The Nazis Win World War Two?

Even if Hitler had succeeded in "winning" WW2 (which was impossible given who he was taking on), he would have NEVER been able to hang on to the conquored territory.

I'm hard pressed to think of a single country in the world right now that is currently "occupied" or controlled by foreign invaders.

Logistics just don't allow for the holding and controlling of a country that doesn't want to be held or controlled. All you need to do is resist. One only need to look as far as the mighty United States of America. Brought to its knees in Afghanistan by a bunch of cavemen. Ditto Iraq and Vietnam.

True, you can't occupy a country where the vast majority of the population hates you.

But there are some, limited examples, of this. Tibet, in China, comes to mind. The Kurds in Iraq. And not all the South Vietnamese who were loyal to the US were able to get out; I don't think anyone envies their position.
 
I'd say that in the long haul, the Germans won..maybe not that particular war, but when was the last time you drove through a decaying city in Deutschland or witnessed the depth, despair and poverty now insidious in every U.S. community, where .27 cents on every tax dollar is being spent on the military??? The u.S. is in cataclysmic, decline, whereas Germany bounced back and is clearly Europe's powerhouse, granted,not that they dont have their own problems at the moment.
 
The inability of conquerers to maintain power over a conquered populace is largely a matter of will. And like it or not, willpower is not something the Nazis lacked.

There's an alternate history short story about the Indian Revolution under Mahatma Ghandi, if the German Nazis controlled them rather than the British. The Mahatma ended up in a concentration camp, IIRC, and gassed.

The Mongols conquered Afghanistan (more of less present-day Afghanistan) pretty well. They killed everyone they could get ahold of, tossed the bodies down the wells, destroyed the irrigation systems, and walked away as the victors. The saying is "they created a desert and called it peace."

The big question of the Nazi regime is whether they would have stayed as driven and as focused as they were. That's the big problem with fascist regimes, after all: the energy and vigor of the first generation usually falls off after the second generation of leadership takes over. If the Nazis had maintained their willingness to do what "just isn't done", then they could very well have conquered the world and kept it cowed.

Remember, the Nazis were also a very "green" movement. What's more green than turning 95% of the human population into fertilizer?
 
The Axis lost because of Japan. They attacked the US even though they knew the US was too big an enemy. The Pearl Harbour attack was what swayed the American public to get out of the splendid isolation and join the Allied forces in the European and the Pacific front.
 
The Axis lost because of Japan. They attacked the US even though they knew the US was too big an enemy. The Pearl Harbour attack was what swayed the American public to get out of the splendid isolation and join the Allied forces in the European and the Pacific front.

Sure, that's the official story; the history books tell us this. But us history buffs want to dig deeper.

Why did the Nazis ally themselves with Japan? Clearly, Asians were not part of the Aryan master race. And, without a preemptive declaration of war on the US, the US would only go to war against Japan, and not in Europe.

Why do this? Unless Hitler felt that Japan would feel obligated to do something for Germany in exchange (attack the USSR).

Most of the action of WW2 is on the Russian front; the key to WW2 is in how Germany deals with this.

But we also wonder; what was Hitler's eventual plan for the US? I guess we'll never know; he was working on Europe first.
 
I'd say that in the long haul, the Germans won..maybe not that particular war, but when was the last time you drove through a decaying city in Deutschland.
Professor Overy addresses the above: a) the Germans adopted allied innovation as part of the occupation. b) much of German industry and infrastructure was destroyed in the war and they had to build new.
 
Franco's Spain - another Fascist state - simply transformed itself into a standard Western democracy after the dictator's death and his ideology died along with him.
It was indeed a remarkable transformation, and of course much of that was due to the personal action of the King of Spain on top of a millennia of history as well.
 
Last edited:
I think they made two major military blunders. One was getting into North Africa in the first place, the other was invading the Soviet Union, which was a horrible miscalculation and with no contigency for continuing it into the Winter of 1941. If Hitler had concentrated everything he had on England they very well could have broken, depriving the US of help in Europe from their closest ally, as well as the jumping off point to invade the mainland.
 
Hitler underestimated the Russian army. That hurt them badly. American production hurt them as well. As for the Japanese, they kept fighting the Americans after Germany was toast. They should have surrendered but waited until 2 nukes hit for the Emperor to make the announcement.

The whole thing was so very sad. It really showed the world once again that humans are nothing more then civilized animals capable of anthing.
 
the Germans adopted allied innovation as part of the occupation.

This is where the West made a huge mistake in Iraq and Afghanistan. The West saw how quickly Japan and Germany rebuilt their countries and thought Iraq and Afghanistan could do the same forgetting that the Germans and Japanese are extremely intelligent, rational, competent and hardworking people whereas those "other guys" are not.
 
This is where the West made a huge mistake in Iraq and Afghanistan. The West saw how quickly Japan and Germany rebuilt their countries and thought Iraq and Afghanistan could do the same forgetting that the Germans and Japanese are extremely intelligent, rational, competent and hardworking people whereas those "other guys" are not.

since when were you an expert on the Middle East and a history buff?
 
Well, if you look at their strategies for the World War II I would disagree that they were intelligent, rational and competent. Hardworking yes.

There are actually 3 periods here. The pre, the during and the post. Clearly, they have done much better post-war than they could ever have done during the war. In fact, some would say that by losing the war, they won.
 
The latest theory I read was that Hitler was hoping Japan would attack the USSR, diverting their resources (in return for Germany declaring war on the US).

I heard that but people don't know is that Japan's resources were being strangled by the US. So even though pearl habour was unprovoked they kinda had it coming...
 
This is where the West made a huge mistake in Iraq and Afghanistan. The West saw how quickly Japan and Germany rebuilt their countries and thought Iraq and Afghanistan could do the same forgetting that the Germans and Japanese are extremely intelligent, rational, competent and hardworking people whereas those "other guys" are not.

I don't think the majority of the Germans and Japanese were intelligent and rational during that conflict. Look at all the racial eugenics nonsense they believed in. Read Mein Kampf, many in the Nazi Party actually believed that ideologistic trash. Familiarize with yourself on the medical experiments conducted by the SS and the Japanese in Unit 731.

Some got caught and executed for their crimes. But I'm sure many were released a short time later after being "re-educated".
 
I don't think the majority of the Germans and Japanese were intelligent and rational during that conflict.

Agreed, but note how quickly they rebuilt their countries POST-WW2. Some in the West thought that Iraq and Afghanistan could do the same POST-Saddam and POST-Taliban but Iraq and Afghanistan are still a bloody mess.
 
This is where the West made a huge mistake in Iraq and Afghanistan. The West saw how quickly Japan and Germany rebuilt their countries and thought Iraq and Afghanistan could do the same forgetting that the Germans and Japanese are extremely intelligent, rational, competent and hardworking people whereas those "other guys" are not.
There is significant truth to what you write.