No Court, in any place that actually exists on this planet, is going to look at her posting history and think that 007 caused her any emotional trauma - based solely on what was posted in public threads on this form (007 if you have been harassing her in PMs all bets are off).
Or if posts that were clearly threatening were posted under another nick from the same IP?
colt, you might be right. I was told by very high price help that I need to talk to a well recognized expert to determine injury. I tried to just ignore him but he continued to vent his lies and insults.
As for the notion that she can sue anywhere other than in Canada - she is dreaming. To the extent that 007 did anything he did it here in Canada - the fact that she and her computer may or may not travel from one jurisdiction to another is not going to be enough for another Court to take jurisdiction
You might be right. Your advice re jurisdiction does not match other advice. Of course if it happened the lawyers can argue it till a decision is made.
As for the notion that it is legally "simple" to "sue" Fred and other ISPs in order to identify 007 - it is not. Any order she gets would have to be enforceable in Canada and Canadian courts will not enforce an order that could not be obtained in Canada. In Ontario it is no simple thing to start suing (actually the correct term would be serving motions on them) third parties merely because you want to identify someone you might want to sue.
That is nice. So what? Who cares about Ontario or Canada.
As for her original basis for feeling "threatened" let us be very clear that she cannot establish any expectation of privacy on the internet - it does not exist. 007 made use of information she willingly (with great bravado) provided on a public forum and combined it with information obtained on another perfectly legal and publically accessible website to call b.s. on her claims as to her identity and location. There is nothing in those actions that would even remotely justify damages of any kind or that would survive a motion for summary judgment. Until 007 starts hacking her email or TERB to get her ISP or doing anything illegal there is nothing that will justify a tort. It is no different than someone saying they are flying over the arctic circle at a particular moment in time and someone accessing one of those websites that depict air travel all over the globe to prove they are lying.
You might be right. I guess it is up to the courts to decide
You make interesting points and I would guess that they apply in your world. Your information just does not match the requirements I have been quoted. Yes opposing council can argue everything you said. And my lawyer argues my side.
Yes some of this could be international case law. So?
Even things like determining an IP, Given vagaries in international laws, it just does not seem that much of an issue. Although I guess checking if any of the threatening PMs came from the same IP could be considered rude.
Bottom line.... why are you wasting our time? I will not be allowed to use litigation. The L&M even said it in Terb land.

