The reality in Canada is that a Tip is mandatory. Wait staff are compensated lower than standard minimum wage with the expectation that they will earn tips to supplement their income. minimum wage law specifically makes an exception for this case.
If you don't agree with this approach, lobby the Provincial government to change the law. Rest assured, however, that if restaurants are forced to pay their staff more, they will pass this cost directly to the customer so there will be no savings to anyone.
You must be using a different definition of mandatory than I am.
The differential minimum wage is not present in all provinces. It is on Ontario and IIRC Quebec, I am not sure about Manitoba, seem to recall reading that it isn't elsewhere and defiantly isn't in Newfoundland unless they have changed things recently. I can tell you however that the law makes no difference as to attitudes towards tipping. Law change or not, people will still tip.
Also the different minimum wage laws in those provinces that do have them don't apply to all tipping professions, and tipping predates the regulations in question. In those provinces that do have a difference, the difference is because of tipping, not the other way around.
Oddly enough at McDs and many other places I can get service every bit as good and friendly as at any restaurant and without any worry about someone spitting in my food. I doubt if you would have to pay much more than minimum wage to get decent waiters. At the markups your typical restaurant charges they should be able to pay their staff, double plus so with some of the markups I've seen on wine. Paying someone 15 bucks to bring you a 100 dollar bottle of wine is just silly, double so when you consider the profit margin.
I also don't see much fairness in someone working a 250 dollar for 2 place being able to claim 37.50 as a fair bribe to do their job [above the 9.50 they already get in Ontario and minimum wage they get in some provinces] when there are so many other people who do the exact same job but might only get 6 or 8 bucks because they work someone less snooty. Never mind those who are not in traditional tipping fields and get by on minimum wage. For that matter 37.50 for some damn dirty ape just to bring you your food. I mean fuck, really?
Tipping on percentage is about as retarded as those real estate agents who expect the same 5 or 6% regardless of if the home is 150K or 1.5 million. People still pay it, but it sure ain't right.
But hey, if tipping is so grand, why not do it everywhere, the poor slob who rings in your purchase at the grocery or corner store, or again who pours your gas back in the day, hell why not tip everyone. Yeah it is tradition, but it is a bloody stupid holdover from a past that no longer applies.

