dslr brand?

That's fine if you're only taking everyday pics.... if you want to start shooting something a little further away your P&S isn't going to cut it.

Agree. There is no doubt that for "special situations", a DSLR will perform better (at a much higher cost) than even a higher end P&S. (BTW: Canon and Fuji have 35x and 30x P&S cameras that can shoot distant objects fairly well.) Here are 4 "special situations" where a DSLR will outperform an S&P.
1) Rapid shooting (3-5 frames per second).
2) Shooting quickly moving subjects (race cars).
3) Producing "poster size" prints.
4) Shooting without flash or with speedlight.

Here are two pics of my dog. Can you tell which was shot with a DSLR and which with a P&S?
 
There is maybe a middle ground between a full DSLR and a P&S. I was about to go the DSLR route myself as even the best P&S camera I could buy was still taking lousy vacation pictures especially in poor light. I ended up buying the Sony NEX-5. It has a huge sensor for great low light photo's and a pretty fast lens. It's really nice to be able to shoot with depth of field again.

It also plugs directly into my iPAD for quick syncing of photos, and is not to big to lug around on vacation.
 
How about Sony Alpha's? They are rated very well also. Use older Minolta style mounts and AF compatibility to older gen Minolta lenses.

I shoot with a top end Sony Alpha kit, and the ZA lenses are phenomenal. That said, I used to shoot Minolta, so I'm used to the ergonomics. For that same reason of ergonomics, I especially dislike Canon. YMMV.
 
I was about to go the DSLR route myself as even the best P&S camera I could buy was still taking lousy vacation pictures especially in poor light.
By poor light, do you mean shooting in twilight without using the flash?
I ended up buying the Sony NEX-5. It has a huge sensor for great low light photo's and a pretty fast lens.
Are you shooting in low light without the flash?
It's really nice to be able to shoot with depth of field again.
By "depth of field", do you mean that the background is blurred and only the subject (your GF?) is in focus?
 
By poor light, do you mean shooting in twilight without using the flash? Are you shooting in low light without the flash?By "depth of field", do you mean that the background is blurred and only the subject (your GF?) is in focus?

Low light no flash - yes with great results.

Twilight - not much experience with this yet as I just got the camera, but it does seem to work well. The camera will take a burst of photos and combine the images.

Depth of field - answer is yes to your question. subject has sharp focus with blurry background.

The kit actually comes with a tiny flash you can mount on the camera, but I haven't needed to use it yet. It wouldnt be good for anything more than six feet away, but it is included.
 
Nikon and Canon are both excellent. I used Canon film cameras for dacades and early digital models. Then got a deal on a Nikon and shoot with that now. Both have better resale or trade-in than Pentax, Sony or similar.

This is a good source for camera info. The guy is opinioted but makes a lot of good points.

http://www.kenrockwell.com/

dpreview is good too.
 
Low light no flash - yes with great results.
DSLR's or equivalent do shoot much better in low light with no flash than even the best P&S. Great for P.I.'s.

depth of field - answer is yes to your question. subject has sharp focus with blurry background.
Again, this is where SLR's have the advantage over P&S.

So, if one takes a lot of pics in low light with no flash and/or needs depth of field, then an SLR or equivalent is the way to go.
 
how much do you want to spend?
What kind of photography?
I am a cannon guy, however it depends on how much you want to spend....
 
The big revolution in DSLR technology will be the video camera modes. The lenses of the DSLR allow it to take different/better pictures than a conventional video camera. However, a video camera has a slew of smooth focus, smooth zoom, and smooth tilt/pan modes that allow the video camera to shoot smooth video. Once Nikon and Canon figure out how to get smooth video from a DSLR camera, they will have a killer product on their hands.

When comparing the point and shoot cameras, it is all about speed of focus and shutter response times. The modern DSLR can focus almost instantly in low-light, and rapidly take subsequent pictures at 4 or more frames per second. Many, many point and shoot cameras are slow to focus, have significant shutter lag, and take forever to take the next picture. It is really nice to be able to capture the action at a birthday party. I really question the utility of any camera that can't usefully take a pictures of a kid blowing out the birthday candles. I was able to take pictures at birthday parties with a fully manual film SLR. Make sure your P&S camera can do the same.
 
DSLRs can be great cameras but they are challenging video cameras - although that said I did take a concert video with my D3s in very low light at to looked and sounded fantastic. You really can't beat the low light capabilities of a FX format camera.

OTB
 
Interesting. It is so difficult to shoot a good video in low light. How low was the light at the concert?

The light gathering technology on some of the DSLRs is exceptional. In particular, if the D3s is shooting at 24 fps, and the Canon is shooting at 60 fps, then the Nikon will have more time to gather light. It will make a little over 1 stop difference. Also, movies are shot at 24 fps. I wouldn't worry about the 24 vs. 60 fps thing.
 
The light gathering technology on some of the DSLRs is exceptional. In particular, if the D3s is shooting at 24 fps, and the Canon is shooting at 60 fps, then the Nikon will have more time to gather light. It will make a little over 1 stop difference. Also, movies are shot at 24 fps. I wouldn't worry about the 24 vs. 60 fps thing.

Interesting. So, it is actually better to shoot at the slower 24 fps so the cam can gather more light per frame.
 
Interesting. So, it is actually better to shoot at the slower 24 fps so the cam can gather more light per frame.

Yes. Between 5 and 15 fps the video often becomes jumpy. A solution is to use it as either (a) a deliberate "jumpy motion" or fast-forward effect, or (b) create intermediate frames on a computer.
 
Interesting. It is so difficult to shoot a good video in low light. How low was the light at the concert?

Extremely low (don't know how to quantify), and harsh differences in lighting intensity and color.... the D3s practically sees in the dark.

OTB