orr
D - Harvey
C - Gretzky
LW - Ovechkin
RW - Howe
 
G - Hasek
D - Orr
D - Harvey
C - Gretzky
LW - Ovechkin
RW - Howe

I can't disagree with this lineup much. But will say Orr would need to be paired with someone who could keep the opposing players honest.
So I will perhaps suggest one of the toughest defensemen that ever played the game Eddie Shore. The stories Grapes tells about him are legendary.
 
The 1919 Quebec Bulldogs.
 
Why not make it an actual team? 4 full lines of 12 forwards, 8 defenseman and 2 goalies plus a coach. That should open things up.
 
Actual Team:

Goalies: Jacques Plante and Dominic Hasek,

Defence: Bobby Orr, Serge Savard, Borje Salming, Larry Robinson, Denis Potvin, Ray Bourque, Nick Lidstrom and Eddie Shore (To keep opponents honest)


Right Wing: Gordie Howe, Guy Lafleur, Mike Bossy and Jaromir Jagr

Centre: Wayne Gretzky, Mario Lemieux, Marcel Dionne and Bryan Trottier

Left Wing: Bobby Hull, Gilbert Perreault, Alexander Ovechkin and Ted Lindsay (to keep opponents honest)


Coach: Scotty Bowman
 
Last edited:
Left Wing: Bobby Hull, Jaromir Jagr, Alexander Ovechkin and Ted Lindsay (to keep opponents honest)
The old timers say Harvey "Busher" Jackson was Bobby Hull before Bobby Hull.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Busher_Jackson

Where are Jean Beliveau, Doug Harvey and Rocket Richard on your team?

Wayne Gretzky
Bobby Orr
Gordie Howe
Mario Lemieux[10]
Maurice Richard
Doug Harvey
Jean Beliveau
Bobby Hull
Terry Sawchuk[11]
Eddie Shore
Guy Lafleur
Mark Messier
Jacques Plante
Ray Bourque
Howie Morenz
Glenn Hall
Stan Mikita[12] Slovakia
Phil Esposito
Denis Potvin
Mike Bossy
Ted Lindsay
 
23-man roster

Goalies: Patrick Roy, Terry Sawchuk

Defence: Orr, Harvey, Bourque, Lidstrom, Robinson, Potvin, Shore

Right Wing: Howe, Rocket Richard, Lafleur, Bossy, Jagr

Centre: Gretzky, Lemieux, Beliveau, Crosby, Mikita

Left Wing: Bobby Hull, Ovechkin, Frank Mahovlich, Messier (natural c, but played LW at times)

Coach: Bowman