Would I be charged if...?

Well, thanks to everyone that gave actual advice although it's still not clear to me what the law would do regarding provocation. Do they take that into account?

And I should point out I'm in my late thirties and the "Old man" was a healthy man probably in his fifities (not some geriatric guy with crutches). He initially cut me off and then has the nerve to call me a "fuck".

Regarding the ass touching thing, Sheik said he would grab the guy's throat. Isn't that like strangling? How is that different from a punch? So you can't be charged with assault with pushing or strangling?

If the other guy throws the first punch then I can claim "self-defense". Is this true? Can I go medieval on the guy if he punches me first?

Whatever happened to men settling their differences like men or protecting the honour of their women. So I gather, you'll get charged, have time in jail, have a criminal record and probably get sued by the other party. Over a single punch.

exactly.......and no you cannot go medievel on the guy ever. You can only do what you need to do to protect yourself. I for one would make sure he couldn't get up and come after me before I made my exit.

The charge would be aggravated assault if you were in fact charged.....
 
Does anyone know what the law is?

Maybe what the law is shouldn't matter? Do we always need the law to help decide what is the right thing to do?

Isn't it obvious that your course of action should be something like the following. With the guy grabbing your gf's butt, first get his attention so that he knows it's wise to cease his groping. Then ask your gf her thoughts. If she's OK with handling it herself, such as telling the guy to go jump, then leave it to her. If she wants you to have a word, then have a word. But beyond a particular maturity level, most girls appreciate a guy who can handle a situation without turning it into fight night. Since when does 'manning up' exclude you from using your brain?! If it still looks like going fight night, then you're clearly dealing with an idiot, at which point others might have the appropriate legal terms for you that define the legal rights of some dude accosted in a bar.
 
Maybe what the law is shouldn't matter? Do we always need the law to help decide what is the right thing to do?

Isn't it obvious that your course of action should be something like the following. With the guy grabbing your gf's butt, first get his attention so that he knows it's wise to cease his groping. Then ask your gf her thoughts. If she's OK with handling it herself, such as telling the guy to go jump, then leave it to her. If she wants you to have a word, then have a word. But beyond a particular maturity level, most girls appreciate a guy who can handle a situation without turning it into fight night. Since when does 'manning up' exclude you from using your brain?! If it still looks like going fight night, then you're clearly dealing with an idiot, at which point others might have the appropriate legal terms for you that define the legal rights of some dude accosted in a bar.

spoken like a true metrosexual lol........

let's all sit down and have a session before determining what the groper's real motivation is and address his childhood upbringing and then go for a big ol' group hug while handing out herbal tea and burning incense lol......

Pop the guy in the nose and be done with it.....
 
Well, thanks to everyone that gave actual advice although it's still not clear to me what the law would do regarding provocation. Do they take that into account?

They take provocation into account during sentencing.

If the provocation were extreme you might even get a discharge (finding of guilt but no penalty), more likely you would get a suspended sentence.

I doubt however that the examples you listed would be enough of a provocation to get you out of jail time. Provocation would be more like someone coming up and pushing you.


He initially cut me off and then has the nerve to call me a "fuck".

It's a free country people have a righ to be jack-asses and say obnoxious things. Your right to annoy people ends with words, though, you can't hit people who annoy you.

Regarding the ass touching thing, Sheik said he would grab the guy's throat. Isn't that like strangling?

I'd say that's borderline behavior but it depends on the situation. You've just witnessed the guy committing a sexual assault, you're entitled to place him under citizens arrest, and in so doing use whatever force is reasonable in the situaiton to do that. Grabbing someone by the throat is a a bit extreme but if there were some indication he was resisting or was likely to resist then providing you did not actually choke him it could be appropriate.

How is that different from a punch? So you can't be charged with assault with pushing or strangling?

If the guy started resisting citizens arrest you could punch him too. You just can't escalate the force beyond what is reasonable to keep him there. If the guy is not resisting at all and agrees to wait for the police you can't touch him. If he runs you can take him down and do whatever you need to to keep him there--but you have to stop when he stops resisting.

If the other guy throws the first punch then I can claim "self-defense".

Absolutely. MOreover he has committed a crime of assault against you at that point you can, again, use whatever force is necessary to hold him there until the police arrive.

In terms of self defense you can use force to defend yourself only so long as you are under threat. Once the threat has ended you cannot continue using force.

Is this true? Can I go medieval on the guy if he punches me first?

No. You must use the MINIMUM force that is necessary in the situation, being reasonable. The law will allow you some lattitude because it's hard to make a good call in a split second, but if the guy is down and you start kicking him that is plainly you committing a further assault, not using the minimum necessary to defend yourself.


Whatever happened to men settling their differences like men or protecting the honour of their women. So I gather, you'll get charged, have time in jail, have a criminal record and probably get sued by the other party. Over a single punch.

Yup. What happened was civilization.
 
Yup. What happened was civilization.

True, but damn, don't we all miss the dueling rapiers at dawn?

(I'd have said dueling pistols at dawn, but Fuji supports gun control re: handguns, so a fine rapier in the hand is just as good for a duel IMHO, and no loud bangs either to startle the neighbours).
 
but I would've and could've.

Are you positive?

I've seen many video's where tough young guys were put flat on their backs by "50ish old guys".
Maybe the "50ish old guy" would be the one charged with assault.
Just an observation.
 
fuji said:
I'd say that's borderline behavior but it depends on the situation. You've just witnessed the guy committing a sexual assault, you're entitled to place him under citizens arrest, and in so doing use whatever force is reasonable in the situaiton to do that. Grabbing someone by the throat is a a bit extreme but if there were some indication he was resisting or was likely to resist then providing you did not actually choke him it could be appropriate.

Sorry, you're contradicting yourself there fuji....you said in the other thread that one must be caught during the commission of a crime, not afterwards. If the guy had already touched his gf's ass, it is too late...according to you anyways......as you said, you have to catch them in the act, not later......nor before, but D U R I N G
 
And I should point out I'm in my late thirties and the "Old man" was a healthy man probably in his fifities (not some geriatric guy with crutches). He initially cut me off and then has the nerve to call me a "fuck".
That change in the facts is significant don't you think?
 
Well, the simple answer you posted above isn't quite accurate. A number of conditions would have to occur in order for the OP to be charged:

1) The police would have to be called
2) The police would actually have to arrive before the OP left
3) Someone would have to detain the OP as he is throwing the punch because (according to fuji) if someone tries to detain him after he has thrown the punch, the ones doing the detaining would be charged and the op would get a reduced sentence for being a witness. According to fuji, one has to be caught during the commission of a crime, not after it has occurred.....
4) The police would actually have to decide to press charges after hearing the whole story. In fact, if the ass grabber stuck around, he could be charged with sexual assault.
The above really isn't entirely accurate. For instance you certainly might end up being convicted although not technically having been arrested, you certainly can be convicted of a crime even if you were not detained during its commission etc. . .

When someone on a board like TERB posts "If I punch you in the nose will I be arrested" you get the basic straight legal answer yes. Not the carefull questioning designed to elicit all the pertinant facts nor necessarly the legal nuances e.g.: "You may be summonsed rather than arrested".

For TERB purposes - don't punch people in the nose!
 
spoken like a true metrosexual lol........

let's all sit down and have a session before determining what the groper's real motivation is and address his childhood upbringing and then go for a big ol' group hug while handing out herbal tea and burning incense lol......

Pop the guy in the nose and be done with it.....

Well I don't think I mentioned a group hug or pop psychology. I believe I noted just communication between GF and BF, followed by avoiding fight night if possible. If that's metrosexual then sign me up.

But heh, the Tboy's of the world confuse manly with neanderthal. The rest of us have evolved, what happened to you?
 
Are you positive?

I've seen many video's where tough young guys were put flat on their backs by "50ish old guys".
Maybe the "50ish old guy" would be the one charged with assault.
Just an observation.

Too many variables can enter your scenario, but in most cases, biology being what it is, some 2O year old claiming self defense would be looked at with an elfish grin coming from many corners. I'm not saying it couldn't happen, just not likely.

Who was it that said, 'age and treachery wins over youth and exuberance every time'.
 
Last edited:
spoken like a true metrosexual lol........

let's all sit down and have a session before determining what the groper's real motivation is and address his childhood upbringing and then go for a big ol' group hug while handing out herbal tea and burning incense lol......

Pop the guy in the nose and be done with it.....

you would "pop the guy in the nose" which is illegal but you wouldn't travel with $4,700 in cash which is legal?
 
I'd say that's borderline behavior but it depends on the situation. You've just witnessed the guy committing a sexual assault, you're entitled to place him under citizens arrest,
Fuji has given good advice in post #25. However, I would strongly emphasize his point three above. A citizen's arrest may be lawful, but it is very easy to go over the line and find yourself subject to criminal charges or civil suit.

As I previously posted far wiser is to call the police. That may not be entirely pratical in some small hamlet not quite north of 60, but in Toronto?



(Further not to cloud the issue, I don't have experience in the Upper Canada Bar, but I truly wonder if a Judge is going to agree with "ass grabbing" being considered Sexual Assualt, rather than physical Assault (and/or Battery) where I am it is going to be the latter rather than the former)
 
Question for the board...

In yesterdays version of this thread, I suggested "Don't sweat the small things in life". I also said that most women are more than capable of looking after themselves in such a case...

Scenario 1:

We are out at a club myself and the lovely Mrs. CG, it is crowded and someone places his hand on Mrs. CG's ass, and gives it a little squeeze. She turns around and there this dude standing there with a sly smile on his face. I was about to step in when Mrs. CG said to him, "Are you looking to get laid?" He replies smuggly, "As a matter of fact I am". She fires back, "Then you should go crawl up a chicken's ass and wait!" just loud enough that the people standing around could hear! He never bothered her again.

Scenario 2:

We are walking through a crowded club and some douchebag grabs her ass. She turns around swiftly and squares the guy right in the nuts with her purse! He doubles over in pain and never bothered her again.

As I said, women know how to deal with douche bags...

So here's my question: If she retaliates in such a manner as scenario 2- she is acting in self defence and is therefor absolved of any wrong doing should the situation escalate beyond this. Correct? If I happened to have stepped in in either scenario and clock the guy, am I still opening the door to an assault charge since the advance was made to Mrs. CG? Just curious?
 
Scenario 1: . . . Mrs. CG said to him, "Are you looking to get laid?" He replies smuggly, "As a matter of fact I am". She fires back, "Then you should go crawl up a chicken's ass and wait!" just loud enough that the people standing around could hear! He never bothered her again.

Scenario 2: . . . squares the guy right in the nuts with her purse! He double over in pain and never bothered her again.

So here's my question: . . . If I happened to have stepped in in either scenario and clock the guy, am I still opening the door to an assault charge since the advance was made to Mrs. CG? Just curious?

I cut up your post, Roller Boy, to get to the gist of it. I honestly don't know if you would be liabe to an assault charge - I'll leave that one to the lawyer dorks.

But I would still say that, because Scenario 1 and 2 lead to the same outcome (no more bothering), the path that involves the least amount of violence is better than the path with more. Less risk of escalation, less risk of legal problems, and less sweating over the little things. Besides, Mrs Roller Boy handles herself perfectly in Scenario 1, so I would say don't fix it if it aint broke. I take it the implication here, as well, is that Mrs Roller Boy has a cute butt?;)
 
Rollerboy? LOL!

I cut up your post, Roller Boy, to get to the gist of it. I honestly don't know if you would be liabe to an assault charge - I'll leave that one to the lawyer dorks.

But I would still say that, because Scenario 1 and 2 lead to the same outcome (no more bothering), the path that involves the least amount of violence is better than the path with more. Less risk of escalation, less risk of legal problems, and less sweating over the little things. Besides, Mrs Roller Boy handles herself perfectly in Scenario 1, so I would say don't fix it if it aint broke. I take it the implication here, as well, is that Mrs Roller Boy has a cute butt?
Coming from someone who chose "nolabel" for a handle, you are awfully quick to hand out labels of your own. :p

I've been called worse... and I like the youthfulness of how that sounds... so OK- knock yourself out. (Better than "conspiracy nutjob"!) LOL

Mrs. "Rollerboy" is well aware of how to handle herself. She is a bartender and has come across every type of douche bag there is I think.

The path of least resistance tends to be the best one in most cases- especially in such a case. Escalating things never ends well. **shudder**

As for her "cute butt", It sure as hell works for me! If you look hard enough, you may even find a picture floating around these parts. ;-)

Lastly... it has happened on a few occasions, where the grabber is female! These situations are handled entirely different! :-)
 
Scenario 2:

We are walking through a crowded club and some douchebag grabs her ass. She turns around swiftly and squares the guy right in the nuts with her purse! He doubles over in pain and never bothered her again. . .

So here's my question: If she retaliates in such a manner as scenario 2- she is acting in self defence and is therefor absolved of any wrong doing should the situation escalate beyond this. Correct? If I happened to have stepped in in either scenario and clock the guy, am I still opening the door to an assault charge since the advance was made to Mrs. CG? Just curious?
In the scenario you give above Cycleguy, if I were a Crown, yes I'd charge you. Now if "jerk" had Mrs CG in a choke hold, that would be a different answer.

As to Mrs. Cycleguy, it depends in part upon a) the mood of the Crown about such things in the local where it happened b) how hard she hit him, proportionality of response counts a lot. e.g. I'm a pig I cop-a-feel on some offended woman in a night club, she being a black-belt kicks me in the "vital organs" rupturing then and requiring surgical removal. Is she going to be charged - oh yes indeed.

In the scenario you describe and with no damage to "jerk" I'd probably either not charge or see if we could agree on a non-judicial remedy such as a contribution to a fund for men's sexual health awareness or some such thing.
 
In yesterdays version of this thread, I suggested "Don't sweat the small things in life". I also said that most women are more than capable of looking after themselves in such a case...

Scenario 1:

We are out at a club myself and the lovely Mrs. CG, it is crowded and someone places his hand on Mrs. CG's ass, and gives it a little squeeze. She turns around and there this dude standing there with a sly smile on his face. I was about to step in when Mrs. CG said to him, "Are you looking to get laid?" He replies smuggly, "As a matter of fact I am". She fires back, "Then you should go crawl up a chicken's ass and wait!" just loud enough that the people standing around could hear! He never bothered her again.

Scenario 2:

We are walking through a crowded club and some douchebag grabs her ass. She turns around swiftly and squares the guy right in the nuts with her purse! He doubles over in pain and never bothered her again.

As I said, women know how to deal with douche bags...

So here's my question: If she retaliates in such a manner as scenario 2- she is acting in self defence and is therefor absolved of any wrong doing should the situation escalate beyond this. Correct? If I happened to have stepped in in either scenario and clock the guy, am I still opening the door to an assault charge since the advance was made to Mrs. CG? Just curious?

Scenario #1 would probably do more damage than #2 and depending on witness statements and the worldliness of the cops , the situation would be dealt with quietly and file under' live with it you jerk'.
 
In the scenario you give above Cycleguy, if I were a Crown, yes I'd charge you. Now if "jerk" had Mrs CG in a choke hold, that would be a different answer.

As to Mrs. Cycleguy, it depends in part upon a) the mood of the Crown about such things in the local where it happened b) how hard she hit him, proportionality of response counts a lot. e.g. I'm a pig I cop-a-feel on some offended woman in a night club, she being a black-belt kicks me in the "vital organs" rupturing then and requiring surgical removal. Is she going to be charged - oh yes indeed.

In the scenario you describe and with no damage to "jerk" I'd probably either not charge or see if we could agree on a non-judicial remedy such as a contribution to a fund for men's sexual health awareness or some such thing.
So no consideration for what "jerk" did to Mrs CG/ Rollerboy to warrant the retaliation? :confused:
 
Coming from someone who chose "nolabel" for a handle, you are awfully quick to hand out labels of your own. :p

What can I say - I'm an enigma!

So no consideration for what "jerk" did to Mrs CG/ Rollerboy to warrant the retaliation?

Maybe the best way to put this is that jerk only did it to Mrs CG. Rollerboy was just along for the ride! Voyeurism on wheels . . .

Or, that when we have options, the law prefers we leave the violent ones to the law. Personally, I find that more conducive to civilization.