Strange Criminal Charges

I think a doll is very much a visual representation and the guy is looking at 90 days minimum.


That's because you can think in the third dimension.

A "doll" is as much of a visual representation as a sculpture. That this doll is specifically marketed and designed to appeal to and meet sexual desires only reinforces that it is in violation of the statute.

Dennis Miller said it best long ago in one of his rant's. He said that if you EVER feel the inclination towards even feeling anything sexual towards a child, take one for the team. Lean into the pitch and let it hit you hard in the head. Just kill yourself and so society the favour you know in your heart you need to. Die a hero.


I would be happy if these people who feel this way simply used a few bucks to get therapy instead of buying sex dolls. Or spend their internet time researching and reading about how to deal with this way of thinking instead of looking for more porn.
 
A "doll" is as much of a visual representation as a sculpture. That this doll is specifically marketed and designed to appeal to and meet sexual desires only reinforces that it is in violation of the statute.
Is it? Secondly, as previously posted if the philosophical basis for criminal law banning child pornography is to prevent the sexual exploitation of children how does a doll fit into that, what child or children have been exploited?
 
Is it? Secondly, as previously posted if the philosophical basis for criminal law banning child pornography is to prevent the sexual exploitation of children how does a doll fit into that, what child or children have been exploited?

Counsel, note how the rest of the section shows the intention of the parliament to outlaw as much of grey territory as possible:

163.1 (1) In this section, “child pornography” means
(a) a photographic, film, video or other visual representation, whether or not it was made by electronic or mechanical means,
(i) that shows a person who is or is depicted as being under the age of eighteen years and is engaged in or is depicted as engaged in explicit sexual activity, or
(ii) the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under the age of eighteen years;
(b) any written material, visual representation or audio recording that advocates or counsels sexual activity with a person under the age of eighteen years that would be an offence under this Act;
(c) any written material whose dominant characteristic is the description, for a sexual purpose, of sexual activity with a person under the age of eighteen years that would be an offence under this Act; or
(d) any audio recording that has as its dominant characteristic the description, presentation or representation, for a sexual purpose, of sexual activity with a person under the age of eighteen years that would be an offence under this Act.

The bold part I think quite accurately describes a sex doll and clearly kills the potential defence. My prediction is 90 days jail and sexual offender registry for life.

Ps - had Nabokov lived in today's Canada and had he come to see a lawyer prior to publishing Lolita, the advice would have been: you have an "artistic merit" defence and some other defences available to you but proceed at your own peril. You could be arrested and charged and should that happen I will be happy to defend you. Make sure I have a contact number for your surety as you might need one for bail purposes. Please take the copy of the book with you, I am not quite comfortable having it in my office at this point.
 
Clearly I can see arguing it either way.

The doll in question is four-foot-tall and depicts a lifelike, prepubescent female with genitals.

The language in question is: a photographic, film, video or other visual representation . . the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under the age of eighteen years

The thing that might save the guy is other. The words "or other" implies that the "visual representation" must be like the "photographic, film, video" -- which all carry the sense that the subject thereof must be real.

On second thoughts, Nah. Maybe the guy swings.
 
little lupe made a career on looking like the underage babysitter. countless others in regular pop culture would be in jail as well.

You're suggesting that photos or videos that depict under-18 girls doing sexual things cannot be classed as child porn -- because you've seen examples of it.

That's like saying, because you've seen a few fights in bars, therefore assault can't be a crime.
 
The thing that might save the guy is other. The words "or other" implies that the "visual representation" must be like the "photographic, film, video" -- which all carry the sense that the subject thereof must be real.
Which as you can tell is more or less my perspective on it.
 
The doll in question is four-foot-tall and depicts a lifelike, prepubescent female with genitals.

The language in question is: a photographic, film, video or other visual representation . . the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under the age of eighteen years

The thing that might save the guy is other. The words "or other" implies that the "visual representation" must be like the "photographic, film, video" -- which all carry the sense that the subject thereof must be real.

On second thoughts, Nah. Maybe the guy swings.
It says that depiction does not have to be electronic or mechanical. Clearly then it means to outlaw stuff other than photos or videos, I.e. pictures and sculptures and cartoons etc.
The fact that they also cover written works as well as adults posing as kids clearly shows that they intend to cover fiction and not only cases where actual kid is involved.
 
Note also that Canadians are generally not uncomfortable with outlawing seemingly innocent shit:
163. (1) Every one commits an offense who

(a) makes, prints, publishes, distributes, circulates, or has in his possession for the purpose of publication, distribution or circulation any obscene written matter, picture, model, phonograph record or other thing whatever; or

(b) makes, prints, publishes, distributes, sells or has in his possession for the purposes of publication, distribution or circulation a crime comic.
 
You're suggesting that photos or videos that depict under-18 girls doing sexual things cannot be classed as child porn -- because you've seen examples of it.

That's like saying, because you've seen a few fights in bars, therefore assault can't be a crime.

lil lupe is a porn star that built a career on looking like an underage babysitter. her videos were filmed in the u.s and shown in canada and the u.s. she should be arrested. same with every girl the dresses proactively. not to mention every guy that fucks a girl. how many escorts are 18 or 19 and offer the school girl outfit. someone legal age pretending to not be.

then you get into pop culture with teen idol music people like mylee cyrus or selena gomez (i can't name them all) that are put in sexy outfits and paraded around. the people that do that would be arrested.

by the way you are interpreting the rules everyone should be in jail right now.

so he fucked a piece of rubber that looked young, who cares. next thing you are gonna try and do is tell me that fucking a real doll is rape.

now if the person in the picture/video is actually under 18 then yes it is child porn and the person who owns it should be arrested immediately.
 
Dennis Miller said it best long ago in one of his rant's. He said that if you EVER feel the inclination towards even feeling anything sexual towards a child, take one for the team. Lean into the pitch and let it hit you hard in the head. Just kill yourself and so society the favour you know in your heart you need to. Die a hero.
I would be happy if these people who feel this way simply used a few bucks to get therapy instead of buying sex dolls. Or spend their internet time researching and reading about how to deal with this way of thinking instead of looking for more porn.

I would imagine that "these people who feel this way", feel this way just as strongly as you or I feel attracted to adult girls and women. I don't suppose their desire to do sexual things with children is somehow less intense than ours, just because theirs is perverted and illegal.

You can't really think that we could be "cured" of our attraction to adult girls and women, if we used a few bucks to get therapy, or if we spent internet time reading about how to deal with our way of thinking.

I can't imagine anything that would have any chance at all of being effective to "cure" our attraction to adult girls and women.
 
Counsel, note how the rest of the section shows the intention of the parliament to outlaw as much of grey territory as possible:

163.1 (1) In this section, “child pornography” means
(a) a photographic, film, video or other visual representation, whether or not it was made by electronic or mechanical means,
(i) that shows a person who is or is depicted as being under the age of eighteen years and is engaged in or is depicted as engaged in explicit sexual activity, or
(ii) the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under the age of eighteen years;
(b) any written material, visual representation or audio recording that advocates or counsels sexual activity with a person under the age of eighteen years that would be an offence under this Act;
(c) any written material whose dominant characteristic is the description, for a sexual purpose, of sexual activity with a person under the age of eighteen years that would be an offence under this Act; or
(d) any audio recording that has as its dominant characteristic the description, presentation or representation, for a sexual purpose, of sexual activity with a person under the age of eighteen years that would be an offence under this Act.

The bold part I think quite accurately describes a sex doll and clearly kills the potential defence. My prediction is 90 days jail and sexual offender registry for life.

Ps - had Nabokov lived in today's Canada and had he come to see a lawyer prior to publishing Lolita, the advice would have been: you have an "artistic merit" defence and some other defences available to you but proceed at your own peril. You could be arrested and charged and should that happen I will be happy to defend you. Make sure I have a contact number for your surety as you might need one for bail purposes. Please take the copy of the book with you, I am not quite comfortable having it in my office at this point.

Canadian law on this ironically is much harder on the Vladimir Vladimirovich Nabokovs of this world than U.S. law certainly 163.1 (1)(c) is not criminal under U.S. Federal law 18 USC § 2256 (8)

“child pornography” means any visual depiction, including any photograph, film, video, picture, or computer or computer-generated image or picture, whether made or produced by electronic, mechanical, or other means, of sexually explicit conduct, where—
(A) the production of such visual depiction involves the use of a minor engaging in sexually explicit conduct;
(B) such visual depiction is a digital image, computer image, or computer-generated image that is, or is indistinguishable from, that of a minor engaging in sexually explicit conduct; or
(C) such visual depiction has been created, adapted, or modified to appear that an identifiable minor is engaging in sexually explicit conduct.
 
lil lupe is a porn star that built a career on looking like an underage babysitter. her videos were filmed in the u.s and shown in canada and the u.s. she should be arrested. same with every girl the dresses proactively. not to mention every guy that fucks a girl. how many escorts are 18 or 19 and offer the school girl outfit. someone legal age pretending to not be.

then you get into pop culture with teen idol music people like mylee cyrus or selena gomez (i can't name them all) that are put in sexy outfits and paraded around. the people that do that would be arrested.

by the way you are interpreting the rules everyone should be in jail right now.

so he fucked a piece of rubber that looked young, who cares. next thing you are gonna try and do is tell me that fucking a real doll is rape.

now if the person in the picture/video is actually under 18 then yes it is child porn and the person who owns it should be arrested immediately.
Your laws make too much common sense. Canadian parliament meanwhile is larger than common sense.

Btw little lupe recently gave testimony on a child porn trial in Puerto Rico as to her age and saved a guy from jail. http://www.nypost.com/p/news/international/trial_star_is_porn_fdAVQvqxVbPZuWPQ9XrukN

Not sure if the result would have been the same had it happened in Canada.
 
Afterhours, Counsel, seemingly this man's case rests upon how courts have interpreted the following:

163.1 (1) (a) a photographic, film, video or other visual representation, whether or not it was made by electronic or mechanical means,

and

163.1 (1) (ii) the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under the age of eighteen years;

Therefore is visual representation really another term for photograph, film, video or drawing or does it cover statues and dolls. Likewise is depiction another term for photograph, film, video or drawing or does it cover statues and dolls. If this was all De Novo I'd haul in a dictionary and try to argue for first definitions, but I presume that there is case law regarding this.
 
Your laws make too much common sense. Canadian parliament meanwhile is larger than common sense.

Btw little lupe recently gave testimony on a child porn trial in Puerto Rico as to her age and saved a guy from jail. http://www.nypost.com/p/news/international/trial_star_is_porn_fdAVQvqxVbPZuWPQ9XrukN

Not sure if the result would have been the same had it happened in Canada.

if the persons age is on file and listed as over 18 there is nothing illegal about it even if they are wearing diapers and sucking a soother. the videos are out there and fully legal to watch. if what you are saying is true then google should be arrested for having links to fully legal women portraying young babysitters. they are distributors by the meaning you are posting.

also lupe is not really a great choice since she was arrested and deported a few years ago for being involved in child porn but she was legal when she made her way to the u.s and canada.

all i am saying is over 18 is legal age to view regardless how they dress. if it wasn't then the entire porn industry would be shut down. as would every search engine that provides links to it.
 
Afterhours, Counsel, seemingly this man's case rests upon how courts have interpreted the following:

163.1 (1) (a) a photographic, film, video or other visual representation, whether or not it was made by electronic or mechanical means,

and

163.1 (1) (ii) the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under the age of eighteen years;

Therefore is visual representation really another term for photograph, film, video or drawing or does it cover statues and dolls. Likewise is depiction another term for photograph, film, video or drawing or does it cover statues and dolls. If this was all De Novo I'd haul in a dictionary, but I presume that there is case law regarding this.

Not sure whether there is case law on statues but I don't see how can one argue with a straight face that statues are not visual depiction. Since times immemorial Romans were using statues as visual representation of their victories etc etc.

does this law make sense? - I don't know. Is the accused caught by the provisions? - I would bet good money that he is. Even if the accused was blind.
 
if the persons age is on file and listed as over 18 there is nothing illegal about it even if they are wearing diapers and sucking a soother. the videos are out there and fully legal to watch. if what you are saying is true then google should be arrested for having links to fully legal women portraying young babysitters. they are distributors by the meaning you are posting.

also lupe is not really a great choice since she was arrested and deported a few years ago for being involved in child porn but she was legal when she made her way to the u.s and canada.

all i am saying is over 18 is legal age to view regardless how they dress. if it wasn't then the entire porn industry would be shut down. as would every search engine that provides links to it.
You realize that porn industry depends on US law and not on Canadian law.

And it's not what I'm saying or what I'm posting, the law is there for you to see and read on canlii or wherever.
 
does this law make sense? - I don't know. Is the accused caught by the provisions? - I would bet good money that he is. Even if the accused was blind.
I'm thinking about it more as we go back and forth and legally as to Canada believe you are probably correct. As to the purpose of criminal law I'm not at all sure that this isn't a real over-reach.
 
You realize that porn industry depends on US law and not on Canadian law.

And it's not what I'm saying or what I'm posting, the law is there for you to see and read on canlii or wherever.
Which is why you see a 18 U.S.C. 2257 "Record-Keeping Requirements Compliance Statement" on most such videos.
 
Reflecting on "visual" argument I think if one considers importing a child sex doll to Canada one better ensure that she has a face of a 80yo grandma or just be so ugly that the (terb) experts would confirm that she can only be fucked in the dark. ;)
 
You realize that porn industry depends on US law and not on Canadian law.

And it's not what I'm saying or what I'm posting, the law is there for you to see and read on canlii or wherever.
So Google should be shut down as with all distributors according to that law.