Economics question

Are you really as stupid as you pretend to be. Look, if you had any brains at all, you would have used this as an opportunity to learn something from someone who knows a hell of a lot more about the subject than you do. The fact is that in the system as a whole deposits are greater than loans. That is just a fact. If you had any common sense, you would try to understand the sources you post before posting them.
I have wasted enough time trying to explain the basics to you. I even made the following offer:
I would rather not spend a lot of my leisure time trying to explain this to you. However, if you indicate you have made a real attempt to try to understand it and still have a question, let me know.
Clearly you have not made any real attempt to understand why you are wrong. If you do, my offer stands. If you make a real attempt to try to understand the process, and have a question, ask it.
LOL, you fail to admit that you know liittle on the subject, by refusing to accept that what I wrote is correct.
What you wrote is
Look, banks ON AGGREGATE lend out more than they take in in the form of deposts - agreed?
I have already explained that this is completely wrong. Indeed, if you understood the sources you quote you would know that even they say you are completely wrong.
However, it is clear that not only do you not understand a basic first-year concept, but you also have a reading comprehension problem.

Edit: Rather than repeating myself, I will just repost the following were I even explained exactly where your misunderstanding was.
You are simply wrong here. I think your confusion is that you think the only deposit in the system is the original deposit. I would suggest you google the terms “deposit creation multiplier”; before you make a complete fool of yourself. The fact is that a bank’s liabilities (e.g. deposits people hold with it) must equal its assets (loans it has made plus reserves it keeps) plus equity (a small term). If you ever take a first-year course, this will be explained to you with what are called T accounts. The left side of which must always equal the right side.
The fact is each loan a bank makes creates new deposits of an equal amount (minus whatever proportion people decide to hold in cash).
You clearly do not understand what the Wikipedia passage says or you would know that nothing in it disagrees with anything I have said.
Read the above and try to understand it before you make yourself foolish by quoting more sources you don’t understand. If you understood the passages you quote, you would see that. In the passages you quote, with no cash drain, Deposits = Loans + reserves. Since reserves > 0, it follows that Deposits > Loans.

BTW, I don’t think you are foolish because you have trouble understanding this stuff. I think you are foolish because you are arguing about a first-year concept with someone with a PhD in economics who teaches this stuff in a university and don’t even bother to ask yourself if maybe the misunderstanding is on your part. If I was having an exchange with a physicist about a basic concept in physics and he told me I was wrong, I would definitely have second thoughts about what I was saying. I would try to understand what he was trying to tell me. The fact that you don’t do that is why I think you are foolish (I am tempted to use a less polite word than "foolish", but I will restrain myself.
 
Last edited:
The government 'prints money' when they buy back bonds.


Only if they want to

Remember they took in money when they sold the bonds so this cancels out

depending on what they did with the money
The greater the money suppy, the looser the credit.


Why would this be true ??
Therefore, you have inflationary pressure because it's cheap to borrow.


Just if the borrowing is used to bid up prices IE the housing collapse but not if the borrowing produces goods as you borrow money that is already in the system but this is what perplexes me as the banks relend the same monies so is this not the same as printing money ??? We should have hyper inflation but do not so something is going on

My theory is the borrowed money goes to create goods so there is more money but more goods for the money to chase so no inflation
Another way of putting is, inflation is when you have more money chasing fewer goods.


true
 
No as they took in money when they sold the bonds so this cancels out
One would assume they spend the money they got when they sold the bonds. Otherwise, why issue the bonds to start with? If they spend the money, someone will deposit it in a bank and the deposit/money creation process begins.
 
LOL, you fail to admit that you know liittle on the subject...

Gonna lose this argument burt. The man teaches the subject at University. You don't. Just a heads up. There are several people on this board that I have serious doubt are actually who they pretend to be. Someone isn't one of them.
 
One would assume they spend the money they got when they sold the bonds. Otherwise, why issue the bonds to start with? If they spend the money, someone will deposit it in a bank and the deposit/money creation process begins.

I assume they repay the loan with taxes not by printing money
 
Gonna lose this argument burt. The man teaches the subject at University. You don't. Just a heads up. There are several people on this board that I have serious doubt are actually who they pretend to be. Someone isn't one of them.

Agreed

he is also very generous with his time
 
He is simply saying that the fractional reserve system results in new deposits etc, so all laons are matched by deposits. That is NOT the point. The point is that the banking system is leveraged and a dollar in new deposits all else equal will result in a multiplier as per my discussion.

I bow to no 'EXPERTS' or PHDS. The Club of Rome was full of so-called experts who predicted the end of most natural resources. Very good reasing, until they were proved dead wrong. Dude, don't just say "I'm this" or I"I'm that" therefore I am right and you are wrong. It's is just silly pontificating and buffoonery.

What did the ecomonics profession put so much faith in in the 60"s? Why, the trade-off between inflation and unemployment. The relationship was clear PPrently. Unfortunatley the 70's proved themn dead wrong. Again.

Can you beliee this guy? Who in their right mind would say, :because I am Z therefore I am right and do not NEED any arguments!

Once you understand how a check clears, you are ready to understand how modern banks create and destroy money. Suppose Bank A decides that it has $100 more of reserves than it wants. This means that it would prefer to hold an interest-bearing asset rather than non-interest bearing reserves. To obtain such an asset, it can write a check on itself and buy government securities (debt of the government that earns interest) from the public. The public now has a reduction in its security holdings and a check for $100 from Bank A. Suppose this check is deposited in Bank B. The check will clear as any check, and the end result will be the changes in this table:

Notice that the public now has $100 more in checking accounts than it previously had: money has been created. This creation of money is not readily apparent to anyone in the banking system. Bank A did not intend to create more money--it merely wanted to exchange non-interest bearing assets for assets that earn interest. Bank B receives the new money, but this new money looks to it just the same as the "old" money that it received when Jones wrote a check to Smith. The creation of money, an aspect of the banking system that economists consider central, is to the banking system merely a side effect or by-product of its quest for profit.

Banks also create money when they lend money to borrowers and they destroy money when loans are repaid. But banks cannot create money in unlimited amounts. Their ability to create money is limited by the amount of legal reserves they have and by regulations that tell them how much reserves they must hold.

Read and learn
 
Under a 10% reserve requirement:

New Depos. Reserves New Loan Aggregate New Loans - the new loan becomes a new deposit, either at the same or a different bank

$1.00 $0.10 $0.90 $0.90
$0.90 $0.09 $0.81 $1.71
$0.81 $0.08 $0.73 $2.44
$0.73 $0.07 $0.66 $3.10
$0.66 $0.07 $0.59 $3.69
$0.59 $0.06 $0.53 $4.22
$0.53 $0.05 $0.48 $4.70
$0.48 $0.05 $0.43 $5.13
$0.43 $0.04 $0.39 $5.51
$0.39 $0.04 $0.35 $5.86
$0.35 $0.03 $0.31 $6.18
$0.31 $0.03 $0.28 $6.46
$0.28 $0.03 $0.25 $6.71
$0.25 $0.03 $0.23 $6.94
$0.23 $0.02 $0.21 $7.15
$0.21 $0.02 $0.19 $7.33
$0.19 $0.02 $0.17 $7.50
$0.17 $0.02 $0.15 $7.65
$0.15 $0.02 $0.14 $7.78
$0.14 $0.01 $0.12 $7.91
$0.12 $0.01 $0.11 $8.02
$0.11 $0.01 $0.10 $8.11
$0.10 $0.01 $0.09 $8.20
$0.09 $0.01 $0.08 $8.28
$0.08 $0.01 $0.07 $8.35
$0.07 $0.01 $0.06 $8.42
$0.06 $0.01 $0.06 $8.48
$0.06 $0.01 $0.05 $8.53
$0.05 $0.01 $0.05 $8.58
$0.05 $0.00 $0.04 $8.62
$0.04 $0.00 $0.04 $8.66
$0.04 $0.00 $0.03 $8.69
$0.03 $0.00 $0.03 $8.72
$0.03 $0.00 $0.03 $8.75
$0.03 $0.00 $0.03 $8.77
$0.03 $0.00 $0.02 $8.80
$0.02 $0.00 $0.02 $8.82
$0.02 $0.00 $0.02 $8.84
$0.02 $0.00 $0.02 $8.85
$0.02 $0.00 $0.01 $8.87
$0.01 $0.00 $0.01 $8.88
$0.01 $0.00 $0.01 $8.89
$0.01 $0.00 $0.01 $8.90
$0.01 $0.00 $0.01 $8.91
$0.01 $0.00 $0.01 $8.92
$0.01 $0.00 $0.01 $8.93
$0.01 $0.00 $0.01 $8.94
$0.01 $0.00 $0.01 $8.94
$0.01 $0.00 $0.01 $8.95
$0.01 $0.00 $0.01 $8.95
$0.01 $0.00 $0.00 $8.96
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.96
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.97
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.97
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.97
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.98
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.98
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.98
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.98
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.98
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.99
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.99
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.99
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.99
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.99
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.99
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.99
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.99
$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $8.99

Well whaddya know, a $1 deposit led to $9 of new loans. Hmmm. $1 was MULTIPLIED by the banking system into $9 of new loans.
 
Gonna lose this argument burt. The man teaches the subject at University. You don't. Just a heads up. There are several people on this board that I have serious doubt are actually who they pretend to be. Someone isn't one of them.

see my notes above, and tell me where you disagree asterix
 
He is simply saying that the fractional reserve system results in new deposits etc, so all laons are matched by deposits. That is NOT the point.
Are you even smart enough to know that you are now completely contradicting yourself and admitting that you were completely wrong! Refresh your memory. To refresh you memory, you posted the following totally incorrect nonsense that started this exchange.
Dead wrong.

Banks lend out many TIMES what they have in deposits.
Look, banks ON AGGREGATE lend out more than they take in in the form of deposts - agreed?
Now you seem to be admitting that you were completely wrong. It took you long enough.
Under a 10% reserve requirement:

New Depos. Reserves New Loan Aggregate New Loans - the new loan becomes a new deposit, either at the same or a different bank
No kidding. This is what I tired to explain to you but you were too stupid to accept. To fresh your memory from the very first post you made in this thread which you are now admitting was completely wrong..
Not individual banks or even the system. Add up the sum total of deposits. Each loan becomes a new deposit.
Dead wrong.

Banks lend out many TIMES what they have in deposits.
Thank you for finally admitting that you have been completely wrong since the first post you made. However, you could have saved use both a lot of time by admitting that you were wrong earlier.
 
see my notes above, and tell me where you disagree asterix

I'm not an economist and not silly enough to get involved in such an argument. I just happen to believe someone is who he says he is.
 
“[Banks] do not really pay out loans from the money they receive as deposits. If they did this, no additional money would be created. What they do when they make loans is to accept promissory notes in exchange for credits to the borrowers' transaction accounts."
- 1960s Chicago Federal Reserve Bank booklet entitled “Modern Money Mechanics”

“The process by which banks create money is so simple that the mind is repelled.”
- Economist John Kenneth Galbraith

"[W]hen a bank makes a loan, it simply adds to the borrower's deposit account in the bank by the amount of the loan. The money is not taken from anyone else's deposit; it was not previously paid in to the bank by anyone. It's new money, created by the bank for the use of the borrower."
- Robert B. Anderson, Secretary of the Treasury under Eisenhower, in an interview reported in the August 31, 1959 issue of U.S. News and World Report

“Do private banks issue money today? Yes. Although banks no longer have the right to issue bank notes, they can create money in the form of bank deposits when they lend money to businesses, or buy securities. . . . The important thing to remember is that when banks lend money they don’t necessarily take it from anyone else to lend. Thus they ‘create’ it.”
-Congressman Wright Patman, Money Facts (House Committee on Banking and Currency, 1964)

"The modern banking system manufactures money out of nothing. The process is perhaps the most astounding piece of sleight of hand that was ever invented."
- Sir Josiah Stamp, president of the Bank of England and the second richest man in Britain in the 1920s.

"Banks create money. That is what they are for. . . . The manufacturing process to make money consists of making an entry in a book. That is all. . . . Each and every time a Bank makes a loan . . . new Bank credit is created -- brand new money."
- Graham Towers, Governor of the Bank of Canada from 1935 to 1955.
 
I'm not an economist and not silly enough to get involved in such an argument. I just happen to believe someone is who he says he is.
This is one reason I often stay away from the economics threads here. You get so many idiots that don’t even know that they don’t know. He did finally admit that he was wrong. However, he could have saved a lot of time by just admitting it in the beginning.
 
Good grief, you are such a turd.. (Just taking after you in the name-calling department, although if you insist on holding back as you have beedn doing recently I may have to reciprocate the civility).


Take 2 points, the beginnig and the END of the above chart. You know full well that the ORIGINAL DEPOSIT was leveraged into $9 of new loans, /The fact that they are represented on the other side of the balance shhet as deposits elsewhere does not change the fact that the ORIGINAL new deposit was $1 ONLY.

All you are saying is that all along the process the new loans are matched by new "de[posits', but the STARTING point is the original $1 or whatever loan.
 
This is one reason I often stay away from the economics threads here. You get so many idiots that don’t even know that they don’t know. He did finally admit that he was wrong. However, he could have saved a lot of time by just admitting it in the beginning.

I was decidedly NOT wrong, as you well know, an dlord knows I admitte dnothing. there are NO contradictions in my statements. I have consistenly said that banks create money. . WE both know what the end result of this proces sis, You are just saying that because each loan is matched in the system with a corresponding liability that nothing has been created.

LOL, I'd love to se eyou go through a REAL credit crunch - you'd learn pretty damn quickly what it's liek when the whole system runds in reverse an dcredit is destroyed.
 
Good grief, you are such a turd.. (Just taking after you in the name-calling department, although if you insist on holding back as you have beedn doing recently I may have to reciprocate the civility).


Take 2 points, the beginnig and the END of the above chart. You know full well that the ORIGINAL DEPOSIT was leveraged into $9 of new loans, /The fact that they are represented on the other side of the balance shhet as deposits elsewhere does not change the fact that the ORIGINAL new deposit was $1 ONLY.
Are you really this thick? What do you think Yoga and I have been talking about since the start of the thread. The only contribution you made was some nonsense about banks lending out more than they deposited. That was totally wrong.

All you are saying is that all along the process the new loans are matched by new "de[posits', but the STARTING point is the original $1 or whatever loan.
What the hell do you think we were talking about in every post since up until you posted your nonsense? You cannot be this thick. As should be obvious from the first few posts of this thread, we spelt out the details in a previous thread and started this one with the basics assumed to be common knowledge.
 
Look guy, I know far more about thus stuff then you do. I am the one who to gets paid to teach people like you this stuff.

**** OH, I bow to you Grand Pooh Bah!


*********

You are simply wrong here. I think your confusion is that you think the only deposit in the system is the original deposit. I would suggest you google the term “deposit creation multiplier” before you make a complete fool of yourself. The fact is that a bank’s liabilities (e.g. deposits people hold with it) must equal its assets (loans it has made plus reserves it keeps) plus equity (a small term). If you ever take a first-year course, this will be explained to you with what are called T accounts. The left side of which must always equal the right side.

The fact is each loan a bank makes creates new deposits of an equal amount (minus whatever proportion people decide to hold in cash).


You clearly do not understand what the Wikipedia passage says or you would know that nothing in it disagrees with anything I have said.

LOL, YOU have contradicted YOURSELF!
 
LOL, YOU have contradicted YOURSELF!
The only possible way you could come to that conclusion would be if you have absolutely no understanding of what we are talking about.
 
This is such BS, I ppointe dout in my first post that banks are responsibel in credit creation and an increase in the money supply, WHICH IS TRUE, and you couldnt stand anyone else saying anything in this forum without kowtowing to you.

So you had to get rude and insulting.
 
This is such BS, I ppointe dout in my first post that banks are responsibel in credit creation and an increase in the money supply, WHICH IS TRUE, and you couldnt stand anyone else saying anything in this forum without kowtowing to you.

So you had to get rude and insulting.
Look guy, the 13 posts before yours all were about money creation. The only contribution you made was some nonsense about banks lending out more than they had in deposits which you have now admitted was completely wrong. Now that you have admitted you were wrong, there is not much left to discuss.


Yoga Face, I am sorry you thread got so off topic. I will likely respond to your last post sometime when I am in a better mood.