Strange Criminal Charges

Is it? Secondly, as previously posted if the philosophical basis for criminal law banning child pornography is to prevent the sexual exploitation of children how does a doll fit into that, what child or children have been exploited?

But it is also against the law for someone to represent themselves as minor, even if they're not, in any kind of porno medium. No child has been exploited but same kind of thing.
I'm guessing the philisophical basis for that would be to discourage the appetite for it, not sure that it does.
 
So Google should be shut down as with all distributors according to that law.
You probably are technically correct at least with respect to distributors in canada but I suspect its not happening on a large scale as you suggest because Canadians would be embarrassed to show the whole world that they are crazier than Americans.

That being said I would not be surprised at all if one of those videos in which underage props are particularly noticeable would lead to a charge being laid. You better know what's on your laptop when you cross the border.
 
Last edited:
You probably are technically correct at least with respect to distributors in canada but I suspect its not happening on a large scale as you suggest because Canadians would be embarrassed to show the whole world that they are crazier than Americans.

That being said I would not be surprised at all if one of those videos in which underage props are particularly noticeable would lead to a charge being laid. You better know what's on your laptop when you cross the border.
all that is on my laptop is taboo with kay parker. she is very steamy.

as for being technically correct you can go to any porn shop in canada and get babysitter porn. the barely legal brand of hustler is available on every shelf in those same porn shops. he was caught for using the mail wrong but that same mail ships all sorts of things that are illegal or inappropriate. go to google.ca and type in young babysitter porn and you will only see results that don't appear to be legal but are.

with what you said the bars can be held responsible but there are laws in place fr bars that they are not legally allowed to serve a person to the point of intoxication. they can face severe fines and loss of liquor license if they do. it would be the same if you tried to say that car manufacturers are responsible are for drivers not wearing seat belts.
 
all that is on my laptop is taboo with kay parker. she is very steamy.

as for being technically correct you can go to any porn shop in canada and get babysitter porn. the barely legal brand of hustler is available on every shelf in those same porn shops. he was caught for using the mail wrong but that same mail ships all sorts of things that are illegal or inappropriate. go to google.ca and type in young babysitter porn and you will only see results that don't appear to be legal but are.

with what you said the bars can be held responsible but there are laws in place fr bars that they are not legally allowed to serve a person to the point of intoxication. they can face severe fines and loss of liquor license if they do. it would be the same if you tried to say that car manufacturers are responsible are for drivers not wearing seat belts.
I am not big on porn but as I understand the "teen" and "barely legal" terms refer to over 18, not to under 18.
The law doesn't go after what "might be construed as under 18". Let's not make shit up. There is enough real shit out there.
 
I am not big on porn but as I understand the "teen" and "barely legal" terms refer to over 18, not to under 18.
The law doesn't go after what "might be construed as under 18". Let's not make shit up. There is enough real shit out there.

i hope you don't think i am saying child porn is okay, that is not my intention. what i am trying to get across is that if a person legal age dressed in a manner that made the person appear under legal age it is not illegal. the way you are reading the law has to be wrong or you are omitting parts to prove a point. if not i could go get a picture of a perfectly legal porn star dressed to look like a young babysitter from google, post it here and me, you, everyone that clicks n the thread, fred, vbulletin, verizon (my isp), the girl, the guy that took the picture, the uploader of original pic, his isp and google would all be arrested for child porn even though she is legal age.

do you not see the flaw in that ?
 
i hope you don't think i am saying child porn is okay, that is not my intention. what i am trying to get across is that if a person legal age dressed in a manner that made the person appear under legal age it is not illegal. the way you are reading the law has to be wrong or you are omitting parts to prove a point. if not i could go get a picture of a perfectly legal porn star dressed to look like a young babysitter from google, post it here and me, you, everyone that clicks n the thread, fred, vbulletin, verizon (my isp), the girl, the guy that took the picture, the uploader of original pic, his isp and google would all be arrested for child porn even though she is legal age.

do you not see the flaw in that ?
do you not see a difference between a "young babysitter" and a "babysitter who is depicted as being UNDER 18"?
 
do you not see a difference between a "young babysitter" and a "babysitter who is depicted as being UNDER 18"?

according to google there is no difference. they show the same images for each search and all are of legal age. you and buttercup both have said that portraying an image of being underage is illegal.
 
According to the law there is.

169_.jpg


see you in jail buddy.
 
But it is also against the law for someone to represent themselves as minor, even if they're not, in any kind of porno medium. No child has been exploited but same kind of thing.
I'm guessing the philisophical basis for that would be to discourage the appetite for it, not sure that it does.
Not quite sure what you are saying. Yes you can't say I'm only 13 when you are actually 20 for 18 U.S.C. 2257 purposes. But if you did (without digging into that particular part of U.S. Code) what are you going to be charged with other than some form of making an unsworn false statement. Certainly any more serious charges are going to go away when you proved that you were actually 20.
 
169_.jpg


see you in jail buddy.

I am not sure how exactly she is depicted as being under the age of eighteen years, much less how can it be proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
It's not what you know, it's what you can prove.
6a00d8345275cf69e20133f49f6eb1970b-300wi
 
Not quite sure what you are saying. Yes you can't say I'm only 13 when you are actually 20 for 18 U.S.C. 2257 purposes. But if you did without digging into that particular part of U.S. Code what are you going to be charged with other than some form of making an unsworn false statement. Certainly any more serious charges are going to go away when you proved that you were actually 20.

I don't know the legalities, but I was under the impression that you cannot portray someone who is underage.
So even if you could prove that you were of age, you(or the producer) would still be charged.
I remember the discussion extending to what would happen in a case where age wasn't mentioned but the character dressed and acted so conspicuously
as to be clearly perceived as a minor.
 
I am not sure how exactly she is depicted as being under the age of eighteen years, much less how can it be proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
It's not what you know, it's what you can prove.
6a00d8345275cf69e20133f49f6eb1970b-300wi

not according to the law the way you and buttercup pointed out. she is legal age but portraying something else.

95dee1563630.jpg


add a couple more years on to your sentence.
 
I don't know the legalities, but I was under the impression that you cannot portray someone who is underage.
So even if you could prove that you were of age, you(or the producer) would still be charged.
I remember the discussion extending to what would happen in a case where age wasn't mentioned but the character dressed and acted so conspicuously
as to be clearly perceived as a minor.
I'm writing off the cuff. However, from memory alone the fact that you dress and look like you are a minor is a so what if you are in fact of age. This was the case in case with the case involving "Little Lupe" in the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico which Afterhours quoted above #33.


A problem here (which I am guilty of myself) is that we are hopping back and forth across the border and the law on this differs.
 
not according to the law the way you and buttercup pointed out. she is legal age but portraying something else.

95dee1563630.jpg


add a couple more years on to your sentence.
can you prove beyond a reasonable doubt that she is not portraying an 18yo?
 
I'm writing off the cuff. However, from memory alone the fact that you dress and look like you are a minor is a so what if you are in fact of age. This was the case in case with the case involving "Little Lupe" in the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico which Afterhours quoted above #33.


A problem here (which I am guilty of myself) is that we are hopping back and forth across the border and the law on this differs.

there is also a similar but different test for when you actually have sex with a minor who looked older
 
she is portraying a young babysitter. according to you legal age but portraying a young image is enough to go to jail.


Portraying her, or viewing her porn if she is portrayed to be under 18 is.

In fact, even searching for "under 18" porn is. Having it in your browsing history or linked to your google search history is enough.

One sure way to find out though!
 
Portraying her, or viewing her porn if she is portrayed to be under 18 is.

In fact, even searching for "under 18" porn is. Having it in your browsing history or linked to your google search history is enough.

One sure way to find out though!
i am on google typing in young hot babysitters. no age specification and certainly not under age. i am also not using my net for the searches. if the owner of the hotel gets arrested tomorrow i will feel bad lol.