Blue jays 2014 edition

Agreed, Happ has been a pleasant surprise. He keeps them in the game more often than not (at least when I watch him pitch).

I don't know a 4.40 ERA just doesn't really bode well too me.

I will give you this however there are times when he looks dominant out there and I think finally he has arrived. Sadly though he can look just the opposite the next time out.
 
I don't know a 4.40 ERA just doesn't really bode well too me.

I will give you this however there are times when he looks dominant out there and I think finally he has arrived. Sadly though he can look just the opposite the next time out.

Yeah, I'd (and I'm sure Mr. Happ as well) would like that to be at least 1/2 run lower.
I come back to the reliability factor, his relatively low cost, and his left-handedness as pluses for him.
People upthread have mentioned a rotation including Stroman, Sanchez, Hutchison.
I see that more in '16 than '15, barring a trade in the next 2 days.
Happ, Dickey & Buehrle will be back next year, unless the Blue Jays want to cover part of Mark or R.A.'s salary in a trade.
 
yes - of course :)

Melky was afraid to tell them.

He had a sore back all season but never told them. The tumor affected his legs - they were more focused on his other symptoms but were never aware his back was bothering him.

(what I was trying to say that he was a better deal than what he ended up being - no matter how great he has been this year. (he still hit well last season even though he couldn't run)..... and after this season he appears to have been a brilliant signing by AA.)

It's not AA's fault he had a tumour.
It's not AA's fault Josh Johnson had a horrible year
It's not AAs fault Morrow does deserve the title "Mr. DL"
It's not AA's fault Santos has been "Mr. Junior DL" (and he was rocking AAA before his last two appearances here after his call-up.

Also - Anthopolis signed Navarro - who no one anticipated working a full-season. He's allowed a few passed balls but he has preformed way above expectations.

I guess I get influenced bc I listen to Mike Wilner all the time on Fan 590 and he's ridiculously-optimistic.... But I strongly disagree with those who place blame on AA and Gibby.

So much is outside of their control.

Some people think Billy Beane is Brilliant - yet the As are in second place now.

Success in baseball involves a little luck.


This is one of the most well articulated and accurate post I've read in this thread.
 
Alex won't be fired.

We made a trade move 2 days before the deadline. Valencia won the game for us. Maybe people would feel better if we got him the day-of.

Let's take a little look at the blockbuster deadline trades of this year.

Hmmm - Price was pulled in the 3rd inning today after allowing an almost record amount of runs in an inning. Detroit is no longer in first.
Let's look towards Oakland where they also are no longer in first (and who gave up their best hitter for another pitcher in a pitching friendly-park). Oakland earlier traded for the pitcher EVERY pundit was proclaiming to be the perfect fit for Toronto.

Who knows why NY is successful? bc on paper they shouldn't be. We may even be able to catch up to them during our series this weekend. (I have no grand illusions about our chances this season but I definitely believe the Jays are a better team than the Yanks!)

Who honestly thinks that one trade (in which we'd give up our very valuable prospects and/or current lineup) could have made a difference in our chances of making the post season? Creating more holes in a lineup that (clearly) had more than one hole to fill....

You really think giving Tampa Stroman, Hutch, and Lawrie for a year and a few months of Price could've gotten us to the playoffs? (remember trading within our division would've cost us more - and these are names I've heard from pundits were on the table). Detroit and Oakland didn't just give up prospects - they gave up every day players to get priemier pitchers.

I don't.

Oakland sacrificed their best hitter - guy who won the last two hr derbys for a 2 month rental and a bench player for someone who won't re-sign in a pitching-friendly park. What the heck does anyone wish AA could do?

Yankees acquired way-over priced guys - who admittedly have been clutch for them but I don't think would have worked out for us.

Everyone wanted us to sign "the shark" from the cubs (can't spell his name off the top of my head). He's been a disaster for the As.

... want to criticize AA for last year's big moves?
The Miami trade? know what? only guy we lost in that trade has ended up being worth anything so far= Alvarez. We got the most coveted pitcher of that off-season (Johnson) and a proven veteran in Buerhle, an all-sar in Reyes, a (supposedly) stellar, switch hitting utility man in Bonifaco. We got Thole and Dickey from the Mets for players who have not proven anything in the big leagues.

We got Melky at a steal (and if he wasn't afraid to deal with his sore back, he could've had two awesome years as a Jay).

Ya - the trades didn't pan out as much as we had hoped... but would our team have been any better without those trades?

How is it Alex's fault that Johnson SUCKED (and is now on the DL after tommy-john. How is it AA's fault that Bonifcaio just sucked here - but did better after he went to Kansas/Cubs (I dunno where he is now).

Regardless of the fact that we had big hopes that weren't met - none of the players we traded are superstars either.

It's not AA's fault.
It's not Gibby's fault.

It's the straight-up fact that baseball has ups and downs and injuries and magic moments and heart breaking moments.

That-said.
http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2014/...s.html?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=facebook

Buerhle has been placed on waivers. I'd love to see him claimed (as much as i do like him). We have solid (young and cheaper) pitching.
Dickey and Reyes have been on waivers since Aug 25.

I think Mark could add to a contending team (with his ws experience). His (and Reyes') salaries go up next year. Morrow is not comming back, nor is Rasmus. I'd like to see the Jays re-sign Melky with the savings of unloading either Mark or Jose and make sure we keep Melky and get a solid 2nd baseman.

I wish something magical happended during the deadline too. But the fact that we had ONE magical month (May), a few ok months and one HORRIBLE one (August), tells me that AA was f'ing smart.

If quality pitching takes up a huge load of salary.... and if we have 4 (yes 4 - cuz if you don't know about Norris ~ check out what he has done! People are saying he's better than Stroman, Sanchez, and Hutchison!)

Say we end up with 4 quality young starters (or maybe 1 or 2 go in the bullpen for now) next year..... and we can unload one or two of Dickey, Buerhle, or Happ... and say we get are free of Morrow, Santos, Rasmus. (not including other FA's - only ones I can think of are Janssen and Kawasaki).
eve
We could very-well end up with a stellar rotation at a low price that could allow us to give Melky whatever he wants and give us room to sign a big 2nd baseman.

I think AA will have a much better reputation one year from now - when we are all glad we didn't give everything up on the off-chance that this year's May would convert to a WS.


God I love reading your posts.
 
Excellent effort by the pitching staff today and JB homers for the fourth game in a row. Well done.
 
Just a FYI, there have been teams who got really hot and overtaken divisions or WC spots while being 5.5 games behind. Sometimes while being even more games behind.

No I'm not googling them all for you, too lazy.
And no, that doesnt mean it'll necessarily happen with the Jays, but it is possible
 
Just a FYI, there have been teams who got really hot and overtaken divisions or WC spots while being 5.5 games behind. Sometimes while being even more games behind.

No I'm not googling them all for you, too lazy.
And no, that doesnt mean it'll necessarily happen with the Jays, but it is possible

As recently as 2011 the Rays were 9.5 games back on Sep 1st and were able to overtake the Red Sox to win the WC spot. I believe it was either the last game or a one game play-off with the Sox that decided the WC team.

In the same year the Cards were 10.5 games back on Aug 25th and came back to win the WC on the last day of the season.

Baseball is a game of momentum.

Chances are slim that the Jays could turn September into another May, but they are one hell of a streaky team.
 
If you think Navarro has performed above expectations then maybe you should read this...http://www.bluebirdbanter.com/2014/8/21/6046603/dioner-navarro-quiet-disaster

There was a reason why he was a part timer most of his career.

Navarro is still better than what was here! Offensively he has been everything expected and then some, defensively, far from an all star, but(sadly), still an improvement.
I don't get Thole. If Dickey was lights out with him catching, then Thole is worth keeping. Currently, he plays every 5th game and basically occupies a spot on the roster. Find a catcher
that can help you defensively and give Navarro some time off.
 
For those of you advocating that Joey Boom Bats should be traded, please stand up.

You have an appointment with Rodney Dangerfield's doctor, Dr Vinny Boom Bats. Wherever it hurts he'll kiss it better.
 
Guys on Bluebirdbanter are critical of Navarro's framing skills, not so much is defence. They argue it's the reason why Jays pitchers are not getting the strike calls some of the other teams are. Ultimately the pressure this puts on the pitchers is likely to translate into more hits and more walks allowed.

No one is saying he is weak with his bat.
 
Guys on Bluebirdbanter are critical of Navarro's framing skills, not so much is defence. They argue it's the reason why Jays pitchers are not getting the strike calls some of the other teams are. Ultimately the pressure this puts on the pitchers is likely to translate into more hits and more walks allowed.

No one is saying he is weak with his bat.
So his defence is OK and his bat is OK. I think he also calls a decent game.

But if he can't frame the pitches, what good is he?

Just curious how many MLB catchers have no deficiencies.
 
For all our critiques of the blue jays...and that is part of being a fan......games like today remind us why we love baseball.
 
So his defence is OK and his bat is OK. I think he also calls a decent game.

But if he can't frame the pitches, what good is he?

Just curious how many MLB catchers have no deficiencies.


My knock on him defensively is there is nothing about his defensive game that stands out. He does most things OK, not WOW, but OK.
As I said previously he is an upgrade from last years catcher. I am quite happy with his performance, as that bat atones for defensive
deficiencies.
I would love to see another catcher on the bench in place of Thole. Thole being used as he is seems ridiculous to me, he isn't the back
up catcher, he is Dickey's personal catcher????
 
It will be very difficult for the Jays to clinch the second wild card now. Only 26 games reminding and they have to win at least 21 games. Too bad that Josh Johnson was a bust.
Can you imagine if Josh Johnson wasn't a bust ..he would give the Jays at least 12-14 wins ...the Jays would have about 79-80 wins right now and be in first place.