Blue jays 2014 edition

Yan Gomes....I could never figure out why he rarely if ever caught here. That trade has really been good for Cleveland. Completely for got about Napoli....Damn... take it you would like to see him(AA) gone too.
Bc Arencebia was our starter (and had a decent year when Gomes was called up).

Gomes was a AAA call-up - not in the lineup at the start of the season. I remember seeing his first game (first Brazillian to ever play in the majors). He's been ok in Cleveland. Esmil was good too for a while.....

I didn't watch baseball when Napoli was a Jay (for a few days), but I did hear it mentioned last night.

He couldda been great here. Too bad.
 
You are aware Cabrera had a tumour pressing on his spine last season?

yes - of course :)

Melky was afraid to tell them.

He had a sore back all season but never told them. The tumor affected his legs - they were more focused on his other symptoms but were never aware his back was bothering him.

(what I was trying to say that he was a better deal than what he ended up being - no matter how great he has been this year. (he still hit well last season even though he couldn't run)..... and after this season he appears to have been a brilliant signing by AA.)

It's not AA's fault he had a tumour.
It's not AA's fault Josh Johnson had a horrible year
It's not AAs fault Morrow does deserve the title "Mr. DL"
It's not AA's fault Santos has been "Mr. Junior DL" (and he was rocking AAA before his last two appearances here after his call-up.

Also - Anthopolis signed Navarro - who no one anticipated working a full-season. He's allowed a few passed balls but he has preformed way above expectations.

I guess I get influenced bc I listen to Mike Wilner all the time on Fan 590 and he's ridiculously-optimistic.... But I strongly disagree with those who place blame on AA and Gibby.

So much is outside of their control.

Some people think Billy Beane is Brilliant - yet the As are in second place now.

Success in baseball involves a little luck.
 
I agree with almost everything Jennifer (future Blue Jay's Gm?) has written above. I recall all the excitement and buzz created when Anthopolous made the trades with Florida and the Met. Every, and I mean every, Jays fan saw the moves as a positive. Las Vegas bookies immediately made the Jays World Series favourites. Hindsight is indeed 20/20.
 
What's amazing is both Detriot and Oakland could not make the playoffs.

Jennifer did an excellent job of looking critically not only at the team, but the league as well.

What happens with Melky I think will depend a bit on Joey Bats. He has said he won't be asking for a trade. I believe him.

Looking at things I think we are going to have to endure one more mediocre season. No one will pick up Buerle and his 19 million next year. I'm not sure about Dickey, is this his option that we can choose not to exercise? His leaving is probably a good part of what Melky will cost.

Jansen is toast. Rasmus is toast. Happ I think will be packaged up in the off season for a position player.

As for Brett he has one more season to get it together.

And we get grass in 2015 so maybe that will make it easier(with 19 million freed up once Buerle is done) to sign whoever is available FA wise. That and we hope a really good looking young starter staff(if one doesn't end up as a closer). To make a playoff run look good to someone.
 
yes - of course :)

Melky was afraid to tell them.

He had a sore back all season but never told them. The tumor affected his legs - they were more focused on his other symptoms but were never aware his back was bothering him.

(what I was trying to say that he was a better deal than what he ended up being - no matter how great he has been this year. (he still hit well last season even though he couldn't run)..... and after this season he appears to have been a brilliant signing by AA.)

It's not AA's fault he had a tumour.
It's not AA's fault Josh Johnson had a horrible year
It's not AAs fault Morrow does deserve the title "Mr. DL"
It's not AA's fault Santos has been "Mr. Junior DL" (and he was rocking AAA before his last two appearances here after his call-up.

Also - Anthopolis signed Navarro - who no one anticipated working a full-season. He's allowed a few passed balls but he has preformed way above expectations.

I guess I get influenced bc I listen to Mike Wilner all the time on Fan 590 and he's ridiculously-optimistic.... But I strongly disagree with those who place blame on AA and Gibby.

So much is outside of their control.

Some people think Billy Beane is Brilliant - yet the As are in second place now.

Success in baseball involves a little luck.

Yes, I agree with most of what you said and had said much the same thing earlier regarding the new pitchers coming through. Really hope they can re-sign Melky.

Navarro might have good offensive numbers but is weak in other respects, in particular (according to guys on Bluebird Banter) at framing.
 
Bc Arencebia was our starter (and had a decent year when Gomes was called up).

Gomes was a AAA call-up - not in the lineup at the start of the season. I remember seeing his first game (first Brazillian to ever play in the majors). He's been ok in Cleveland. Esmil was good too for a while.....

I didn't watch baseball when Napoli was a Jay (for a few days), but I did hear it mentioned last night.He couldda been great here. Too bad.

You have the September call ups so you can evaluate their talent in the bigs. If you don't play them at their positions you can not evaluate them. Jays had tunnel vision when it came to JP and we know how that went.
I admire you loyalty to the Jays management, but , personally I'm tired of losing.
This group is at best a 500 team and I don't see it improving under the current regime. I don't blame Gibby. I don't think it would matter who the manager is/was they couldn't succeed with this group as it stands.,
 
Buerhle has been placed on waivers. I'd love to see him claimed (as much as i do like him). We have solid (young and cheaper) pitching.
Dickey and Reyes have been on waivers since Aug 25.

Yes Jenn! You finally give in after all these years!:closed_2:
 
Butler100,

The turf will not be replaced until 2017. The Argos still have to find a place to play after their lease runs out in 2017.
 
No one will pick up Buerle and his 19 million next year. I'm not sure about Dickey, is this his option that we can choose not to exercise?

Happ I think will be packaged up in the off season for a position player.


As for Brett he has one more season to get it together.

And we get grass in 2015 so maybe that will make it easier(with 19 million freed up once Buerle is done) to sign whoever is available FA wise. That and we hope a really good looking young starter staff(if one doesn't end up as a closer).

As noted above, no grass 'til at least 2017.

Mark Buehrle is signed thru 2015 $20,000,000
R.A. Dickey is signed thru 2015 $12,000,000, the Blue Jays hold an option for '16, $12M (or thereabouts), with buyout of $1,000,000

Why would you want to move J. A. Happ?
He's a left handed starter, healthy when not getting hit in the head by line drives.
Takes the ball every 5th day and tends to give the team a chance to win.
And! he's relatively inexpensive, the Blue Jays hold an option for '15 ~$5,400,000 with a $200K buyout.
 
Alex won't be fired.

It's not AA's fault.
It's not Gibby's fault.


Buerhle has been placed on waivers. I'd love to see him claimed (as much as i do like him). We have solid (young and cheaper) pitching.
Dickey and Reyes have been on waivers since Aug 25.

I think Mark could add to a contending team (with his ws experience). His (and Reyes') salaries go up next year. Morrow is not comming back, nor is Rasmus.

I wish something magical happended during the deadline too. But the fact that we had ONE magical month (May), a few ok months and one HORRIBLE one (August), tells me that AA was f'ing smart.

If quality pitching takes up a huge load of salary.... and if we have 4 (yes 4 - cuz if you don't know about Norris ~ check out what he has done! People are saying he's better than Stroman, Sanchez, and Hutchison!)

Say we end up with 4 quality young starters (or maybe 1 or 2 go in the bullpen for now) next year..... and we can unload one or two of Dickey, Buerhle, or Happ... and say we get are free of Morrow, Santos, Rasmus. (not including other FA's - only ones I can think of are Janssen and Kawasaki).

We could very-well end up with a stellar rotation at a low price that could allow us to give Melky whatever he wants and give us room to sign a big 2nd baseman.

I'm just a run of the mill fan with opinions. Not remotely as knowable as you.

Someone has to take responsibility. AA and Gibby should go. Wipe the slate clean.

Brett should be traded. He's just not reliable because of all his injuries. Didn't know Reyes and Dickey were on waivers but I've been saying it for months. They're just not reliable. Rasmus is also not performing as advertised. Goodbye.

Melky is a gem. Pay him whatever he wants and the same with Kawasaki. Both get on base.

And bring back a couple of the young players that have been sent down. We have too many veterans.

Ramblings of an average fan but I love the Jays. My wardrobe speaks volumes. :)
 
A player can always be yanked back, if placed on waivers. Even superstars go on waivers once in a while to test the interest of other teams. No one is picking up Buehrle and Dickey because of the price tag.
 
Yes Jenn! You finally give in after all these years!:closed_2:

lol

Dickey was never supposed to be our Ace.

Johnson was. He sucked big time.

Buerhle was supposed to be number 3 or 4 (behind Johnson, Morrow (ppl thought he would win the Cy Young award last year), Dickey, Romero wouldda been fifth).

You gave me your opinion on Dickey the day after the trade and you've always been against him lol. Dickey is more solid than guys way younger than him and I bet he has more years left in him than guys younger than him.

I haven't changed my opinion - I still like our starters. I still like Dickey and I'd rather him stay over Buerhle. I do realize Mark and RA are not front of the rotation guys.

Dickey has been a good back of the rotation guy. He has pitched better than his record suggests.

We've got young guys to fill front of the rotation now... It would help if we can drop some salary... I hope one of them get claimed off waivers. If that doesn't happen, I bet Happ goes via trade. Morrow is not re-signed. Romero continues on with life in AAA. Norris goes to the Bullpen. Stroman is the Ace.
 
A player can always be yanked back, if placed on waivers. Even superstars go on waivers once in a while to test the interest of other teams. No one is picking up Buehrle and Dickey because of the price tag.

... yes - it's a way to gauge interest in the post season.
 
Dickey was never supposed to be our Ace.

I still like Dickey and I'd rather him stay over Buerhle. I do realize Mark and RA are not front of the rotation guys.

Dickey has been a good back of the rotation guy. He has pitched better than his record suggests.


Jennifer, the Toronto Blue Jays traded C Travis d’Arnaud, C John Buck, RHP Noah Syndergaard and OF Wuilmer Becerra for the reigning Cy Young Award winner R.A. Dickey for him to be a back of the rotation starter, not a front line, ace or #2?!:confused:

Toronto also acquired R.A.'s personal catcher~C Josh Thole and C Mike Nickeas from the Mets.

Travis d'Arnaud~Rookie with the Mets, struggling offensively b.a. .222, but NYM are very happy with his defence
John Buck~traded for prospect(s)
Noah Syndergaard~in AAA Las Vegas, still just 21 years old, averaging 9.9K/9, 9-7, a w.h.i.p. under 1.5 in a graveyard for pitchers, on schedule to join the Mets either to start 2015 or part way through 2015.
Wuilmer Becerra~still only 19 years old, playing in Rookie League, b.a .301 o.b.p. .352 slg.471 o.b.p. .823

Dickey~has been underwhelming with Toronto
Josh Thole~no stick, decent job as R.A.'s personal caddy.
Mike Nickeas~31 years old, playing AAA Buffalo hitting .207

The Blue Jays acquired Dickey to a #3 or #4 starter, not an ace or at worst a #2?
Umm, no.
 
Jennifer, the Toronto Blue Jays traded C Travis d’Arnaud, C John Buck, RHP Noah Syndergaard and OF Wuilmer Becerra for the reigning Cy Young Award winner R.A. Dickey for him to be a back of the rotation starter, not a front line, ace or #2?!:confused:

Toronto also acquired R.A.'s personal catcher~C Josh Thole and C Mike Nickeas from the Mets.

Travis d'Arnaud~Rookie with the Mets, struggling offensively b.a. .222, but NYM are very happy with his defence
John Buck~traded for prospect(s)
Noah Syndergaard~in AAA Las Vegas, still just 21 years old, averaging 9.9K/9, 9-7, a w.h.i.p. under 1.5 in a graveyard for pitchers, on schedule to join the Mets either to start 2015 or part way through 2015.
Wuilmer Becerra~still only 19 years old, playing in Rookie League, b.a .301 o.b.p. .352 slg.471 o.b.p. .823

Dickey~has been underwhelming with Toronto
Josh Thole~no stick, decent job as R.A.'s personal caddy.
Mike Nickeas~31 years old, playing AAA Buffalo hitting .207

The Blue Jays acquired Dickey to a #3 or #4 starter, not an ace or at worst a #2?
Umm, no.

If I remember correctly, I think Buerhle was the prospective number three at the start of the season with Dickey as the number one.
 
The Jays and the Leafs are always in the same boat by end of their season. They cannot be real bad so that they can obtain the first overall pick in the draft!
 
Why would you want to move J. A. Happ?
He's a left handed starter, healthy when not getting hit in the head by line drives.
Takes the ball every 5th day and tends to give the team a chance to win.
And! he's relatively inexpensive, the Blue Jays hold an option for '15 ~$5,400,000 with a $200K buyout.

Agreed, Happ has been a pleasant surprise. He keeps them in the game more often than not (at least when I watch him pitch).
 
Agreed, Happ has been a pleasant surprise. He keeps them in the game more often than not (at least when I watch him pitch).

I expect the Jays to pick up his option. In the group of starters the Jays currently have, he looks pretty good. Usually gives you innings. If they opted to trade him I imagine there would be a fair bit of interest, just don't think it would be prudent looking at the depth and quality of what the Jays currently have for starters.