Blue Jays: 2015 edition

Pillar makes that diving catch and we're looking at a tie ballgame right now
 
If Pillar had made that catch would have been greatest of season - and he has made a few. And now he is pressing badly at plate.

As for Dickey, I could have seen him in his Cy Young year...because he looks like a back end of the rotation guy...like that knuckleballer Boston had for a few years (name on tip of tongue). Did the Red Sox swing and miss at any of his pitches today? I know he had no strikeouts. How did he ever win 20 games...were NL hitters that bad?

Good start for the kid from Buffalo. He threw strikes. The Pelara era has begun
 
Besides Phil Niekro I cant think of one knuckleballer who's ever been an ace

Wilber Wood, this guy had some amazing stats. In the early 70's he averaged 345 innings pitched a season and one day he pitched the last 5 innings of a suspended game in the afternoon and got the win then pitched a complete game victory later the same night. Unfortunately he had his knee cap shattered by a line drive and he was never the same retiring two years later.
 
Wood was an ace ...but not a superstar or cy younger. Hoyt Wilhelm had a long career as a knuckleballing reliever. Does any one know the difference between Dickey in his Cy Young year and now? Lack of walks? Better control?
 
Charlie Hough comes to mind as well, although he was never really an ace nor did he ever win a Cy Young
 
yup....good pitcher, never an ace

As far as knucklers go I would rather have Wakefield then Dickey, but agree still not an ace.
 
I've heard the Giants are going to give Romero a shot, apparently close to signing a minor league deal.
 
Jays have a $12m team option on Dickey for 2016. Normally, 12 mil is nothing for a decent starter but at this rate I'm not sure they'll pick it up.

If Syndergaard becomes as good as most think people think he'll be, the deal is going look real bad.
 
Cards are exclamated
 
Jays have a $12m team option on Dickey for 2016. Normally, 12 mil is nothing for a decent starter but at this rate I'm not sure they'll pick it up.

If Syndergaard becomes as good as most think people think he'll be, the deal is going look real bad.

If Dickey came close to his Cy Young year and/or the he helped the Jays make the playoffs the past two years this deal does not look too bad, but considering how he has pitched and where the Jays actually finish this is a win for the Mets.

In my opinion you never win if you give up so much potential for a pitcher(just looking at the numbers) you could have had for a lot less money and from the FA pool.
 
If Dickey came close to his Cy Young year and/or the he helped the Jays make the playoffs the past two years this deal does not look too bad, but considering how he has pitched and where the Jays actually finish this is a win for the Mets.

In my opinion you never win if you give up so much potential for a pitcher(just looking at the numbers) you could have had for a lot less money and from the FA pool.
Even though the Jays might not have expected more Cy performances, I think the drop off was more than anticipated.

Won/loss, not so good. His assets have been eating innings and I believe he is a good clubhouse influence/mentor (same with Buehrle [and his dogs]). I don't think those RA positives are worth $12M, though.

D'Arnaud and Syndegaard are still nothing more than unproven potential.

As someone else alluded to, I'd like to see AA give up some prospects (I think our farm has decent depth) for a very solid starter. The AL East is ripe for the picking. And make the deal sooner rather than later before there is a bad stretch that puts them significantly behind the leaders.
 
It's not hard to find some years that are anomalies.

Won/loss record is almost always one of the prime criteria in determining best pitchers. Always has and always will
This ^

Costanza is cherry-picking the exception rather than the rule