Would I be charged if...?

Enigma?

What can I say - I'm an enigma!
Wrapped in a riddle no doubt! I won't argue with you on that point. (I learned my lesson last time!)
Maybe the best way to put this is that jerk only did it to Mrs CG. Rollerboy was just along for the ride! Voyeurism on wheels . . .
Well I do like to watch!
evilgrin0039.gif
But only when Mrs. CG is havin some fun with one of her GF's!
 
LOL!!! That would be quite hilarious if in court your defense was that some old guy said fuck to you, so you knocked him out. I'm afraid you would require much more provocation to prove it was necessary to assault someone.

The ass grabbing thing on the other hand... you might get away with it with proper defense. You would be much more likely to get away with it if you just punch him ONCE and no more. Even still you might lose and even if you win, the legal process can be very stressful. It's best to try to solve things non violently.
 
So no consideration for what "jerk" did to Mrs CG/ Rollerboy to warrant the retaliation?
Perhaps on the Prairie in the days of Sam Steele you could get away with defending your fair lady's honour for ass grabbing. Today, however, we say you should call his friends (the Police) instead.

If "jerk" has your wife in a choke hold (threat of bodily harm or deadly force) of course you can grab or punch use judo holds to make him let her go. However if "all" "jerk" does is grab her ass - call the police, you can't punch him in the nose.

Now if you lets say shoved "jerk" rather than punched him in the nose, the judge might, might take it into consideration as a mitigating factor, but I certainly wouldn't bet on it and almost certainly not for the punch in the nose.
 
Well I don't think I mentioned a group hug or pop psychology. I believe I noted just communication between GF and BF, followed by avoiding fight night if possible. If that's metrosexual then sign me up.

But heh, the Tboy's of the world confuse manly with neanderthal. The rest of us have evolved, what happened to you?

nothing happened to me and if called upon, I'd have NO problem answering the call to defend this country. But if we take the "evolved" route, we'd still be having our "chit chat" while the enemy was at the gates......
 
you would "pop the guy in the nose" which is illegal but you wouldn't travel with $4,700 in cash which is legal?

Yup and Nope. I wouldn't carry that amount of cash while flying because it might raise a few red flags. Just like I wouldn't carry my leatherman, socket wrenches, contact cement, utility knife etc. All are legal but not while trying to board an airline....

BTW: as for illegal, I also smoke in no smoking zones, speed, run with scissors because, hey, I'm a rebel! lol......

(I have yet to hear anyone prove that poping the guy in the nose is illegal and because fuji says it is doesn't make it so....the ONLY people that can say it is legal or illegal are judges and or prosecutors).
 
The above really isn't entirely accurate. For instance you certainly might end up being convicted although not technically having been arrested, you certainly can be convicted of a crime even if you were not detained during its commission etc. . .

When someone on a board like TERB posts "If I punch you in the nose will I be arrested" you get the basic straight legal answer yes. Not the carefull questioning designed to elicit all the pertinant facts nor necessarly the legal nuances e.g.: "You may be summonsed rather than arrested".

For TERB purposes - don't punch people in the nose!

But that is what our justice system has become....a legal system full of nuances and loopholes and interpretation.....

Sorry, it should be permissable to pop someone in the nose for sexually assaulting your wife or gf.

If you get caught selling illegal handguns you SHOULD go to jail.

If you kill someone while racing you should spend years in jail and lose your licence forever.

But in our new PC legal system, none of the above is guaranteed to happen.
 
So, I'm in a rush, after work, walking through a store and this old guy cuts me off. He's taking his time so I go around him and he mutters under his breath "you fuck..." so I turn around and say "WHAT?" and he sheepishly says he was talking to himself.

First instance, you were a fuck. Be considerate of old slow guys.

No we don't need to stand behind people who move slowly. They know they move slowly. Why can't they be courteous instead of oblivious to others?

Every day I encounter 2 or 3 people who cut me off in a busy place and then... just stand there. They stand or sit at the bottom of stairwells. I need the handrail all the way down. They tell me to go around. They cut me off and stop in doorways, in front of turnstiles and ticket windows and stare into space. They step in my path at Starbucks and block the coffee cream counters. They arent buying anything. Just standing there.

I gently say "excuse me" and they either ignore me or get bent out of shape (ie "excuse me for living"). I have never wanted to punch any of them. Just give them a postit note to wear

8071740_95c69b88d8.jpg
 
Bullshit. You're exaggerating.

Mind you Tboy, I'd never do that to a lady, ESPECIALLY if she's with her boyfriend. Even if I'd make the fucker's life miserable with an assault charge or civil suit, people who do that are usually losers, and it ain't worth getting a broken nose.

I gotta dirty look once from some wetback (sorry but that's appropo for him by his conduct, even though I appreciate all cultures) at The Brix Club for telling his girlfriend who bumped into me that she was a great salsa dancer, to which she replied 'thank you' with a smile - then he gave me this mean look (what a mental midget), and then I said, 'you too' (well, he knew how to dance too of course). That seemed to calm the waves.

The pen is mightier than the sword, and it ain't being metrosexual.

But what would YOU do if some guy GRABBED your gf's ass NOT compliment her (neutrally) on her dancing? Apples and oranges my friend.

People have to learn (and some the hard way) that for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. If no one ever taught them right from wrong, someone has to.....

BTW: where I grew up if you took the metrosexual course of action you'd get your head handed to you in a platter before you got the first words out.......
 
But that is what our justice system has become....a legal system full of nuances and loopholes and interpretation......
I'm not going to disagree with you that the system can be complex. But what is so damn hard in this scenario with: No don't hit him, call the police!
 
But if we take the "evolved" route, we'd still be having our "chit chat" while the enemy was at the gates......

Obviously the T stands for Terminator. I guess it never occurred to you, Terminatorboy, that part of human evolution involved developing social intelligence by being part of community relationships not totally dominated by violent behaviour. So actually, contra what you imply, dealing with any kind of enemy in ways that individuals benefit from (in evolutionary terms) centrally involved chit chat. If humans had actually taken your punch first, talk later approach, we might still be swinging from the trees. Clearly you still appear to be doing so, but that's OK, evolution is known for having throwbacks.

BTW: where I grew up if you took the metrosexual course of action you'd get your head handed to you in a platter before you got the first words out.......

All that proves is that you deserve some sympathy for being exposed to shitty conditions in childhood. But isn't it the case that, as we mature, we like to act a bit different than we might have done as less mature individuals?

By the way, as an anecdote, I was once talking to a girl in a bar and some idiot grabbed her arm and thought she would like the whole 'me tarzan, you jane' approach to seduction. She said no and I said he should abide by her words, at which point he wanted to fight me. I declined, several times, pointing out it was, well, pointless and silly and also that he had had too much to drink. Once it became clear I wasn't going to take the bait, he stormed off. The girl and I ended up in the sack later, had a nice relationship for a few months, before amicable split and friendship. She always said she appreciated that I was not a neanderthal.
 
Yup and Nope. I wouldn't carry that amount of cash while flying because it might raise a few red flags. Just like I wouldn't carry my leatherman, socket wrenches, contact cement, utility knife etc. All are legal but not while trying to board an airline....

I think they'd confiscate them as they are prohibited items on airplanes (or prevent you from boarding if you insisted on keeping them), but they'd have to let the police determine if you were up to anything illegal.

Otherwise I'd have been busted for nail scissors a few years ago.
 
As "evolved" as some have alluded to, guess we do need us neanderthals to protect you metrosexuals. I don't care how "advanced" you are, words won't and can't stop a bullet once it leaves the end of the barrel. (think about that for a second)..........

The thing that all you "talk first" types are counting on is the fact that you think that cops will automatically charge me (or the nose popper). What you forget is that many (most?) cops are the neanderthal types that you seen to dispise. They too might appreciate the fact that one is standing up for someone important to them.

I used to hang out with quite a few cops and got to know some quite well. (probably why I can relate to their image in society and defend them) Having heard the thousands of stories of their exploits and encounters on the job, I can say with some certainty that if a cop is actually called to this situation (most bar fights only result in the combatants being escorted out the door), unless the ass-grabber is missing teeth or requires an ambulance, most will say: tsk tsk tsk you shouldn't have punched him, run your/my name, no wants no warrants no record, and send them/me on my way.

Having been in situations like this in the past, as I said, unless someone requires hospitalization, or it is a blatant attack w/o provocation, they will scold the participants and go on their way to more pressing matters.

Oh yeah, one more thing, for all you evolved types, don't worry, when push comes to shove I'll stand up for you too.......
 
Well, John, your story seems to fit with my experience(s).....yes, I'm not a bouncer but street cops "know" when and who to charge and who not to.

Like I said before, a LOT has to happen before charges can or will be laid. Like I also said, just leave before the cops show up......

Another saying came to mind after reading your post:

The only way evil can prevail is when good men do nothing......

BTW: if a guy simply said something untoward to my girl, I'd respond in kind. Since this thread is about physical contact, that is how I would respond.

As for agreeing/disagreeing, different strokes for different folks.

Oh and for the huggy/kissy types: I used to try and talk my way out of situations and pretty much always ended up getting blindsided. Ever since I started responding in kind, I survived unscathed. Something to remember....

and Brill? no, not rugged, just protective of those I care about.....
 
As "evolved" as some have alluded to, guess we do need us neanderthals to protect you metrosexuals. I don't care how "advanced" you are, words won't and can't stop a bullet once it leaves the end of the barrel. (think about that for a second)..........

We so-called metrosexuals only need a second to think about it, and realize pretty quickly it's better for the words to stop the bullet leaving the gun than to try and defend against a speeding bullet.

But I guess you're Superman, aren't you, Tboy?! Of course, as a neanderthal, you're still trying to figure that whole line of thinking out . . .

The only way evil can prevail is when good men do nothing...... not rugged, just protective of those I care about.....

There are many ways good men can prevail over evil, the same as there are many ways to protect those we care about. When your first port of call is violence, you might be part of the problem rather than the solution.
 
We so-called metrosexuals only need a second to think about it, and realize pretty quickly it's better for the words to stop the bullet leaving the gun than to try and defend against a speeding bullet.

But I guess you're Superman, aren't you, Tboy?! Of course, as a neanderthal, you're still trying to figure that whole line of thinking out . . .



There are many ways good men can prevail over evil, the same as there are many ways to protect those we care about. When your first port of call is violence, you might be part of the problem rather than the solution.

What you fail to see is that the bullet in this case (the ass grabbing) has already occurred. Your words are too late. Unless of course you plan on going into all bars and telling everyone to keep their hands off your gf. Since the bullet has already left the gun, and to prevent the next one from occurring, a pop in the nose is a like minded response. If the idiot was dumb enough to think grabbing a girls ass is permissable, then simply telling him probably won't do a thing.....

You see, guys who take it to the next level COUNT on metrosexuals not doing a thing. But when they go home with a bloody nose, they will remember that....definitely.

I mean, if words were/are so powerful, why don't you (nolabel) go over to afghanistan and simply tell the extremists to stop? (because they won't and your words won't mean a damn thing). Now I'm not comparing an ass grabber to a jihadist but you get my meaning.
 
Since the bullet has already left the gun, and to prevent the next one from occurring, a pop in the nose is a like minded response.

I see your point, Terminatorboy. Sometimes, violence might be the only way to stem further violence. Unfortunate, but real. That said, do you see my point that, in principle, two wrongs do not make a right? I am saying that, if it's possible to respond without violence, we should.

You see, guys who take it to the next level COUNT on metrosexuals not doing a thing. But when they go home with a bloody nose, they will remember that....definitely . . . I mean, if words were/are so powerful, why don't you (nolabel) go over to afghanistan and simply tell the extremists to stop? (because they won't and your words won't mean a damn thing). Now I'm not comparing an ass grabber to a jihadist but you get my meaning.

I do get your meaning. But note, for instance, the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. Despite very different views of that conflict existing, no-one denies that violence is begetting more violence in a never-ending spiral. Anyone with a brain can see that, at some point, someone in that conflict just has to act like what you call the metrosexual way. Someone has to stop. Somewhere, somehow. Otherwise they're going to go on hating each other and killing each other. Just like you, I don't want to directly compare a major conflict to an ass grabber. But, for the sake of argument, a major conflict can either be fought to the absolute death by bringing more destruction down on your opponent than they can manage to resist, OR someone can sue for peace. Someone can say 'enough is enough'. It might not work, I admit that, but if no-one tries, everyone just goes on killing each other.

I'm just saying that, if in big conflicts we hold out the hope of ending them through talk rather than violence, then it makes alot of social sense to practice that mind-set in all of the silly little conflicts that pervade our social world. As an open question, I wonder if you are one of those guys in the bars picking fights for little reason? Or one of those guys that always tends to escalate a situation rather than calm it down? If you are, you're a tool. If not, then rethink the whole 'fight night is my thing' attitude.
 
Nolabel:

No, I don't go around looking for or picking fights. I got in enough (for minor reasons) in my younger days. But in those days, I DID try and talk my way out of it and never took anything too seriously. On more occasions than not I ended up in the hospital with: broken cheekbone, broken ribs, broken leg, 20 stitches in my face, (almost) amputated earlobe, etc etc etc. Talking only made me the victim. Ever since I have responded in kind, I am no longer the one getting blindsided.

I also see your point about someone having to take the higher path but in my experience, those taking the higher path usually end up with the shitty end of the stick and I had enough of that end of the stick to last a lifetime.

The thing about the Palestinian/Isreal conflict isn't just violence, some of the mistreatment of the Palestinians on the west bank has a lot to do with it.

More locally: we're being taxed to death and the government wants to tax us more. What do you think would happen if 100 people went to ottawa and carried signs? Not a whole heck of a lot. What if 100 people armed to the teeth went to ottawa? A shitstorm. If the powers that be didn't pay attention to the 100 carrying signs, they sure as hell would if those same 100 were carrying ARs......

Anyhow, I'm not talking about going Jihad on the ass grabber, just a quick poke to let him know he's an ass.....(like I said, it turned physical when he went physical, if he had just said something, saying something back would be appropriate).