No rock frontman will ever compare....

No!! Especially in regards to this topic when it's soooo fucking idiotic.. Are you gonna be as stupid to say Cobain was Mercury's equal in terms of songwriting and stage presence? Fuck off!! All the guy did was whine and bang on 3-4 chords on every song. He didn't even sing. He screamed. Yawn!! I guess with your logic you'll put his widowed bitch up there with him as well right?

In terms of songwriting I support his claim.

 
Good God! Am I ever glad u said it...
Another great showman was Diamond Dave of early Van Halen. Man, that guy was entertaining. He never claimed to be a good singer....that guy was a show!
Freddie is unmatched! Top 2 for sure!
Some of my personal faves:

Steve Perry (journey)
Bob Delp (Boston)
Lane Staley (Alice in Chains)
Bono
Robert Plant (Zeppelin)
Bowie
Sting (in The Police)
Prince

Save for Prince though, no one was as 'flamboyant' as mercury.
Cobain? Few neat little diddies....but couldn't even hold Mercury's gold plated jock!

"flamboyant" as Mercury?...Little Richard.............i know, im old..lol...
 
No!! Especially in regards to this topic when it's soooo fucking idiotic.. Are you gonna be as stupid to say Cobain was Mercury's equal in terms of songwriting and stage presence? Fuck off!! All the guy did was whine and bang on 3-4 chords on every song. He didn't even sing. He screamed. Yawn!! I guess with your logic you'll put his widowed bitch up there with him as well right?

Fuck no. His opinion on this topic is wrong and so are you.

Not only are you disrespect others you also can't read my posts and are making your own assumptions. I have not contributed about frontman to this thread or care you contribute about this. What I care is the way you disrespected the guys opinion because it was not inline with your thoughts or the majority. You could have said it differently. To say his comment is stupid says a lot about you and your lack of comprehension or your ability to carry a constructive discussion. For spreading your poison on terb I say to you Fuck You!
 
I was at the same show, Freddie was going through his Oscar Wilde phase. I wouldn't say Thin Lizzy was better, just different. They complimented each other, and correct me if I'm but that was the last time Queen took to the road with an opening act. And as a front man Phil Lynott is very under-rated. He paved the way for bassist frontmen to come.

I saw the Montreal Forum show. Lizzy were especially good that night.

When I say that Thin Lizzy were 'better', I'm referring to performance, not material. Lizzy played as if everyone had come to see them. Queen played a very polished show, which was probably virtually identical on every stop, with the name of the city changed during stage banter, (like most arena concerts today).

In at least one gig, (Boston), Queen opened the show, and Lizzy headlined. I know that from a 1977 article in New Musical Express, (or possibly from Trouser Press, but I think it was NME), in which the writer rated the two bands on ten consecutive gigs, (he said each band 'won' five times each). It's very possible that Lizzy regularly upstaging Queen had a lot to do with why they didn't tour with support bands after that.
 
No!! Especially in regards to this topic when it's soooo fucking idiotic.. Are you gonna be as stupid to say Cobain was Mercury's equal in terms of songwriting and stage presence? Fuck off!! All the guy did was whine and bang on 3-4 chords on every song. He didn't even sing. He screamed. Yawn!! I guess with your logic you'll put his widowed bitch up there with him as well right?

What are you talking about Cobain had fantastic stage presence!? He was probably the only guy selling millions of records while puking on stage destroying his guitar rig at the same time. Who said that fantastic had to be cheesy and not disgusting? Mercury was a better signer, no doubt (he could sing more octaves), but Cobain was a song write and a voice of his generation. He transformed rock music, changed it's direction; MTV was flooded with bands who were influenced almost exclusively by Nirvana in 1990s. To a degree his influence still lives on not only in music but in the attitudes people have towards this world, their music and even art.

The only other person I can think of, who had a similar effect on music is Lennon. Similar in a sense that after Nirvana music was never the same just like it wasn't after Beatles. These bands marked fundamental shifts in music. It doesn't mean that there cannot be any subtrends, big subtrend, but these guys set the overall trend.

That's just my perception of things based on my understanding of frontman's role and comparability of frontmen. I'm obviously biased as I grew up in the 90s I bet that hippies have a different perspective :)
 
Without a doubt....Freddie Mercury.

Arguably, Bono.

Freddie had the vocal range and power that Bono never had, but Bono has this religious ferver to his performances that Freddie never had.

Both are head and shoulders above the rest.

But greatest concert I have ever seen would probably go to Roger Waters - "The Wall". (Go figure.)
 
What are you talking about Cobain had fantastic stage presence!? He was probably the only guy selling millions of records while puking on stage destroying his guitar rig at the same time. Who said that fantastic had to be cheesy and not disgusting? Mercury was a better signer, no doubt (he could sing more octaves), but Cobain was a song write and a voice of his generation. He transformed rock music, changed it's direction; MTV was flooded with bands who were influenced almost exclusively by Nirvana in 1990s. To a degree his influence still lives on not only in music but in the attitudes people have towards this world, their music and even art.

The only other person I can think of, who had a similar effect on music is Lennon. Similar in a sense that after Nirvana music was never the same just like it wasn't after Beatles. These bands marked fundamental shifts in music. It doesn't mean that there cannot be any subtrends, big subtrend, but these guys set the overall trend.

That's just my perception of things based on my understanding of frontman's role and comparability of frontmen. I'm obviously biased as I grew up in the 90s I bet that hippies have a different perspective :)

Rock died with Kurt. He couldn't sing, he couldn't play guitar. It didn't matter. HIS pain was real.
 
Who could forget Johnny Rotten of the Sex Pistols? He had a malignant charisma that was mesmerizing. Granted he could not sing very well - basically hoarse screaming - but he and is band were hugely influential, revolutionizing music at the time as well as inspiring changes in attitudes and fashion.
 
Glad someone mentioned Eric Burdon. The man had a unique stage presence. His facial expression projected a rebellious anger. His voice is soulful and surprisingly deep for such a little guy. Watch some of his old clips with The Animals from Ed Sullivan and British pop shows of the mid sixties. Good stuff, especially "Please Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood".
 
Not only are you disrespect others you also can't read my posts and are making your own assumptions. I have not contributed about frontman to this thread or care you contribute about this. What I care is the way you disrespected the guys opinion because it was not inline with your thoughts or the majority. You could have said it differently. To say his comment is stupid says a lot about you and your lack of comprehension or your ability to carry a constructive discussion. For spreading your poison on terb I say to you Fuck You!

Well said
 
Glad someone mentioned Eric Burdon. The man had a unique stage presence. His facial expression projected a rebellious anger. His voice is soulful and surprisingly deep for such a little guy. Watch some of his old clips with The Animals from Ed Sullivan and British pop shows of the mid sixties. Good stuff, especially "Please Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood".

and "Im Crying"
 
He was a fine lead singer/guitar player , but he never had the stage presence of those listed thus far

That I agree with.
 
What are you talking about Cobain had fantastic stage presence!? He was probably the only guy selling millions of records while puking on stage destroying his guitar rig at the same time. Who said that fantastic had to be cheesy and not disgusting? Mercury was a better signer, no doubt (he could sing more octaves), but Cobain was a song write and a voice of his generation. He transformed rock music, changed it's direction; MTV was flooded with bands who were influenced almost exclusively by Nirvana in 1990s. To a degree his influence still lives on not only in music but in the attitudes people have towards this world, their music and even art.

The only other person I can think of, who had a similar effect on music is Lennon. Similar in a sense that after Nirvana music was never the same just like it wasn't after Beatles. These bands marked fundamental shifts in music. It doesn't mean that there cannot be any subtrends, big subtrend, but these guys set the overall trend.

That's just my perception of things based on my understanding of frontman's role and comparability of frontmen. I'm obviously biased as I grew up in the 90s I bet that hippies have a different perspective :)

As someone who grew up in the 90s I'm sorry man, I have to disagree. I liked Nirvana a lot but Kurt Cobain spawned a generation of guys staring at their sneakers onstage (hell, Eddie Vedder moved around more than him and that should tell you something). He did NOT have a presence. Creative songwriter for sure and a distinct voice, which can often trump pure vocal talent, but he is not in the pantheon of legendary frontmen.
 
it seems to me his voice is not as good as in recordings

they use the power of electronics to make his great voice

there are better voices when you take him out of the studio
 
I came here thinkin...if this isn't Freddie M...OP is terribly wrong....please forgive me...
 
To me, the best frontman is less about the vocals and more about stage presence and showmanship.
Guys like Mercury, Springsteen, Jagger, Bono were larger than life and got the crowd eating out of their hands. Some like Morrison, Iggy, Alice, Bowie, Daltry were up there as well.

But Elvis did it before them all, he could make your Grandma soak her panties through decades of swivelling his hips. :thumb: