They better actually have something against this guy

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,936
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
It'll be interesting to see what they've got. If they put him in jail for 330 days, cost him his wife, his house, and his job, all for nothing, what's his recourse?

OK -- he was an idiot to poke his finger in the G20 security folks eyes. But really?

Interesting to see how this goes.

http://www.thestar.com/news/crime/article/1082461--trial-begins-on-g20-explosives-charge?bn=1

One of the most highly anticipated G20 criminal cases begins in earnest today with the opening of the trial for Byron Sonne, the so-called “G20 geek,” charged with possessing homemade explosives in the lead-up to the June 2010 summit of world leaders in downtown Toronto.

Sonne, who spent nearly 11 months in pre-trial custody – longer than any other G20 accused – before being released on bail last May, is also facing the obscure charge of “counselling the commission of mischief not committed.”

Four other charges were dropped earlier this year. The trial will be argued in front of a judge alone.

Sonne, a 38-year-old Internet security expert living in a $1 million Forest Hill home, seemed an unlikely target for a G20 police probe at the time of his arrest on June 22, 2010.

But police had been following his online activity in the weeks leading up to the summit, as Sonne – an ardent civil libertarian and critic of state surveillance – posted photos of the security fence and surveillance cameras in the downtown core.

Sonne also openly scorned police and the G20 security apparatus on his Twitter and Flickr accounts.

Evidence given in previous bail hearings is under a publication ban.

When he arrived at the University Ave. courthouse this morning, Sonne said he was happy and excited to have his day in court.

“Today there won’t be a publication ban, and you'll be able to actually hear the evidence against me,” he said.

When he was arrested four days before the summit, Sonne’s friends and supporters – who say Sonne was intentionally baiting security officials to provoke a response – figured he would spend a night or two in jail.

When Sonne was finally released after spending 330 days behind bars, he returned to a very different life than the one he left behind.

His wife, artist Kristen Peterson – who was arrested two days after her husband but had all charges against her dropped – ended the couple’s 15-year relationship and has cut off all contact with Sonne and his family since the arrest.

Sonne also lost his home and his income as a result of restrictive bail conditions which limited his computer and Internet access and forced him to move back into his parents' Brampton home.

The trial is scheduled for three weeks.
 
In this day and age (post 9/11, terrorism etc) this guy was an absolute moron to bait the authorities like this. For that he deserves to lose his wife and spend some time thinking about his stupidity. I have no sympathy.
 
And in the same vein.. In varying levels of baiting..... The other protesters could be put in the same category as this loser sonne!!!
 
In this day and age (post 9/11, terrorism etc) this guy was an absolute moron to bait the authorities like this. For that he deserves to lose his wife and spend some time thinking about his stupidity. I have no sympathy.

Well let's see what happens. So far there's very little real information available, it's hard to say. If he was doing more than just baiting, if he was actually over the line--so be it.

If they come up with nothing, though, then they've put an innocent man in jail for nearly a year, cost him his house and job, and probably his marriage. That seems unwarranted.

But we don't know the facts yet--the next three weeks should prove interesting.
 
I doubt this event cost him his marriage.... He was likely on TERB and got caught!

Well she didn't exactly stick with him so probably there were issues there, but at least it cost him his house and his job and a year of his life behind bars.
 
This along the same level of common sense as saying to my mind "super-max" penitentiaries are bad therefore despite those large signs along the highway saying "do not stop" and "no photography" I will both stop and take photographs. Then don't complain about the consequences.
 
This along the same level of common sense as saying to my mind "super-max" penetentaries are bad therefore despite those large signs along the highway saying "do not stop" and "no photography" I will both stop and take photographs. Then don't complain about the consequences.

That would actually be in violation of the law... supposing this guy hasn't broken it?
 
That would actually be in violation of the law... supposing this guy hasn't broken it?
The I'm right dead right mentality. He knew that the government did not want photographs taken of the security measures, he quite deliberately chose to violate that (basicly dared the goverment to take legal action).
 
Well she didn't exactly stick with him so probably there were issues there, but at least it cost him his house and his job and a year of his life behind bars.

Looks like he's a bit of a shit disturber and tempted fate a wee bit much.

http://www.cbc.ca/m/touch/news/story/2011/11/07/byron-sonne-g20-trial.html

He said the warrant was, in part, based on "wildly speculative" claims. Those claims included that some of the objects pictured on the Flickr website were projectiles capable of being fired from a potato cannon and that he was involved in a criminal plot to destroy surveillance cameras.

According to the court documents, Sonne, prior to the search of his house, was detained by police and gave them information that he had number of recreational potato cannons at a family cottage.

He also gave them information about chemicals at his home —chemicals that could be used to produce explosives. But Sonne also claimed that he had an interest in model rocketry and that some of the chemicals are used in the manufacture of fireworks and model rocket fuel.
 
The bottom line I'm willing to bet is that Mr. Sonne is one of those who objected to the manner in which various emergency laws were enacted before the G20, decided that he didn't believe they really were the law and decided that he was going to attempt to take the law into his own hands, rather than protest in a legal manner.
 
The bottom line I'm willing to bet is that Mr. Sonne is one of those who objected to the manner in which various emergency laws were enacted before the G20, decided that he didn't believe they really were the law and decided that he was going to attempt to take the law into his own hands, rather than protest in a legal manner.

And this justifies what, exactly? I have noticed you have pretty much zero respect for the law, the rule of law, and due process. You seem to have respect for "authority", but not law.
 
I usually have a lot of respect for your opinion...

You'd lose that bet.

He was careful to limit his actions to talk.

He was arrested for what he was expected that he might do, and that was simply being a shit disturber to provoke an illegal response.

Wait until the case plays out and what the Judge ultimately says.

I'll bet that his judgement will be a scathing criticism of the pre-emptive action taken against the guy!

Limiting actions to talk is still in many cases a crime
Case in point; walk around Pearson discussing security measures and bomb making and watch how quickly you end up on the floor

This guy is a moron and deserves everything he gets (even if he provoked an aggressive response he won't get compensated for it cuz its in the greater good)
 
And this justifies what, exactly? I have noticed you have pretty much zero respect for the law, the rule of law, and due process.
This is one of your favorate lines Fuji whenever someone disagrees with your bending over backwards approach to making sure any defendant has at least three shots at the apple beyond what the law requires.


The laws were legally enacted by the Governor in Council
 
And this justifies what, exactly? I have noticed you have pretty much zero respect for the law, the rule of law, and due process. You seem to have respect for "authority", but not law.

Do you know if the emergency laws enacted (to quote Aardvark) for the G20 summit were unconstitutional? I mean, what about protecting G20 leaders from potential harm? Do we let anyone defy that temporary law and expose people to potential terrorist attacks?

Then again, was he really a threat or just a shit disturber that they should've released after a few days or weeks instead of 330 days?

If he made no threats or wasn't carrying explosive material in his car, etc. , then perhaps he was no real threat.
 
Maybe if he wasn't worth so much money--at the time, cops would not had noticed him as much.

Money is power, people with deep pockets can make more waves. If your not on the police side you are then more of a target.

YES, lets wait and see just what evidence the police have on him...how come he isn't getting a jury trial but by a judge--hope this is a fair judge.
 
Limiting actions to talk is still in many cases a crime
Case in point; walk around Pearson discussing security measures and bomb making and watch how quickly you end up on the floor

This guy is a moron and deserves everything he gets (even if he provoked an aggressive response he won't get compensated for it cuz its in the greater good)

Okay but did he make a verbal or written threat (or imply one) to cause physical harm, or did he just complain about the G20 security measures?
 
Okay but did he make a verbal or written threat to cause physical harm, or did he just complain about the G20 security measures?

Hopefully we will be finding that out, great question.