No rock frontman will ever compare....

Three pages and not even a mention of Peter Gabriel. Shame on all of you. Thank goodness I arrived to fix that oversight.


And honourable mentions go to David St. Hubbins, Nigel Tufnel, and Derek Smalls.
In 2002, This Is Spinal Tap was deemed "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant" by the Library of Congress and was selected for preservation by the United States National Film Registry. - Wikipedia.
 
I actually like Peter Gabriel, but dude can barely sing...that's like having Gary Numan on the list.
 
If you're gonna cut Gabriel because he can't sing, then you gotta cut Jagger as well. Fair is fair.
 
I think the OP was referring to the combination of vocal ability, showmanship and strength of material.
I've had the good fortune to see a lot of the frontmen mentioned here:
Freddie: 3 times
Daltrey: Twice
Bowie: 4 times
Springsteen: Twice
Jagger: 7 times including 3 club shows
Bono: 4 times including a club show on "Boy". They weren't very good then.
Hutchence: 3 times all in clubs
Tyler: Before, after, and after again. First time on "Rocks".
Perry: 4 times
Plant: solo
Sting: In The Police, three times, once in a club on "Outlandos D'Amour"
Ozzy: Once in Sabbath, once solo
Ian Gillan: Once, Machinehead was the first album I ever bought.
Prince: Twice
Diamond Dave: 3 times with VH, one solo.
Cobain: in a club, twice.

Of these, Freddie was my favourite.
There are a few left out though, some of my faves:

Gord Downie: Before he started taking himself too seriously
Frankie Venom: If you saw Teenage Head you know what I mean.
Axl Rose: Before he completely lost the plot.
Joey Shithead: See Frankie Venom, sub DOA.

And one I didn't get to see, and won't.:frown:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kz_JGJuYL40
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hsppkBQhnYQ
 
What I wouldn't give to see Freddie Mercury live one more time. His stay presence was legendary.
It's true that the best do die first. The psycho in the sky makes sure of it.
But an equally big issue is the decline of modern music. Who in this day can compare with Mercury, Queen, supertramp, genesis, rush, Beatles, Alan parsons, Chicago, Elton John, Yes. I don't think any young music writers can compare
 
But an equally big issue is the decline of modern music. Who in this day can compare with Mercury, Queen, supertramp, genesis, rush, Beatles, Alan parsons, Chicago, Elton John, Yes. I don't think any young music writers can compare

Quality music is still there, you just got older.
 
I think this one beat it.


He was way overrated. Undeniably very popular but then so is Miley Cyrus.

Bruce
Elton
Bowie
Marc Bolan
Bryan Ferry
Daltrey
Mick
Hendrix
...and on and on.

FM was nothing original. Actually, he was a ripoff of Elton and Bowie and Marc Bolan and Ferry. They all came before FM.

Nah, this one is the winner. Stupidest. Comment. in. This. Thread.
 
ok , give us your list
Here's my (partial) list:

Black Keys
Jack White
North Mississippi All-Stars
Nick Cave
Ryan Adams
Iron and Wine
Felice Brothers
Ed Harcourt
The Eels
Drive-By Truckers
Thea Gilmore
Jason Isbell
My Morning Jacket
Alejandro Escovedo
Los Lobos
Dawes
Gillian Welch
Vampire Weekend
MGMT
Old Crow Medicine Show
Jon Spencer Blues Explosion
Gary Clarke Jr.
 
OK then. Who r the new musicians, artists who be making music with the same depth and meaning of lyrics and the same complex melodies of the 60s,70s,and 80s.
Let's name em. Don't just criticize us without evidence.
 
It's not that I'm comparing him with the one and only Freddie but Dave Gahan of depeche mode is a decent front/showman.
 
OK then. Who r the new musicians, artists who be making music with the same depth and meaning of lyrics and the same complex melodies of the 60s,70s,and 80s.
Let's name em. Don't just criticize us without evidence.

When people name them, you will go off on a geezer rant that they don't use the same technology as the musicians from back when you still had hair.

Of course every generation uses new technology. Electric guitars were a fad that had its heyday when you were a kid. New things are in fashion now. Talented musicians make use of the tools of their age, whatever they are.
 
OK then. Who r the new musicians, artists who be making music with the same depth and meaning of lyrics and the same complex melodies of the 60s,70s,and 80s.
Let's name em. Don't just criticize us without evidence.

you are only feeding a goldplated troll..he came here because the Politics section is quiet