Just because I enjoy contradicting you so much.....
They were so safe that Britain called out every able bodied man to defend the beaches and were even contemplating using poison gas to defend themselves.
Trust me, stick to something you have a clue about. :wink:
To be fair, it seems the Brits at Sandhurst post war looked at sealion and figured it couldn't work. Also on alt.history.what-if the consensus seemed to be that there was no way it could happen. It was almost a point of orthodoxy. Trying to prove sealion could work pretty much put you on par with claiming that Nambla is right, the holocaust never happened, Justin Bieber isn't history's greatest monster or that pie isn't delicious. That being said, preparing for defenses is always a wise thing to do.
Being a bit of a contrarian, it seemed to me to be that a lot of brits had a bit of a bee up their bonnet.
From the wiki
"he great majority of military historians believe Operation Sea Lion would not have succeeded. Kenneth Macksey asserts it would have only been possible if the Royal Navy had refrained from large scale intervention[52] and the Germans had assaulted in July 1940 (although Macksey conceded they were unprepared at that time),[53] while others such as Peter Fleming, Derek Robinson and Stephen Bungay believe the operation would have most likely resulted in a disaster for the Germans. Len Deighton and some other writers have called the German amphibious plans a "Dunkirk in reverse".[54]
Adolf Galland, commander of Luftwaffe fighters at the time, claimed invasion plans were not serious and that there was a palpable sense of relief in the Wehrmacht when it was finally called off. Field Marshal Gerd von Rundstedt also took this view and thought that Hitler never seriously intended to invade Britain and the whole thing was a bluff, to put pressure on the British Government to come to terms.[55] In fact in November 1939 the German Naval staff produced a study (on the possibility of an invasion of Britain) and concluded that it required two preconditions, air and naval superiority, neither of which Germany ever had.[56]"
Also
In the wargame conducted at the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst in 1974, which assumed the Luftwaffe had not yet won air supremacy, the Germans were able to establish a beachhead in England by using a minefield screen in the English Channel to protect the initial assault. However, the German ground forces were delayed at the "Stop Lines" (e.g. the GHQ Line), a layered series of defensive positions that had been built, each a combination of Home Guard troops and physical barriers. At the same time, the regular troops of the British Army were forming up. After only a few days, the Royal Navy was able to reach the Channel from Scapa Flow, cutting off supplies and blocking further reinforcement. Isolated and facing regular troops with armour and artillery, the invasion force was forced to surrender.[62]
However if the Germans pulled off Dunkirk,
if they managed to obtain air superiority over the channel and had say a hundred or so decent and well trained torpedo bombers to control the channel, it might be a different story. They had Stukas and bombers but it is my understanding [which may be wrong] that they had a bad track record for hitting boats, both at Dunkirk and during the Battle of Britain. Toss in the torpedo bombers and train some Stuka crew for fleet bombardment and get a suitable supply of bombs, toss in mine fields subs and the kitchen sink... Maybe it won't be enough, but I wouldn't say impossible. One would have to assume the Royal Navy would toss everything into a counter attack, perhaps move in at night and do a daylight bombardment of the barges and other boats the Germans were going to use until they take them out/get sunk leaving German troops that have landed on the wrong side and hard/impossible to reinforce or resupply. I will leave the problems of how the Germans could gain air superiority aside, not easy and would also require rewriting history before 1940, unless you are willing to go for a late in the season invasion, in which case there is another set of possibilities with their own difficulties.
However then we get to the question of why would the Germans bother building up such air power. Hitler never had much interest in occupying the UK despite allied propaganda claims to the contrary, his vision was narrow focused east. Hell in Aug 39, I don't think many would even dream that by June 1940 they would have to consider running something like sea lion. The invasion of France was a close run thing, if a certain plan didn't crash with the original plans, things might not have turned out so well.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invasion_of_France_(Nazi_Germany)#German_strategy
For that matter even the German plan as is was risky, the right counter attack and the right time. There should be more homosexuals in the military as the ability to shove large objects like horseshoes up your ass is a great attribute for someone in the military.
To be fair, most historians don't degrade themselves with such base considerations as alternative histories, and only focus on what different sides bring to the table in fact.