Strange Criminal Charges

The law doesn't go after what "might be construed as under 18". Let's not make shit up. There is enough real shit out there.


You are completely wrong. It doesn't matter.

If the image depicts anyone who appears not to be of legal age, you're fucked.

The law goes even beyond that. Did you know that if you are caught with a drawing or text of an imaginary individual not to be legal age, you're fucked too.
 
If this had happened in Canada, most likely the guy, Little Lupe and the whole production company would've been thrown in Jail

so being in posession of a lil lupe video in canada would be illegal and get you thrown in jail ?
 
Seems pretty clear that a doll which is made to appear under 18 and is made for sexual purposes is illegal in Canada.

You can argue all you want about "no harm" being done to any actual minors, but the law - and public opinion - is pretty clearly on the other side of the discussion: witness the instant demonization of a certain former Professor in Alberta who made a comment out of context about one's taste in viewing pictures not causing harm. It is clear that even viewing such pictures is considered to contribute to the harm of minors who were used in the creation of such filth. The same arguments apply for a "doll" appearing under age.
 
Seems pretty clear that a doll which is made to appear under 18 and is made for sexual purposes is illegal in Canada.

You can argue all you want about "no harm" being done to any actual minors, but the law - and public opinion - is pretty clearly on the other side of the discussion: witness the instant demonization of a certain former Professor in Alberta who made a comment out of context about one's taste in viewing pictures not causing harm. It is clear that even viewing such pictures is considered to contribute to the harm of minors who were used in the creation of such filth. The same arguments apply for a "doll" appearing under age.
there is a huge difference between an under age child being raped by a full grown adult and horrid pictures being taken for the sake of being able to get a nut and a guy fucking a molded chunk of rubber.
 
i hope you don't think i am saying child porn is okay, that is not my intention. what i am trying to get across is that if a person legal age dressed in a manner that made the person appear under legal age it is not illegal. the way you are reading the law has to be wrong or you are omitting parts to prove a point. if not i could go get a picture of a perfectly legal porn star dressed to look like a young babysitter from google, post it here and me, you, everyone that clicks n the thread, fred, vbulletin, verizon (my isp), the girl, the guy that took the picture, the uploader of original pic, his isp and google would all be arrested for child porn even though she is legal age.
do you not see the flaw in that ?

Simon, baby, believe what you want.

And if you want to load your computer up with images of girls (or boys) who seem (to the police' and the judge - not to you) to be under 18, no doubt you will do that.

But your wishful thinking does not change the actual legal definition of child porn, as it is written down, for all to see, in the criminal code of Canada.

We can all tell that you are as appalled as the rest of us that, in Canada, a person is to be sent to prison, simply for possessing a drawing he drew himself, that depicts a child's genitals. You, too, are as shocked as we are that, if a pervert writes a story, simply for his own entertainment, that advocates sex with children, the pervert swings.

You can write stories about committing and getting away with murder, and have them published by the millions. But write a sex story involving children -- and you show it to nobody (until the police confiscate your computer) -- down you go.
 
Simon, baby, believe what you want.

And if you want to load your computer up with images of girls (or boys) who seem (to the police' and the judge - not to you) to be under 18, no doubt you will do that.

But your wishful thinking does not change the actual legal definition of child porn, as it is written down, for all to see, in the criminal code of Canada.

We can all tell that you are as appalled as the rest of us that, in Canada, a person is to be sent to prison, simply for possessing a drawing he drew himself, that depicts a child's genitals. You, too, are as shocked as we are that, if a pervert writes a story, simply for his own entertainment, that advocates sex with children, the pervert swings.

You can write stories about committing and getting away with murder, and have them published by the millions. But write a sex story involving children -- and you show it to nobody (until the police confiscate your computer) -- down you go.

dude i got no interest in younger women. i would never fuck anything under 30. whether you believe that or not is of no consequence to me.

all i am doing is pointing out the stupidity of your logic. by your logic and theory google.ca should be shut down and it's servers confiscated. every porn host site should be shut down. the creators of married wit children should be locked up. countless other people and films and just about everything. anyone that has ever asked for the school girl role play an sp should be locked up.

i get your extreme attitude and it's cool. i would stand just as hard with you if anyone ever tried anything on someone under 18. if they are over 18 it is legal to do what you want. if it isn't then shut down the internet and send all of canada to jail.
 
little_lupe_strips_009-450x600.jpg


now you all go to jail with google.
 
You are completely wrong. It doesn't matter.

If the image depicts anyone who appears not to be of legal age, you're fucked.

"Appears to be" is not the legal test. Don't make shit up. The code says "depicted as being under the age of eighteen". That is the test.
If a porn video shows a girl mentioning that she turns 18 next week it clearly meets the test.
If a video shows a 20yo with ponytails having sex it probably does not meet the test.
There sure is a grey area there but "appears not to be of legal age" can maybe trigger an investigation or lead to a charge being laid, but certainly it cannot secure a conviction.
 
"Appears to be" is not the legal test. Don't make shit up. The code says "depicted as being under the age of eighteen". That is the test.
If a porn video shows a girl mentioning that she turns 18 next week it clearly meets the test.
If a video shows a 20yo with ponytails having sex it probably does not meet the test.
There sure is a grey area there but "appears not to be of legal age" can maybe trigger an investigation or lead to a charge being laid, but certainly it cannot secure a conviction.

that changes everything. i thought we were talking about a girl that doesn't mention age and just appears (by appearance alone) to be under 18. if during the scene she comes out and says she is under legal age i can see how that would be illegal since it is now claiming to be child porn and aimed at the child porn audience.

when you were saying depicted i was under the impression that you meant just by appearance and not by saying "i am under 18". i agree with you with that point then.

the chunk of rubber didn't say it was under 18. maybe he has a midget fetish or the girl from the movie orphan had that illness that made her look like she was 12 years old but was really 30. maybe he likes chicks that have that disease.
 
"Appears to be" is not the legal test. Don't make shit up. The code says "depicted as being under the age of eighteen". That is the test.
If a porn video shows a girl mentioning that she turns 18 next week it clearly meets the test.
If a video shows a 20yo with ponytails having sex it probably does not meet the test.
There sure is a grey area there but "appears not to be of legal age" can maybe trigger an investigation or lead to a charge being laid, but certainly it cannot secure a conviction.

You are faced, here, with someone who is looking to seize on the slightest excuse, so he can hang his hat on the notion that schoolgirl fantasies are not illegal. So please tell the full story:

In Canada, child porn is defined as:
163.1(1)(a) a photographic, film, video or other visual representation . .
(i) that shows a person who is or is depicted as being under 18 and is engaged in or is depicted as engaged in explicit sexual activity,

As to videos of teenage/schoolgirl fantasies (which, as we all know, are very popular), if the video shows a person who is actually 20yo, but in the video she appears, from her visual appearance and the way the video is presented, to be under 18, you could be convicted for possession of that video.

The word depicted/depiction, in this context, means: "represented in a picture (including a moving picture)" The word also carries the sense of deliberate intent -- so if, in the representation, the 20yo only accidentally, and without any deliberate intent, appears to be a child, my guess is that would not get you convicted.

What if the video contains a verifiable and believable notice that the models are actually over 18, even though they appear to be children? Now, on the one hand, the video depicts someone who looks like a child, but on the other hand the video also makes it perfectly clear that she is not a child. My guess is that gets the possessors of the video out from under depicted. (Disclaimers like that appear sometimes in US-based videos - and my guess is that that makes it OK in Canada, too.)


Coming back to the chap with the doll -- again, in Canada, child porn is:
163.1(1)(a) a photographic, film, video or other visual representation . .
(i) that shows a person who is or is depicted as being under 18 and is engaged in or is depicted as engaged in explicit sexual activity, OR:
(ii) the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under 18.


The chap with the doll escapes under 163.1(1)(a)(i) because the doll is not a person. If the chap with the doll is to escape altogether, he also has to escape S.163.1(1)(a)(ii), under which the court would have to find that his doll is not a visual representation the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ . . which might be a problem for the chap.
 
Note also that Canadians are generally not uncomfortable with outlawing seemingly innocent shit:
163. (1) Every one commits an offense who
(a) makes, prints, publishes, distributes, circulates, or has in his possession for the purpose of publication, distribution or circulation any obscene written matter, picture, model, phonograph record or other thing whatever; or
(b) makes, prints, publishes, distributes, sells or has in his possession for the purposes of publication, distribution or circulation a crime comic.


This is the definition of obscenity, in Canada. The huge difference between that and child porn lies in the punishment for possession.

If you possess obscene stuff, you swing if you possess it for the purpose of publication, distribution or circulation.

If you possess child porn, on the other hand, you are faced with S.163.1(4), which says:
Every person who possesses any child pornography is guilty of (a) an indictable offense and liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years

To me, that smacks of punishing perverts - not because they do harm to children - but simply because they are perverts. That has no place in a civilized country, and certainly not in my Canada.
 
I don't have references (maybe someone wants to spend a couple minutes on google? hint, hint) but it's been brought to my attention that it is illegal in Australia to use an "A-cup" actress in porn because such a girl would qualify as depicting someone who is or appears to be underage.

I'm not saying what the law should or should not be, just what I'm told it is.