The Nazis Win World War Two?

It was in large measure a combination of fear and "rally to the flag," rather than any rational analysis.

In the same way much of World War II rationing in the U.S. and to a lesser degree Canada was entirely about the government attempting to induce a sense of shared sacrifice among the population rather than any true shortage of goods, particularly by late 1943.
The rally to the flag came out of how broke Germany was after WW1 where they were forced to pay reparations to those they attacked. That's why in the second world war the allies stuck round to rebuild Germany and Japan. I suppose that was what was suppose to happen in Iraq and Afghanistan. There was a tim hanks movie while ago about a real life senator that funded the afghans against the soviets. Millions were approved to fund arms to rebels but 100k wasn't approved to fund building of schools, and we all know what happened next for the country. Moral of this story, to the victors comes the responsibility to rebuild the conquered unless one day they may rise up o exact their revenge.
 
Still Germany able to carry on fighting being a landlocked country with no harbour is quite a feat.

Bear mind that Germany was on a war footing since 1934 and they built up their military during that period. In contrast the American military was manned (womanned?) by "citizen soldiers" who were schoolteachers and accountants as late as December 8, 1941.
 
Still Germany able to carry on fighting being a landlocked country with no harbour is quite a feat.

Landlocked? How the hell do you figure that?
 
May I suggest that discussing the book without most of us having read it is not the most brilliant of ideas.

What! There's a book? I thought this was all conjecture. Imagine if the Nazis invaded the Middle East and ran into 30 billion suicide bombers. They deserve each other.
 
This is where the West made a huge mistake in Iraq and Afghanistan. The West saw how quickly Japan and Germany rebuilt their countries and thought Iraq and Afghanistan could do the same forgetting that the Germans and Japanese are extremely intelligent, rational, competent and hardworking people whereas those "other guys" are not.

Eh.

The rationale behind the Iraq Invasion was that Iraq was (as hard as this is to believe by some) the most advanced country of the Arab Middle East. It was already well into nationalism: it was just a question of steering that nationalism to where the West wanted it. By steering Iraq, you could theoretically steer all of the Arab Middle East and by steering the Arabs you would steer Islam. And to a large degree, it has worked. I'll argue all day long that the Arab Spring and even the voluntary democratic reforms by many Middle Eastern nations in the last decade would not and could not have happened without the Iraq Invasion. Short term, the Arab Spring is going to be "bad" for the West. Extremist groups are going to get "elected" (even legitimately elected by a populace that has the franchise for the first time). But those groups are going to screw up, and will either get elected out of office or thrown out by the populace. Long term, the totalitarian regimes that will likely take over in Egypt and Libya (and other "Spring" nations) will get toppled in turn, and on a shorter cycle now that the people are aware of their power. That's the long term recipe for, maybe, some kind of democracy.

An Arab/Islamic democracy doesn't necessarily have to look like a Western democracy. Japan's democracy doesn't look like a Western democracy. Not if you really pay attention to it. As long as Arab nations have some kind of internal semi-peaceful political discourse rather than venting all political discourse externally (which is what terrorism really is), then that's a "win" for the West. I couldn't care less if the Middle East "likes" us or not. As long as their crazies are standing on the Iraq/Iranian/Saudi/Egyptian equivalent of Yonge, spouting nonsense, who cares?

Afghanistan is just a mess. They're still stuck in tribalism. They're decades away from even developing nationalism. But they were protecting bin Laden, and the West had to invade, if only to put bin Laden on the run. That's just bad political circumstances.
 
that Iraq was (as hard as this is to believe by some) the most advanced country of the Arab Middle East.

I thought Lebanon was the most advanced country in the ME until it imploded. Right now, it appears Jordan is the most rational country of a bad bunch.

BTW: Are the Iranians better off now than they were 35 years ago under the Shah?
 
Landlocked? How the hell do you figure that?

Figurativly. For all practical purposes their minimal coastline to the north did not provide any real benefit. The english Channel is shallow and at the time was heavily mined. I used the term harbour to describe direct access to any major ocean in context of the war.
 
I thought Lebanon was the most advanced country in the ME until it imploded. Right now, it appears Jordan is the most rational country of a bad bunch.

BTW: Are the Iranians better off now than they were 35 years ago under the Shah?

Advanced in what sense? as far as money and economic prosperity is concerned, the gulf states are light years ahead of others.
 
What about allies outnumbering them ~ 5 to one. Still Germany able to carry on fighting being a landlocked country with no harbour is quite a feat.

I agree with the impressiveness of the first point. The second, not so much.

Germany had lost most of its colonies during WWI (and it didn't have many to begin with even then, being late to the game of colonialism) so it didn't have the dependency on foreign oceanic imports like say, Great Britain or particularly Japan.

That said, Germany was heavily dependent on imports from throughout Europe and in particular from the Scandinavian countries. So it was vital that Germany maintained control of the Baltic Sea (something made much easier by the relatively narrow entrance to the Atlantic). When you don't have to provide naval protection to merchant fleets sailing around the world, that's effectively a "force multiplier" of your otherwise small navy.
 
If it wasn't for the Lend-Lease program the Russians wouldn't have had enough material or machinery to stop the Germans in 1941. Just in airpower alone the USA sent over 500 P-39 AirCobras to the USSR before the end of 1941.

Horse hockey.

The Americans gave the Soviets about 11 billion bucks worth of military hardware.

The Russians put together the biggest military machine the world has ever seen and obliterated the Germans. Air Forces don't win wars. Armies do.
 
Chucklesome stuff. Nazi Germany had little or no surface navy, aside from a dozen or so big behemoths which were supposed to raid convoys in the Atlantic and which were either sunk by the RN shortly after they put to sea or penned in harbour the entire war. And the RN and USN outnumbered the Japanese Navy 3:1. Ain't no invasion on the USA ever takin' place with those odds. And the French Navy was sunk in port by the RN in 1940 to stop the Germans getting their paws on it.

Quite correct.

I don't think Britain was ever in danger of being invaded. First, the Germans couldn't knock out the RAF, and second, they would have needed to get past the RN - which was frankly mission impossible for them.
 
Air Forces don't win wars. Armies do.
In terms of WW II far more true than today, however, a major lesson of Iraq is that to win the "after the war" you still need boots on the ground. Most of the problems of the past eight years were due to an inadequate number of "boots on the ground" in the first year. Further, "purple" is a great colour, no service can go it alone.

It has been said of the U.S. military since the Second World War that the Army was the most willing to be joint i.e “purple” (Green + Blue), the Navy the least so since the Navy already had an air force and an army (the U.S. Marine Corps) of its own.
 
I thought Lebanon was the most advanced country in the ME until it imploded.

Right, but we aren't talking about the early 1980s as the timeframe for the Iraq Invasion.

Right now, it appears Jordan is the most rational country of a bad bunch.

If the West were looking to push a monarchical state with "good rule", Jordan would be the best bet by far. It doesn't hurt that the Hashemite kings of Jordan have at least token respect of both Sunnis and Shi'ia Muslims, and have a pretty "Western" outlook. That said, there are all kinds of political and social reasons why the West can't push for that. And practical ones. The competition represented by a unified Islamic state under a Hashemite king/Caliph isn't to the West's advantage, even if that state is "friendly" and part of the modern world stage.

BTW: Are the Iranians better off now than they were 35 years ago under the Shah?

No, but Iran isn't any more a democracy today than it was under the Shah. There are window dressing elections, but the Ayatollahs reign there. The theory is that 21st century revolutions will be easier to start and harder to stop. That doesn't mean they'll always be successful, but that the self-correcting process where bad leaders are thrown out while (hopefully) good leaders stay in power becomes more energetic, with a higher rate of turnover.
 
Quite correct.

I don't think Britain was ever in danger of being invaded. First, the Germans couldn't knock out the RAF, and second, they would have needed to get past the RN - which was frankly mission impossible for them.
On the contrary, if the Luftwaffe had realized how vital the radar stations were, and how desperately over stretched Fighter Command was and had changed strategies, things could have been quite different. If the Luftwaffe had done that and now had air superiority over the channel the R.N. wouldn't have been able to effectively counter any attempt at a landing.
 
Horse hockey.

The Americans gave the Soviets about 11 billion bucks worth of military hardware.

The Russians put together the biggest military machine the world has ever seen and obliterated the Germans. Air Forces don't win wars. Armies do.

I guess you never heard of inflation, both strict monetary and in terms of cost of military hardware.

During the war a P-51 cost about 51000 dollars. 11 billion dollars would be enough to equip the Soviets with 200 000 P-51s or a mix of other things.

Or
The USSR was highly dependent on rail transportation, but the war practically shut down rail equipment production: only about 92 locomotives were produced. 2,000 locomotives and 11,000 railcars were supplied under Lend-Lease. Likewise, the Soviet air force received 18,700 aircraft, which amounted to about 14% of Soviet aircraft production (19% for military aircraft).[15]

Although most Red Army tank units were equipped with Soviet-built tanks, their logistical support was provided by hundreds of thousands of U.S.-made trucks. Indeed by 1945 nearly two-thirds of the truck strength of the Red Army was U.S.-built. Trucks such as the Dodge 3/4 ton and Studebaker 2½ ton, were easily the best trucks available in their class on either side on the Eastern Front. American shipments of telephone cable, aluminium, canned rations, and clothing were also critical


But I guess wars are not won on logistics either. Considering the labour inefficiency of soviet agriculture, that food would release many workers for the front as well as the others who would need to be producing all that stuff. I guess manpower doesn't win wars either.


Before the war Germany was one of the few countries building up its military while many countries were scaling back....

However considering not a single person caught this massive example of wrongness... I guess I should not expect much.
Unless by few you mean France, England, the Soviet Union, hell even Poland was ramping up with a view to a war by 42 or so. The western powers might have started later than Germany, but they started from a higher base, every year would make things worse for Germany. Never mind the assumption that only the Germans could do technology.
 
I don't think Britain was ever in danger of being invaded. First, the Germans couldn't knock out the RAF, and second, they would have needed to get past the RN - which was frankly mission impossible for them.

Just because I enjoy contradicting you so much.....

They were so safe that Britain called out every able bodied man to defend the beaches and were even contemplating using poison gas to defend themselves.

Trust me, stick to something you have a clue about. :wink:
 
Even the mighty British empire - they not only conquored, but the colonized by settling their own people into a foreign country
This was the template the English used in invading a peaceful little country of 6 million people. Starved 2 million to death, forced another 2 million to flee to North America or shipped to Australia in prison ships. Stole land from the indigenous people and gave it to the Orange Scots. When the natives resisted they were immediately branded terrorists.


My uncle was a cop. I asked him one time about why sometimes you see instances of it taking 12 cops to arrest one guy.

The Nazis could have done the job with just one guy in 1/100th of the time.
 
This was the template the English used in invading a peaceful little country of 6 million people.
Pax, Mир, Peace!

The Queen has even been an official guest of the Irish Republic for a State Visit. Anglo-Irish relations is much more complex than a few posts on TERB can give justice to. Such as that Lord Edward Fitzgerald (who by the way spent a year as a Major with the 54th Regiment of Foot in New Brunwick) was a member of the C. of I. and through his mother a Great-great grandson of King Charles II.
 
This was the template the English used in invading a peaceful little country of 6 million people. Starved 2 million to death, forced another 2 million to flee to North America or shipped to Australia in prison ships. Stole land from the indigenous people and gave it to the Orange Scots. When the natives resisted they were immediately branded terrorists.

I know my British forebears were responsible for many things, but I wasn't aware that we forced the Irish potato crop to fail.

And as for Ireland being "peaceful", before the British took over, they were in a state of anarchy, misgovernment and civil war. Pretty much what they went back to in 1921 when they kicked the British out. Next time you want to play the "good Irish, bad British" game, you may want to remember that the Irish killed far more of each other in their civil war than the British killed in the previous 2 or 3 years we half-heartedly tried to hold on to Ireland.

But of course, that's not the version your IRA heroes tell.
 
Just because I enjoy contradicting you so much.....

They were so safe that Britain called out every able bodied man to defend the beaches and were even contemplating using poison gas to defend themselves.

Trust me, stick to something you have a clue about. :wink:

To be fair, it seems the Brits at Sandhurst post war looked at sealion and figured it couldn't work. Also on alt.history.what-if the consensus seemed to be that there was no way it could happen. It was almost a point of orthodoxy. Trying to prove sealion could work pretty much put you on par with claiming that Nambla is right, the holocaust never happened, Justin Bieber isn't history's greatest monster or that pie isn't delicious. That being said, preparing for defenses is always a wise thing to do.

Being a bit of a contrarian, it seemed to me to be that a lot of brits had a bit of a bee up their bonnet.

From the wiki
"he great majority of military historians believe Operation Sea Lion would not have succeeded. Kenneth Macksey asserts it would have only been possible if the Royal Navy had refrained from large scale intervention[52] and the Germans had assaulted in July 1940 (although Macksey conceded they were unprepared at that time),[53] while others such as Peter Fleming, Derek Robinson and Stephen Bungay believe the operation would have most likely resulted in a disaster for the Germans. Len Deighton and some other writers have called the German amphibious plans a "Dunkirk in reverse".[54]

Adolf Galland, commander of Luftwaffe fighters at the time, claimed invasion plans were not serious and that there was a palpable sense of relief in the Wehrmacht when it was finally called off. Field Marshal Gerd von Rundstedt also took this view and thought that Hitler never seriously intended to invade Britain and the whole thing was a bluff, to put pressure on the British Government to come to terms.[55] In fact in November 1939 the German Naval staff produced a study (on the possibility of an invasion of Britain) and concluded that it required two preconditions, air and naval superiority, neither of which Germany ever had.[56]"

Also


In the wargame conducted at the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst in 1974, which assumed the Luftwaffe had not yet won air supremacy, the Germans were able to establish a beachhead in England by using a minefield screen in the English Channel to protect the initial assault. However, the German ground forces were delayed at the "Stop Lines" (e.g. the GHQ Line), a layered series of defensive positions that had been built, each a combination of Home Guard troops and physical barriers. At the same time, the regular troops of the British Army were forming up. After only a few days, the Royal Navy was able to reach the Channel from Scapa Flow, cutting off supplies and blocking further reinforcement. Isolated and facing regular troops with armour and artillery, the invasion force was forced to surrender.[62]




However if the Germans pulled off Dunkirk, if they managed to obtain air superiority over the channel and had say a hundred or so decent and well trained torpedo bombers to control the channel, it might be a different story. They had Stukas and bombers but it is my understanding [which may be wrong] that they had a bad track record for hitting boats, both at Dunkirk and during the Battle of Britain. Toss in the torpedo bombers and train some Stuka crew for fleet bombardment and get a suitable supply of bombs, toss in mine fields subs and the kitchen sink... Maybe it won't be enough, but I wouldn't say impossible. One would have to assume the Royal Navy would toss everything into a counter attack, perhaps move in at night and do a daylight bombardment of the barges and other boats the Germans were going to use until they take them out/get sunk leaving German troops that have landed on the wrong side and hard/impossible to reinforce or resupply. I will leave the problems of how the Germans could gain air superiority aside, not easy and would also require rewriting history before 1940, unless you are willing to go for a late in the season invasion, in which case there is another set of possibilities with their own difficulties.
However then we get to the question of why would the Germans bother building up such air power. Hitler never had much interest in occupying the UK despite allied propaganda claims to the contrary, his vision was narrow focused east. Hell in Aug 39, I don't think many would even dream that by June 1940 they would have to consider running something like sea lion. The invasion of France was a close run thing, if a certain plan didn't crash with the original plans, things might not have turned out so well.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invasion_of_France_(Nazi_Germany)#German_strategy
For that matter even the German plan as is was risky, the right counter attack and the right time. There should be more homosexuals in the military as the ability to shove large objects like horseshoes up your ass is a great attribute for someone in the military.
To be fair, most historians don't degrade themselves with such base considerations as alternative histories, and only focus on what different sides bring to the table in fact.
 
Last edited: