This is what I believe what most of us have also written.
However, again, the RAF maintaining air superiority over the southeast coast of England and the Channel was a lot more closely run, than I believe many here have given it credit for having been. As it was the Germans practically had Fighter Command on the ropes, when the Luftwaffe switched strategies to “the Bliz.”
It was air superiority which enabled any possibility of naval superiority in such a narrow sea.
There are two issues here, neither of which negate what you are saying BTW.
1: There is a seasonal issue here, when you are trying to cross the channel with Rhine river barges [talk about half assed], you want to avoid the fall and winter season. If the Germans didn't switch I am not sure [as in I don't have the information] if they would still have time to go across.
2: And here is the real odd fucked up stuff. I recall reading that by the Battle of Britain the Brits were out training and outbuilding the Germans in Aircraft, or at least fighters. Things would have been helped for the Germans if they started ramping up production from day 1 for the long haul but they waited till 42 and Speer
"At the time of Speer's accession to the office, the German economy, unlike the British one, was not fully geared for war production. Consumer goods were still being produced at nearly as high a level as during peacetime. No fewer than five "Supreme Authorities" had jurisdiction over armament production—one of which, the Ministry of Economic Affairs, had declared in November 1941 that conditions did not permit an increase in armament production. Few women were employed in the factories, which were running only one shift. One evening soon after his appointment, Speer went to visit a Berlin armament factory; he found no one on the premises."
That is just nucking futz. If the Germans started taking things seriously in Sept 39 and didn't swtich strategies during the BoB, air superiority at least over the channel was something achievable IMHO.
Of course a victory during the BoB and a successful invasion of the British Islands brings forward a bizarre chain of events.
If the Brits stay fighting, and wishful thinking aside, it could go either way, even the I-ties could probably handle the middle east. No British Islands providing economic and manpower resources to the Middle East. Germans from Scotland to Wales would be over the Home Fleet's dead body which which probably will have an effect over the Med, assuming they don't recall the Mediterranean fleet for a last chance run to disrupt the invasion.
Either way perhaps Greece would be less willing to say όχι to the I-ties or more accurately Alors, c'est la guerre (Then it is war)
No way would Yugoslavia not be joining the Axis if Britain is out, or even if Britian is fighting but without the home islands and struggling otherwise.
Talking Spain into the war would be much easier either way.
If the Brits quit, they really have no way to justify having all those troops in Poland as a diversion, even Stalin can't be that wishful thinkingish. It also opens up the sea lanes again and leaves a lot of German divisions free for the east as well as more Italian and Spanish [who would send more than the Blue division if the west is at peace]. Also if Yugoslavia is Axis that means not only more help but no need to tie down units to keep order.