Pirates: The Russian Solution

I believe that under MARITIME LAW if tried in a Maritime Court they can be hanged if found guilty of piracy.

Yup correct. They could hold a court martial trial presided over by officers of suitable rank and then execute them. I'm not a big fan of the death penalty, but then at least the rule of law would have been upheld. Would have been Russian law in this case as they were captured by a Russian ship, so it would have been under the Russian court martial system had they bothered to do it.
 
In other words you have a lot of wishful thinking as to how these crimes could be proved.

If it can't be proved so be it. It deserves a thorough investigation. It is possible that they are telling the truth and had nothing to do with the deaths of the Somalis. Seems unlikely, but they deserve a fair trial at which they're presumed innocent until proven guilty.
 
What the police would typically do in any such case is start out by gathering as much hard physical evidence as they can, fingerprints, ballistics, any video that might be present, hair fibres, things that establish who was where at what time, who did what, and so on. They would then interrogate all the participants separately. Usually someone will crack and fess up to what happened.
I don't want to beat a dead horse, so this will likely be it for me on this, but I'd like to try and clarify something.
I'm asking about prosecuting the Somalis for piracy. The Somalis who were on board the tanker when the Russians retook the ship. The same Somalis who didn't get killed by the russians in the fight to retake the ship, and that the Russians subsequently released back into their original vessel when the Russians felt they didn't have sufficient reason to detain them any longer. Those are the Somalis I'm asking about.
So, despite the Russian opinion that the Somalis physical presence on the tanker wasn't sufficient reason to hold them any longer, but finding fingerprints & hair fibres to establish that the somalis were on the ship would be sufficient to detain them further?? So, small tiny pieces of material evidence are better than the actual entity from which those pieces would have been left from?? The Russians felt they had no grounds to hold these remaining Somalis as suspected pirates any longer because they didn't have witnesses (crew was in the saferoom) or videos, but fingerprints and hair fibres would establish that the Somalis were in fact on board the ship (although the actual, entire, living & breathing man being on the ship at the time of the retaking would likely also confirm they were on board the ship).

Well, there you go. I certainly didn't know that & I hope that the Russian dudes don't hear this revelation, as it seems with fingerprints or hair fibres they could have proved that the men they just released off the ship were actual onboard the ship.
Thanks for clearing that up Fuji - your knowledge of investigative techniques and forensic sciences is remarkable.
 
Not in the least. I related what I know, which is pretty general, about how the police conduct an investigation--collect as much hard evidence as they can, interrogate people. He asked me for more details and I don't know more details, but it's their job and I'm pretty sure that if we assigned some cops to investigate these soldiers that they would know how to do their jobs.

As I read it, you implied that you had an understanding of forensics or investigative techniques that you felt I lacked. You didn't reveal anything remotely resembling insight or exceptional knowledge (actually, not even the proper application of common knowledge IMO). And I wasted some primo sarcasm on it in my other post. My sarcasm limits are finite, Fuji. If some other buddy of mine does or says something really really stupid, and I can't provide sarcasm because I've used my daily allotment on this....well, lets just say there'll be some unhappy campers at Camp Gecko today.

Fingerprints and hair fibres.....thanks again for the laughs!!!
 
Here's the end of this Pirate business!
sexy-pirate.jpg
 
So, despite the Russian opinion that the Somalis physical presence on the tanker wasn't sufficient reason to hold them any longer, but finding fingerprints & hair fibres to establish that the somalis were on the ship would be sufficient to detain them further?? So, small tiny pieces of material evidence are better than the actual entity from which those pieces would have been left from?? The Russians felt they had no grounds to hold these remaining Somalis as

Here's the thing: I don't believe the Russians. I think they captured the Somalis and then killed them in cold blood. I think everything they've said since has been to cover up a crime. While I'm decrying that, you will find several posters on this thread who think the same thing, but think it's right. I'm not alone in my opinion that this is what happened.

Do I have proof? No. No-one does. Hence the call for an inquest. If they're innocent of what I've said let it be known. If they're guilty--then let them hang.