The Nazis Win World War Two?

True, you can't occupy a country where the vast majority of the population hates you.

But there are some, limited examples, of this. Tibet, in China, comes to mind. The Kurds in Iraq. And not all the South Vietnamese who were loyal to the US were able to get out; I don't think anyone envies their position.

Absolutely true, however, Tibet is murkey at best. The South Vietnamese are now running the place, and the Kurds, well, they were never a country as far as I am aware. They are more like an ethnic group within several different countries.

I look at eastern europe and Germany in particular. The Soviet Union wanted to create its own empire. They built walls, they placed their own puppet governments in charge, they backed up their puppets militarily, but eventually they simply could not hang on.

It is the same with the USA - they were crushed in Vietnam, are being crushed in Afghanistan and just got the hell out of Iraq (wisely) years before they were supposed to. If the Americans don't have the political will or resources to conquor a country, no-one does. As we saw in Europe under the Soviets, all the populace needs to do is resist ever so slightly and eventually the whole thing comes crumbling down.

Even the mighty British empire - they not only conquored, but the colonized by settling their own people into a foreign country but eventually the logistics and the cost of it ended the greatest empire the world has ever seen.

I'll give you an example.

My uncle was a cop. I asked him one time about why sometimes you see instances of it taking 12 cops to arrest one guy. You have one normal sized guy and 12 burly cops on top of him kicking the shit out of him in order to bring the guy in. My uncle said, "that's because all the average sized guy has to do is resist and it becomes a nightmare trying to subdue him. Pull an arm away, pull a leg away, twist, turn, it takes 12 cops to bring him in"

It's the same with trying to conquor and control another country.

As we have seen time after time, all a country has to do is resist and the big boy will have to commit so many men and so many resources that the big boy simply cannot keep it up.

It would have been the same if Nazi Germany had succeeded in conquoring all of Europe.

It may have taken 50 years, but eventually they would have to let go because they simply would not have had the clout to maintain control.
 
The Axis lost because of Japan. They attacked the US even though they knew the US was too big an enemy. The Pearl Harbour attack was what swayed the American public to get out of the splendid isolation and join the Allied forces in the European and the Pacific front.

I disagree.

The Nazis lost the second they attacked the Soviet Union.

It was the Soviets who defeated the Germans, not the Western Allies.

Don't get me wrong, the Western allies had a huge part it in the defeat of the Axis, however, it was the Russians who did the lions share of the heavy lifting.

The Battle of Kursk was 2 weeks in the summer of 1943 and more than a million Russians and a million Germans fought to the death.

That was just one battle
 
There's a movie about this. I can't remember the title, but after all the jews are dead, the Nazis start knocking off everyone who knows about it because they are about to start diplomatic relations with the USA.

I think it starred Rutger Hauer as an SS officer in the mid-70's investigating a murder and he finds out about the "holocaust".
 
I disagree.

The Nazis lost the second they attacked the Soviet Union.

It was the Soviets who defeated the Germans, not the Western Allies.

Don't get me wrong, the Western allies had a huge part it in the defeat of the Axis, however, it was the Russians who did the lions share of the heavy lifting.

The Battle of Kursk was 2 weeks in the summer of 1943 and more than a million Russians and a million Germans fought to the death.

That was just one battle

If it wasn't for the Lend-Lease program the Russians wouldn't have had enough material or machinery to stop the Germans in 1941. Just in airpower alone the USA sent over 500 P-39 AirCobras to the USSR before the end of 1941.
 
There's a movie about this. I can't remember the title, but after all the jews are dead, the Nazis start knocking off everyone who knows about it because they are about to start diplomatic relations with the USA.
There have been several alternative histories about the Nazi’s winning WW2. However, I think your thinking of the movie Fatherland based on the novel by the same name written by Robert Harris.
 
A map of Manhattan, if the Nazis had conquered it, and Life magazine's theoretical invasion map of America by the Axis.

Melissa Gould's Neu-York, "an obsessively detailed alternate-history map, imagining how Manhattan might have looked had the Nazis conquered it in World War II".

In 1942, Life magazine speculated about what an Axis invasion of North America might look like.

http://kottke.org/11/11/if-the-nazis-conquered-america
 
Agreed, but note how quickly they rebuilt their countries POST-WW2. Some in the West thought that Iraq and Afghanistan could do the same POST-Saddam and POST-Taliban but Iraq and Afghanistan are still a bloody mess.

I think history can provide some answers. I wonder if a similar situation like Iraq and Afghanistan occurred in dark ages Europe.
 
A map of Manhattan, if the Nazis had conquered it, and Life magazine's theoretical invasion map of America by the Axis.



http://kottke.org/11/11/if-the-nazis-conquered-america

Chucklesome stuff. Nazi Germany had little or no surface navy, aside from a dozen or so big behemoths which were supposed to raid convoys in the Atlantic and which were either sunk by the RN shortly after they put to sea or penned in harbour the entire war. And the RN and USN outnumbered the Japanese Navy 3:1. Ain't no invasion on the USA ever takin' place with those odds. And the French Navy was sunk in port by the RN in 1940 to stop the Germans getting their paws on it.
 
If it wasn't for the Lend-Lease program the Russians wouldn't have had enough material or machinery to stop the Germans in 1941. Just in airpower alone the USA sent over 500 P-39 AirCobras to the USSR before the end of 1941.

IIRC, Lend-lease to the USSR started in '42 and the Aircobras started in late '42 or '43. Eventually, about 5,000 were sent to Russia. The Brits and Yanks hated the P-39's, but the Ivans loved them. The Russians also got Hurricanes, which were already obsolete by '42; P-40's, which the Russians thought were so-so; and about 1,000 Spitfires. In fact, the Russians were flying about as many Spits as the Brits by '45. They used them for high altitude interception over Leningrad and other priority targets. The Spits weren't robust enough to take the grass strips the Red Air Force flew out of at the front lines.

The Russians also got B-25 Mitchells which were used as heavy bombers by the Red Air Force which was far more into tac ground support and frontline air superiority than strategic bombing. And also A-20 Douglas twin-engine light bombers for taking out bridges and junctions.

The Russians also got 100's of Shermans. What the Russians really loved though were jeeps and Studebaker deuce and a halfs. They ran all their big offensives in 44 and 45 with US made supply echelon vehicles. Made a big difference. The Germans couldn't match the Russians new mobility in rough terrain - i.e. most of Eastern Europe - and the Ivans could out maneuver them.
 
If it wasn't for the Lend-Lease program the Russians wouldn't have had enough material or machinery to stop the Germans in 1941. Just in airpower alone the USA sent over 500 P-39 AirCobras to the USSR before the end of 1941.

Myth.

Much of the machinery didn't arrive until the Soviet Union was well on its way to defeating the Germans.

p.s., this myth is often cited to make Westerners feel better about having the Soviet Union bear the brunt of the war.
 
As we have seen time after time, all a country has to do is resist

Of course when the Irish resist they are immediately branded terrorists. BTW: When will the Orange Scots be leaving Northern Ireland.

Iraq, Afghanistan and VietNam were basically civil wars with the Americans taking sides. Even with the Americans gone, the killing in VietNam and now in Iraq and Afganistan still continued.
 
I'm surprised nobody has brought up the theory of "if the Germans had waited three more years (or more) would that have changed the outcome of World War II"....


Before the war Germany was one of the few countries building up its military while many countries were scaling back....Some of Hitler's generals had advised him to wait so the military could be fully prepared and perhaps be able to use the next generation of weapons their scientists and engineers were developing....


A few more years could have meant that the Germans could have fully developed and widely produced their next-pgen weapons and as a result effectively used cutting edge weapons such as ME262 fighter jet and the V2 rocket in the war...

Obviously the Americans had their own weapons in development (none bigger than their "atomic" bomb") so its an interesting debate....
 
I don't think the majority of the Germans and Japanese were intelligent and rational during that conflict. Look at all the racial eugenics nonsense they believed in. Read Mein Kampf, many in the Nazi Party actually believed that ideologistic trash. Familiarize with yourself on the medical experiments conducted by the SS and the Japanese in Unit 731.

Some got caught and executed for their crimes. But I'm sure many were released a short time later after being "re-educated".

You can say whatever you like, but Ameicans and Soviets stole a hell of alot of German technology when they took Germany.
 
As Overy points out, one of the reasons the allies won was their mass production of weapons. The Germans had superior technology, but they were swamped by the allies because the allies mass produced their weapons. I don't think a delay would necessarily have helped the Germans unless they used that delay to mass produce weapons. To win the Germans should have planned more strategically and mass produced their weapons.
 
As Overy points out, one of the reasons the allies won was their mass production of weapons. The Germans had superior technology, but they were swamped by the allies because the allies mass produced their weapons. I don't think a delay would necessarily have helped the Germans unless they used that delay to mass produce weapons. To win the Germans should have planned more strategically and mass produced their weapons.

What about allies outnumbering them ~ 5 to one. Still Germany able to carry on fighting being a landlocked country with no harbour is quite a feat.
 
Of course when the Irish resist they are immediately branded terrorists. BTW: When will the Orange Scots be leaving Northern Ireland.

Iraq, Afghanistan and VietNam were basically civil wars with the Americans taking sides. Even with the Americans gone, the killing in VietNam and now in Iraq and Afganistan still continued.

Sure, now that the farms are up and running, you want back in.
 
Chucklesome stuff. Nazi Germany had little or no surface navy, aside from a dozen or so big behemoths which were supposed to raid convoys in the Atlantic and which were either sunk by the RN shortly after they put to sea or penned in harbour the entire war. And the RN and USN outnumbered the Japanese Navy 3:1. Ain't no invasion on the USA ever takin' place with those odds. And the French Navy was sunk in port by the RN in 1940 to stop the Germans getting their paws on it.
It was in large measure a combination of fear and "rally to the flag," rather than any rational analysis.

In the same way much of World War II rationing in the U.S. and to a lesser degree Canada was entirely about the government attempting to induce a sense of shared sacrifice among the population rather than any true shortage of goods, particularly by late 1943.