Congrats to Genie

Glad to see that Genie did not lose.

Kvitova won by playing amazing tennis. An unbeatable combination of power and consistency. Huge hitting, sharp angles and very, very very few misses.

Nothing that Genie (or anyone else, I think) could have done.

Sorry but Genie lost BIG. She was slaughtered. I was a bit puzzled why she did not step back when receiving 1st serve. That would have allowed her a more aggressive return. Poor adaptation. Could have adapted better. She did better against Sharapova in the French, so I expected more from her even against Kvitova . She need to be standing 1-2 feet back on those serves
 
Sorry but Genie lost BIG. She was slaughtered. I was a bit puzzled why she did not step back when receiving 1st serve. That would have allowed her a more aggressive return. Poor adaptation. Could have adapted better. She did better against Sharapova in the French, so I expected more from her even against Kvitova . She need to be standing 1-2 feet back on those serves

Read a post from someone, who unlike you, is not ignorant about tennis.

I dont know if she played poorly today as much as Kvitova didnt allow her to play at all. Kvitova took the racquet out of Genie's hands. Grass court tennis is very much about 1st strike tennis and Kvitova has the better serve. Also, Genie's serve is attackable. Kvotiva has the higher power-quotient and Kvitova just smothered her with that power. Took all of Genie's time away.
 
Sorry but Genie lost BIG. She was slaughtered. I was a bit puzzled why she did not step back when receiving 1st serve. That would have allowed her a more aggressive return. Poor adaptation. Could have adapted better. She did better against Sharapova in the French, so I expected more from her even against Kvitova . She need to be standing 1-2 feet back on those serves

That is part of Genie Bouchard tennis. I heard Nick Saviano do an interview on the Aces show on Fan590 and he was talking about her style is taking the ball early, attacking, controlling the point and finishing. I do agree that Genie needs to be a little less stubborn with her tactics. I dont know whether to blame Genie for that or Coach Saviano. But especially on a fast court against a big hitter you need to give yourself a little more time to prepare for your shots. Her court-positioning almost worked against her because it allowed Kvitova to rush Genie even more. She might be able to get away with that on a slower court like on clay but harder to do on grass.

Sharapova, like Kvitova also hits a big ball but the difference on clay is the ball doesnt move through the court as quickly so the surface provides Genie a little more time. If Sharapova had played Genie @ Wimbledon I think Sharapova may have done the same thing that Kvitova did to her.

That said the way Kvitova played she would have beaten a LOT of good players. She was even playing defense as well as I have ever seen her play defense. Even hitting a few winners on the run.
 
No matter how you put it, she did lost big. For you to say she did not lose, that was stupid.
Of course she lost and very decisively. The point was that Kvitova played amazing tennis and even if Genie played her best tennis she still would have lost. It would have been closer but she still would have lost. Kvitova was in a zone.

Hence my point that Kvitova won it by playing great more so than Genie lost it due to poor play.

Hope that clarifies my statement for anyone too stupid to understand its' nuance.
 
Of course she lost and very decisively. The point was that Kvitova played amazing tennis and even if Genie played her best tennis she still would have lost. It would have been closer but she still would have lost. Kvitova was in a zone.

Hence my point that Kvitova won it by playing great more so than Genie lost it due to poor play.

Hope that clarifies my statement for anyone too stupid to understand its' nuance.

Agreed. And the way Kvitova was playing she likely would have beaten players who are even better than Genie. Even if Genie plays her best (which I am not sure how she could have b/c Kvitova's game totally took the racquet out of her hands) Kvitova would have won regardless. However, I would say that Genie didnt do a good job of making in-match adjustments. For example taking a step back behind the baseline to give herself a little more time. Would it have made a difference in the outcome? Probably not. But the fact that she didnt go to a Plan B is something her and Nick Saviano need to work on. You need to be willing to make in-match adjustments at the highest levels.

Kvitova's game is so tailor-made for grass with the big lefty serve and FH.
 
20 in women's tennis is not that young. Monica Seles http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monica_Seles was winning Slams in her teens as did Tracey Austin and maybe others.

The game is changing though. It demands maybe a greater physical and mental maturity than ever before. So I think it is becoming harder for teenagers to win slams.. In today's game I think 20 is still very young. The Genie we see today is FAR from the finished product. And when you have women winning majors in their late 20s early 30s like Li Na and Sam Stosur it just shows that 20 is still young. I think the days of 16 year olds winning majors is over - even in the women's game. And even if a teenager does win a slam like Sharapova did its far less likely now than it was in the past I think.
 
Read a post from someone, who unlike you, is not ignorant about tennis.

I play tennis, and have played with people who have a much more powerful game then I am used to, you can adapt to it, if you look at where she was standing to receive, and where male tennis players stand, she was wayyyy to close to the base line. Kvitova serves at close to the pace of a male pro, average serve speed of 106 mph vs 117 mph for Federer. That is 10 mph faster then her opponent in the semis. There is NO REASON she should not have been able to handle that by moving a step or 2 back. As for Kvitova high angle shots that messed her up, weak returns, get you behind and leave you open to those. After her weak returns, she fell further behind in each rally.
 
Of course she lost and very decisively. The point was that Kvitova played amazing tennis and even if Genie played her best tennis she still would have lost. It would have been closer but she still would have lost. Kvitova was in a zone.

Hence my point that Kvitova won it by playing great more so than Genie lost it due to poor play.

Hope that clarifies my statement for anyone too stupid to understand its' nuance.

I disagree, Genie was too dogmatic it her approach and did not adapt her game to the new reality. As a player, you always want to impose your game on the other player, if you can then great. But if you are getting blown away you have to try a few things to stay in the match and hopefully soem chances will come your way. I did not see her adapt at all. She kept with her game plan even when it was clear it was not working at all. I think she will wise up quickly. Get a male tennis player to blast some 110-115 mph serves at her to work out her positioning. They shoulda been doing this on the practice court.
 
I play tennis, and have played with people who have a much more powerful game then I am used to, you can adapt to it, if you look at where she was standing to receive, and where male tennis players stand, she was wayyyy to close to the base line. Kvitova serves at close to the pace of a male pro, average serve speed of 106 mph vs 117 mph for Federer. That is 10 mph faster then her opponent in the semis. There is NO REASON she should not have been able to handle that by moving a step or 2 back. As for Kvitova high angle shots that messed her up, weak returns, get you behind and leave you open to those. After her weak returns, she fell further behind in each rally.

I play tennis as well but will admit that while I have played against players who have slightly more power than I do , I havent played against players who have a LOT more power than I do. I do agree that Genie should have been willing to move off the baseline just a little bit. When you are playing against a big hitter on grass and you are not the greatest defensive player (Genie's defense/movement is better than people give her credit for but certainly not elite) then you need to give yourself a little more time. Tactically Genie should have made that adjustment. Honestly, the way Kvitova was playing though I do agree with shack that I think Kvitova would have won regardless . I dont think the x's and o's were the difference in this match. Genie just got beat by a player whose game is tailor-made for grass and who played her A game. I'd even argue she played better than her A-game. I dont think we normally expect Kvitova to move as well or be as good defensively or hit those winners on the run like she did in the final.. So not only did she play her A game she even played beyond her A game. Genie's game is predicated though on hugging the baseline, taking the ball early and on the rise , attacking, controlling the point and finishing. It is very difficult to get her off the baseline but I think it is something that she should be willing to do against the bigger hitters. She might be able to get away with it a little bit on the slower surfaces like clay but certainly not on grass. Though even Shazza was able to penetrate Genie's defenses in that semi @ RG.

So I actually sort of agree with you both. I agree with nottyboi that Genie needs to be a little less stubborn and be willing to make in-match adjustments especially against the top players. If Rafa Nadal is willing to make adjustments then Genie Bouchard should be willing to as well.

On the other hand I agree with shack that the x's and o's were not the difference in this match. Kvitova's outstanding play was. Moving forward though Genie does need be a little less stubborn tactically because it is something that could cost her in a close match down the road. I have probably watched about 15 of Genie's matches @ the majors this year including those ones that Jim Van Horne called in the early rounds of Melbourne on his own from some bunker in Toronto and I'll be honest - if Genie had played her A game I still think Kvitova would have won. However, that does not excuse Genie from being stubborn tactically. She should have made adjustments to give her opponent a different look if nothing else.

It may not necessarily have been a bad idea to stand close to the baseline on the ad-court though to return serve in order to protect against that lefty slice serve out-wide on the ad-court to Genie's BH. If Genie stands further back that serve would completely take her off the court. Playing closer to the baseline at least affords her the opportunity to step up and cut that ball off before she gets taken completely off the court.
 
I disagree, Genie was too dogmatic it her approach and did not adapt her game to the new reality. As a player, you always want to impose your game on the other player, if you can then great.
It does happen but I think it is rare. I remember Arthur Ashe beat the "unbeatable" Jimmy Connors in the U.S. Open (?) by changing his tactics to beat Jimmy's powerful groundstrokes and volleys. I think Arthur did it by slowing down Jimmy's game.
 
Of course she lost and very decisively. The point was that Kvitova played amazing tennis and even if Genie played her best tennis she still would have lost. It would have been closer but she still would have lost. Kvitova was in a zone.

Hence my point that Kvitova won it by playing great more so than Genie lost it due to poor play.

Hope that clarifies my statement for anyone too stupid to understand its' nuance.

Genie Bouchard lost decisively because she played a terrible match, plain and simple, both strategically and pragmatically, and clearly Saviano was out-coached. Stop being an apologist for her - it's not a patriotic crime to admit she sucked and got her ass handed to her. By playing so poorly, Bouchard allowed her opponent far too many opportunities for winners. That, combined with a handful of exceedingly well-played shots by Kvitova resulted in Bouchard being beaten badly. To suggest that Bouchard played even moderately well, but was beaten by the 'extraordinary overall play' of her opponent suggests it's YOU who knows nothing about tennis. The match was no where near ever being close largely because Bouchard came into it too inexperienced, over-confident, and her nerves got the better of her. When she smartens up a bit, and stops reading her own accolades, beating someone like Kvitova will be a very achievable goal. She has the talent and potential, but simply put, this time out she took a massive dump in her shorts. If she and her coach looked embarrassed afterwards, they both had good reason to be.
 
She is only 20 years old everyone ... How many women go from 56 rank to winning a grand slam in same fiscal year ? Give the girl time ..
 
Genie Bouchard lost decisively because she played a terrible match, plain and simple, both strategically and pragmatically, and clearly Saviano was out-coached. Stop being an apologist for her - it's not a patriotic crime to admit she sucked and got her ass handed to her. By playing so poorly, Bouchard allowed her opponent far too many opportunities for winners. That, combined with a handful of exceedingly well-played shots by Kvitova resulted in Bouchard being beaten badly. To suggest that Bouchard played even moderately well, but was beaten by the 'extraordinary overall play' of her opponent suggests it's YOU who knows nothing about tennis. The match was no where near ever being close largely because Bouchard came into it too inexperienced, over-confident, and her nerves got the better of her. When she smartens up a bit, and stops reading her own accolades, beating someone like Kvitova will be a very achievable goal. She has the talent and potential, but simply put, this time out she took a massive dump in her shorts. If she and her coach looked embarrassed afterwards, they both had good reason to be.

To me Genie's power quotient got exposed. I have discussed Genie's power quotient numerous times in my posts as far back as May 27 or May 29th. And have mentioned it a few times since then. Long before the final against Kvitova and long before Wimbledon even began. None of Genie's previous 6 opponents in this tournament hit as big a ball as Kvitova. None of Genie's previous 5 opponents hit as big a ball as Sharapova @ RG. Same could be said for the Austrlian Open against Li Na in the semis. On a grass court where its about 1st strike tennis against a player with a considerably greater power-quotient Genie wasnt going to win this match. Yes, she could have made adjustments. But I am not sure it would have made a difference. She was simply overpowered. She was on her back foot a lot and her aggressive court-positioning is not gonna help on grass against a big hitter. It only made it easier for Kvitova to penetrate her defenses. Its hard to generate your own power too when you dont have the time to take a full swing. If Genie plays her A game she still loses this match. Ive mentioned many times that the power quotient does concern me. Look at the list of winners of majors in the women's game in recent years - almost ALL of them have a higher power quotient than Genie does. Serena, Maria, Vika, Kvitova, Li Na, Bartoli, Stosur. Schiavone might one of the few exceptions but Schiavone has a completely different game from Genie. Schiavone has a ton of variety and court craft and that works well on the clay.

Kvitova simply took the racquet out of Genie's hands and didnt allow her to play. Genie doesnt get many cheap points on serve, not even on grass. So the fact that she didnt in the final is not unexpected. And Genie doesnt have the power to blast winners from the back of the court on a consistent basis. She needs to take the ball early and on the rise in order to rob her opponents of time and there in lies the problem because that is HARD to do on a grass court against a big hitter. Genie could have taken a step back to help her defend better but it would have sacrificed her offense. And playing defense isnt her game. I have watched a lot of her matches from last year and this year and I cant think of a single match that she won more on defense than on offense. Offense is the foundation of her game. Besides, grass rewards aggressive play so trying to defend on grass may not necessarily be a winning proposition.
 
To me Genie's power quotient got exposed. I have discussed Genie's power quotient numerous times in my posts as far back as May 27 or May 29th. And have mentioned it a few times since then. Long before the final against Kvitova and long before Wimbledon even began. None of Genie's previous 6 opponents in this tournament hit as big a ball as Kvitova. None of Genie's previous 5 opponents hit as big a ball as Sharapova @ RG. Same could be said for the Austrlian Open against Li Na in the semis. On a grass court where its about 1st strike tennis against a player with a considerably greater power-quotient Genie wasnt going to win this match. Yes, she could have made adjustments. But I am not sure it would have made a difference. She was simply overpowered. She was on her back foot a lot and her aggressive court-positioning is not gonna help on grass against a big hitter. It only made it easier for Kvitova to penetrate her defenses. Its hard to generate your own power too when you dont have the time to take a full swing. If Genie plays her A game she still loses this match. Ive mentioned many times that the power quotient does concern me. Look at the list of winners of majors in the women's game in recent years - almost ALL of them have a higher power quotient than Genie does. Serena, Maria, Vika, Kvitova, Li Na, Bartoli, Stosur. Schiavone might one of the few exceptions but Schiavone has a completely different game from Genie. Schiavone has a ton of variety and court craft and that works well on the clay.

Kvitova simply took the racquet out of Genie's hands and didnt allow her to play. Genie doesnt get many cheap points on serve, not even on grass. So the fact that she didnt in the final is not unexpected. And Genie doesnt have the power to blast winners from the back of the court on a consistent basis. She needs to take the ball early and on the rise in order to rob her opponents of time and there in lies the problem because that is HARD to do on a grass court against a big hitter. Genie could have taken a step back to help her defend better but it would have sacrificed her offense. And playing defense isnt her game. I have watched a lot of her matches from last year and this year and I cant think of a single match that she won more on defense than on offense. Offense is the foundation of her game. Besides, grass rewards aggressive play so trying to defend on grass may not necessarily be a winning proposition.

If this is the case, she may as well pack it in and call it a career now, as she will never hit harder than some of the other women on the tour. A true champion will learn to win regardless of playing surfaces, against a variety of differing types of opponents' strengths and styles of play. Until she learns to adapt her game to make best use of her own strengths, and minimize those of her opponents, she ain't going anywhere fast. Maybe her biggest problem is her coach. If he can't teach her how to take advantage of her natural talents to win against more powerful opponents, she should find a coach who can.
 
If this is the case, she may as well pack it in and call it a career now, as she will never hit harder than some of the other women on the tour. A true champion will learn to win regardless of playing surfaces, against a variety of differing types of opponents' strengths and styles of play. Until she learns to adapt her game to make best use of her own strengths, and minimize those of her opponents, she ain't going anywhere fast. Maybe her biggest problem is her coach. If he can't teach her how to take advantage of her natural talents to win against more powerful opponents, she should find a coach who can.

One thing I know is that in this era of women's tennis it seems to be difficult to win if you dont have the power. Unless Genie can get lucky and maybe there are some upsets in the draw and she gets to play 7 opponents that dont hit a big ball. Aga Radwanska is one of my favorite players on the women's tour because of her eclectic game and her use of changes of pace and spin. She has such variety in her game and plays good defense as well and has a very high tennis IQ. She did beat Vika in the Australian Open QF and Vika hits a bigger ball than does Aga BUT Aga has a ton of variety in her game much like Schiavone (though Aga is a better player).

The only thing about Nick Saviano that I dont like is this - remember before her final against Li Na in Melbourne Pammy Shriver interviewed him before the match and Pam asked Saviano about the matchup against Li Na and and Saviano basically said "it isnt about Li Na, it is about Genie....". He was asked a similar question before one of Genie's matches at Wimbledon (may have even been the final) and Saviano gave a similar answer. Its nice to have confidence in your charge and I understand that you want to play your game but you need to have a plan B if things arent working. You need to at least be willing to change up a losing pattern.

Genie does have a very good return of serve, she has a good FH and BH, she has that good swinging FH and BH volley, the mental toughness and work ethic. The only thing I see missing in her game is a dose of power. Her game isnt devoid of power but she doesnt possess elite power. I wont go so far as to say it will prevent her from winning a major but it certainly will make it harder without that elite power..

One thing you can do against more powerful opponents is use variety, change up the pace and use slices and drop shots etc. That is what Aga did against Vika in the AO QF. But that is not Genie's game. Genie doesnt have nearly as eclectic a game as Aga. Genie's game seems to be more similar to Sharapova with a couple minor exceptions - Shazza has elite power while Genie has just decent to good power. The other difference in their game is in the serve. It can be an issue for both but for different reasons. Shazza's serve can produce more free points aces/unreturnables but also more DFs. Since the shoulder issues began for her several years ago she has battled the service yips at times. Its less frequent than before but out of nowhere she can still throw in 2 DFs in a game or 3 in a span of 2 service games. I even saw a game in Paris where she committed 3 DFs in the same game - but she still found a way to win the game.

I do agree with your comment about the power though - she will likely never hit as big a ball as the big hitters on the tour presently or even in the coming years. Could she improve her strength and hit a slightly bigger ball than she does now? Yes. But I dont know if she will get to the point where her power-quotient will be elite. I dont think its impossible to win without elite power but it sure is hard in this era. All we need to do is look at the list of women who have won majors in recent years. When Hingis was winning slams she did it without power but she had variety , court-craft and IQ just like Radwanska does. But it seems as though after the Williams sisters arrived they injected power into the women's game and it seems to be here to stay. It was there before with the likes of Capriati, Davenport, Seles and others but the power quotient in women's tennis went up a notch when the Williams sisters arrived. Now it seems like we have more bit hitters on the women's tour than in the past.

BTW, demien2k5 I tried sending you a pm but it said you were over quota on your msgs or something. Can you clear out a few msgs so I can pm you?
 
Last edited:
Patrick McEnroe is being interviewed on TSN1050 right now and he said Kvitova just blew her off the court with Kvitova's artillery of weapons. P.Mac said this is mostly about Kvitova just playing her A game on grass. Genie didnt have a chance. That was what he just said.