They better actually have something against this guy

When he was arrested four days before the summit, Sonne’s friends and supporters – who say Sonne was intentionally baiting security officials to provoke a response – figured he would spend a night or two in jail.

Maybe this is what they have against him ?? the charge is "counselling the commission of mischief not committed" so that would fit I think ? ?
 
Then again, was he really a threat or just a shit disturber that they should've released after a few days or weeks instead of 330 days?

Guess we will find out. That's the 330 day question--what did he do that made him so dangerous he had to be held in jail for most of a year while awaiting trial.
 
Maybe this is what they have against him ?? the charge is "counselling the commission of mischief not committed" so that would fit I think ? ?

Some sort of petty mischief charge, sure, I can believe he is guilty of some minor crime like that. What's that usually get you? A small fine? A couple months in jail max? What's the justification for holding him for a year in pre trial?

That implies they believed he was either a flight risk or else a serious threat to the public. However... since they finally did let him out on bail... he hasn't escaped and he hasn't blown anybody up!
 
How will you answer your grandchildren when they ask you "Granpa, what were civil liberties"
 
The print version of The Star says that at the initial encounter downtown and later Sonne handled his chats with the cops poorly—although it's quite likely any honest but self-righteous citizen might do the same. He refused to provide ID documents until threatened with a jaywalking ticket, that info allowed the cops to do surveillance which then led to an 'invitation' to come downtown and chat. Which he did, perhaps overestimating his legal position, most certainly how that could be dealt with to police advantage. The two sides now have different opinions of when in the chatting process he was arrested and thus should have been warned and could have demanded a lawyer, and what info was properly obtained for the search.

So from the get-go there are questions about how properly the police behaved, serious enough for the Court to decide. And of course the final charges are pretty obvious face-savers to cover police over-reaction to a self-proclaimed security knowitall.

At the G20! I'm shocked! Shocked! to hear there was questionable police activity at this event
 
That's my impression too...
100%, He broke no laws. The police saw an opportunity to go nuts and took it. Our weak political leaders were happy to let them. Blair disgraced himself that weekend. Mr. Sonne deserves plenty of compensation and the judge should be making statements about civil liberties and abuses. I doubt if he will, as it may be beyond his mandate tho.
 
Maybe if he wasn't worth so much money--at the time, cops would not had noticed him as much.

Money is power, people with deep pockets can make more waves. If your not on the police side you are then more of a target.

YES, lets wait and see just what evidence the police have on him...how come he isn't getting a jury trial but by a judge--hope this is a fair judge.

Who is the judge?
 
I am pretty sure he will be well compensated for his time in jail. A mil or 2 is worth the time in the can and the escape from a wife. :) Hopefully the complimentary butt-fuck wasn't on the menu!
 
Anybody could say they were just fucking around once they get caught. Slippery Slope for him. Shows that academic and technical knowledge does not equate to common sense.
 
Anybody could say they were just fucking around once they get caught.

There are people who came forward from various security organizations he was a member of that corroborated his claim that he said he was just fucking around BEFORE he got caught.
 
... he pleaded not guilty in Ontario Superior Court to four counts of possessing an explosive substance and one of counselling mischief not committed.

Were explosive founds in his home?

What was he charge with?
 
I heard that he had an unindicted co-conspirator.

They suspected Sonne had battery acid but he drank it. So now they could charge him.

The other guy had fireworks and ate the evidence too. They let him off!

Fuck, you are always ever ready wilth the battery jokes. Lithium up your puns to my level.
 
This is one of your favorate lines Fuji whenever someone disagrees with your bending over backwards approach to making sure any defendant has at least three shots at the apple beyond what the law requires.


The laws were legally enacted by the Governor in Council

why respond to fuji? i know its hard to resist
 
The bottom line I'm willing to bet is that Mr. Sonne is one of those who objected to the manner in which various emergency laws were enacted before the G20, decided that he didn't believe they really were the law and decided that he was going to attempt to take the law into his own hands, rather than protest in a legal manner.

So, security measures by the government broke the law and this guy was angry about that and decided to show it. Do you really think the big issue here is that the guy baited security forces?
 
I am pretty sure he will be well compensated for his time in jail. A mil or 2 is worth the time in the can and the escape from a wife. :) Hopefully the complimentary butt-fuck wasn't on the menu!

Bet he won't get shit--not anywhere close to a mill, if U were on the jury how much would U give him?
 
Bumping a very old thread I found interesting
For those who did not remember, Sonne was the moron who tried baiting the police, RCMP, CBSA, & CSIS
Ironically enough noone cared about him until he started harassing the G20 security, but then they looked into his past and found years worth of "issues"

Interesting read (& gives closure to this thread as well)

http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/201...ree_but_the_g20_forever_changed_his_life.html
 
In this day and age (post 9/11, terrorism etc) this guy was an absolute moron to bait the authorities like this. For that he deserves to lose his wife and spend some time thinking about his stupidity. I have no sympathy.

. . . and many more in similar vein.

Quote from the article:
Sonne, too, is unrepentant and unapologetic. He says he will not stop challenging government authority and criticizing what he calls “security theatre.”
“It’s more important than ever that we fight against the slippery slope of what’s being done with our rights,” Sonne said Tuesday.
Justice Spies, in her methodical, judicious way, may not have wholly agreed with Sonne’s tactics, but she was unequivocal in her decision that he was within his rights to do what he did.
So what of Sonne’s attention-seeking experiment, which aimed to determine whether authorities could distinguish between real threats and red herrings?
“The answer is they’re not too good at picking out people that are a legitimate risk until people start flipping out about security and they lose their critical faculties, especially when they’re under the gun,” Sonne said.
Toronto police had six months to prepare for the G20, far less time than other cities that have hosted the summit. If they had more time to profile prospective threats, Sonne says, perhaps he would have been investigated and disregarded much earlier.
He understands if people think he got what he deserved; that if you poke the bear, the bear might poke back.
But he wishes the public, in general, made more of a fuss when their liberties are restricted, even in extreme circumstances like the G20.
“I’m not trying to dress myself up as some kind of civil rights superhero. . . . But I’d like to see this as something that feeds into some kind of future dialogue about the way things are going.”



There is no shortage of people who believe: "if it's in the interests of law and order, it's ok.", "the safety of society is more important than the individual rights of morons", "it's our job to obey govt orders, not to question them", "if you taunt the authorities, you deserve all you get", etc, etc.

I don't have the courage to do these things myself, so all the more reason to praise those who do. Our appreciation and grateful thanks should go out to guys like this, and to the courts who acquit them. The incremental but constant erosion of individual rights is a huge danger - cases like this bring the danger to the front of the public consciousness - for a moment - then back to it.