Simona Halep will crush Sharapova in the final. Ever since Halep had her breast reduction surgery, her career has been on an upswing (Google her to see how enormous her jugs were before surgery, there was no way she could succeed carrying those funbags around). She"s got a great all-around game, i see her winning a few Grand Slam tournaments in her career. She and Genie could be the top 2 players in the world by this time next year.
Actually find Halep's GAME more aesthetically appealing than Genie's. Halep's footwork is TREMENDOUS. So light on her feet and so quick to move up to short balls. There is an elegance to her footwork. And she seems to be a natural mover on clay. You are right she does have a good all-around game. And one major difference between Simona and Genie is that Simona is the far steadier of the two players while Genie has a tendency to be streaky within matches.
Hard to make an direct apples-to-apples comparison between Simona and Genie in terms of their careers though b/c I feel like they are at different points in their maturation process and progression. Simona is a couple years older than Genie and has more matches under belt which makes it more difficult to make a fair comparison.
Aside from the fact that Genie has a Maple Leaf on her passport though I actually find Simona's game more fun to watch. There is a fluidity to her game that you don't see with Genie. Genie's game seems more mechanical and taught. I will say however that I am struggling to think of a player as young as Genie past or present that has had a better mental toughness quotient than Genie. She is very mentally strong. Love her fight and compete level.
Still feel like Shazza will beat Simona in the final though. Probability suggests that Simona will have some early nerves and butterflies in the 1st set given that it is her maiden slam final. Perhaps playing (and winning) a lot of tour events will help her with that but still a slam final is a different animal. To be fair though I will acknowledge that we have seen nerves from Shazza too during the fortnight. After Serena got bounced by Muguruza I think Shazza has started to feel more pressure b/c she knew that she could win this without having to play Serena. So we have seen her feel the pressure a bit more. That may also explain why some of her celebrations have been a bit more demonstrative this year at the French Open.
As for Genie I still feel like she has a lot of areas to work on her game. She is very streaky within matches. I feel like her shot-selection/decision-making at times could be better. She committed a LOT of unforced errors yesterday and that to me was a function of impatience (going for too much too soon in a rally instead of constructing points - what is the old saying? patience over power on clay), overplaying (there were times yesterday where she had Shazza out of position and Genie went for too fine a shot when she had more margin to work with), and sometimes just plain old execution. The serve definitely needs to improve as well. I'd like to see her beef it up a bit more so she can generate some more free points. The 2nd serve is an attackable shot too so she needs to work on that as well.
And definitely those 1-2 Genie service games in the 2nd and 3rd sets were killers. She was up 40-0 in both games and got broken. Fowler made a tremendous point during the telecast - we always talk about break point conversion rates but I agree with Chris that game point conversion rates against good returners is perhaps just as important a stat. And Shazza is not just a good returner-of-serve but a GREAT one.