Strange Criminal Charges

isn't that like charging somebody for possession of illegal firearm when in reality they have a replica firearm?

as ridiculous as this is, i dont see how a doll is considered a child.
 
having sex with animals is also illegal yet you can buy a blow up animal at any sex shop. would the gov't rather him fuck a doll or a kid ? i am not sticking up for his behavior at all and glad he is behind bars for having child porn in his possession.
 
having sex with animals is also illegal yet you can buy a blow up animal at any sex shop. would the gov't rather him fuck a doll or a kid ? i am not sticking up for his behavior at all and glad he is behind bars for having child porn in his possession.

thats the thing here, its not really child porn.
a doll isn't a child, am i the only one who sees this?
 
thats the thing here, its not really child porn.
a doll isn't a child, am i the only one who sees this?

i agree with you the doll isn't porn. i thought it said in the article that he had child porn as well as the doll.

i see no difference between that and a blow up animal and if it keeps him from kidnapping and raping a kid then good.
 
having sex with animals is also illegal yet you can buy a blow up animal at any sex shop. would the gov't rather him fuck a doll or a kid ? i am not sticking up for his behavior at all and glad he is behind bars for having child porn in his possession.

Whatever you do in the privacy of your own home should not be of any concern to the public if you are not affecting the rights of any other individuals (children, women, dogs, whatever). My problem is that people seem a little slow to realize that if you give up rights to privacy for even socially unpopular behaviour - you then give it up for everything. You can't put your private choice of activity in your own home to popular or government scrutiny.

Speaking out of concern for kids - I can see that kiddy porn promotes a market in filth that directly results in child abuse so possession must be dealt with severely. However, if this guy can direct his sick behaviour on a doll instead of real children - should it be removed at the risk to real kids ? If he has the doll - will it just feed the perversion ? Successful prosecution of this doll case should be carefully weighed at what is best for the community. What do these creeps do if we remove any safe releases that doesn't involve kids or porn ?

I have no answers, I just hope the decision is based sound logical reasoning and not short sighted passions..
 
thats the thing here, its not really child porn.
a doll isn't a child, am i the only one who sees this?
You are not, that's one reason why I started the thread. If the philosophical basis for criminal law banning child pornography is to prevent the sexual exploitation of children how does a doll fit into that?
 
Whatever you do in the privacy of your own home should not be of any concern to the public if you are not affecting the rights of any other individuals (children, women, dogs, whatever). My problem is that people seem a little slow to realize that if you give up rights to privacy for even socially unpopular behaviour - you then give it up for everything. You can't put your private choice of activity in your own home to popular or government scrutiny.

Speaking out of concern for kids - I can see that kiddy porn promotes a market in filth that directly results in child abuse so possession must be dealt with severely. However, if this guy can direct his sick behaviour on a doll instead of real children - should it be removed at the risk to real kids ? If he has the doll - will it just feed the perversion ? Successful prosecution of this doll case should be carefully weighed at what is best for the community. What do these creeps do if there are no safe releases given to them.

I have no answers, I just hope the decision is based sound logical reasoning and not short sighted passions..
in the post of mine that you quoted i had actually typed up "i am glad he has the doll to fuck instead of raping someones kid" and deleted it so as not to come off as an ass or confrontational. the doll is a good idea and they make them regular in japan. i see no issue with a young looking piece of rubber. i thought he was arrested for having child porn on his computer and transporting it and in the process of arresting him they found the doll.

i agree with your statement of what happens behind closed doors as long as no one gets hurt as well. i do think children should be protected though since they can often not protect themselves. these dolls may be a good idea for aiding in that.
 
i thought he was arrested for having child porn on his computer and transporting it and in the process of arresting him they found the doll. .

I thought the doll itself was being treated as child porn - I wasn't aware of any other issues.
 
I thought the doll itself was being treated as child porn - I wasn't aware of any other issues.

i am delirious from bad pizza and may have read it wrong. i will have to read it again.
 
I thought the doll itself was being treated as child porn - I wasn't aware of any other issues.
That is what I read. "On Jan. 30, Canada Border Services officers were inspecting international mail at a processing facility in Mississauga when they flagged the package for a more detailed examination. The parcel was travelling from Japan to a home in St. John’s and they suspected it contained child pornography." What it contained was the doll.
 
i was wrong. the doll was considered child porn and he was charged with mailing obscene material. i thought he was caught for child porn and they found the doll. the doll isn't something to be worried about.
 
The four-foot-tall doll, Follett says, depicts a lifelike, prepubescent female with genitals and is considered child pornography.


The criminal code says:

163.1 (1) In this section, “child pornography” means
(a) a photographic, film, video or other visual representation, whether or not it was made by electronic or mechanical means,
(i) that shows a person who is or is depicted as being under the age of eighteen years and is engaged in or is depicted as engaged in explicit sexual activity, or
(ii) the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under the age of eighteen years

The officer seems to be sticking his neck way out, saying the doll "is considered child pornography". The questions, By whom?, and On what basis? come next.

Clearly, a doll is not a photograph, film or video. Now, we can agree that a a doll is a "representation" of a person. But you'd be hard-pressed to get anyone to agree that a doll is a "visual representation" of a person.

I think the guy walks.
 
I think the guy walks.

not before having his name dragged across the news and i am sure all his family and friends know he was arrested and will put 2 and 2 together.

why not if you really want an experience with a child just find a midget. same effect i would think.
 
having sex with animals is also illegal yet you can buy a blow up animal at any sex shop. would the gov't rather him fuck a doll or a kid ? i am not sticking up for his behavior at all and glad he is behind bars for having child porn in his possession.

Animal porn somehow is not illegal while child porn is.
 
The criminal code says:

163.1 (1) In this section, “child pornography” means
(a) a photographic, film, video or other visual representation, whether or not it was made by electronic or mechanical means,
(i) that shows a person who is or is depicted as being under the age of eighteen years and is engaged in or is depicted as engaged in explicit sexual activity, or
(ii) the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under the age of eighteen years

The officer seems to be sticking his neck way out, saying the doll "is considered child pornography". The questions, By whom?, and On what basis? come next.

Clearly, a doll is not a photograph, film or video. Now, we can agree that a a doll is a "representation" of a person. But you'd be hard-pressed to get anyone to agree that a doll is a "visual representation" of a person.

I think the guy walks.
I think a doll is very much a visual representation and the guy is looking at 90 days minimum.
 
The criminal code says:

163.1 (1) In this section, “child pornography” means
(a) a photographic, film, video or other visual representation, whether or not it was made by electronic or mechanical means,
(i) that shows a person who is or is depicted as being under the age of eighteen years and is engaged in or is depicted as engaged in explicit sexual activity, or
(ii) the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under the age of eighteen years

The officer seems to be sticking his neck way out, saying the doll "is considered child pornography". The questions, By whom?, and On what basis? come next.

Clearly, a doll is not a photograph, film or video. Now, we can agree that a a doll is a "representation" of a person. But you'd be hard-pressed to get anyone to agree that a doll is a "visual representation" of a person.

I think the guy walks.

This part has always made me scratch my head.Every porn shop in Canada i'd be willing to bet has vids of babysitter,schoolgirl,mom teen fantasy shots right on the front cover for public consumption.Would these not fit the criteria for this part of the charge?
 
Criminal Code of Canada:

163.1 (1) In this section, “child pornography” means
(a) a photographic, film, video or other visual representation, whether or not it was made by electronic or mechanical means,
(i) that shows a person who is or is depicted as being under the age of eighteen years and is engaged in or is depicted as engaged in explicit sexual activity, or
(ii) the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under the age of eighteen years

I think a doll is very much a visual representation and the guy is looking at 90 days minimum.
Clearly I can see arguing it either way.

However, the stigma society at large places on anything that even touches upon child pornography truly clouds the issue of whether or not this is a "visual representation." This is a similar sort of argument to that which has erupted before over paintings and drawings, sometimes by famous artists, as to whether the work is question is art or pornography.
 
This part has always made me scratch my head.Every porn shop in Canada i'd be willing to bet has vids of babysitter,schoolgirl,mom teen fantasy shots right on the front cover for public consumption.Would these not fit the criteria for this part of the charge?

little lupe made a career on looking like the underage babysitter. countless others in regular pop culture would be in jail as well.