Worst trades ever ...

shinjitsu

Member
Jul 7, 2002
623
0
16
55
Toronto
Candidates ...

Hockey :
a. VAN trades Barry Pederson to BOS for Cam Neely and 1st round pick (Glen Wesley)

Wesley was later traded for 3 1st rounders (Samsonov, Aitken, K.McLaren)

b. VAN trades Trevor Linden to NYI for Todd Bertuzzi, Brian McCabe and 3rd round pick (Jarko Ruuttu)
c. NYI trades Robert Luongo, Olli Jokinen to FLO for Oleg Kvasha, Mark Parrish
d. OTT trades Pavel Demitra to STL for Christer Olsson
e. PITT trades Markus Naslund to VAN for Alex Stojanov
f. EDM trades Miro Satan to BUF for Craig Millar, Barrie Moore
g. EDM trades Jimmy Carson, Kevin McClelland to DET for Joe Murphy, Adam Graves, Petr Klima, Jeff Sharples
h. CHI trades Domenik Hasek to BUF for Stephane Beauregard, 4th round pick (Eric Daze)
i. WIN trades Kris Draper to DET for $1

and TOR fav
j. CAL trades D. Gilmour, R. Wamsley, J. Macoun, R. Nattress, K. Manderville to TOR for G. Leeman, J. Reese, M. Petit, A. Godynyuk, C. Berube.
 
b. VAN trades Trevor Linden to NYI for Todd Bertuzzi, Brian McCabe and 3rd round pick (Jarko Ruuttu)

Are you serious? Linden in his later years was a bum in Vancouver. And he washed out in NY and Montreal. Now back in Vancouver we all hope he'll get a little bit of a resurgence.

Bertuzzi has turned into a bag of chips and Snickers Bar. So thats positive. Hes also needs his head shrunk. So thats a negative. McCabe i believe jumped ship for better money. So thats a negative. Ruuttu is a thorn in the side of every opposing player who thinks they'll have there way with the Canucks.

Sorry shin... Canucks won this one..........BIG TIME. And his name is Todd (I may end up in jail) Bertuzzi. --- Kev
 
Minor correction, shin.

It was actually the other way around in the Bos/Van deal with Neely coming from Vancouver.
In the Canucks defense though.........Pederson was a quality player at the time. He racked up 315 points in 3 seasons for the B's ('82-84) got hurt in '85 but still rebounded in '86 to get 76 points.
He also played well for Van his first 2 years averaging close to a point a game.
(147 points in 155 games)
All in all still a brutal trade though.
 
Speaking of Vancouver.......

Anybody remember that great smoke job that Punch Imlach pulled on them in 1980?
He managed to get Rick Vaive and Bill Derlago for Tiger Williams and Jerry Butler.
Vaive would go on to captain the Buds and had 3 straight 50+ goal seasons.
The pair of them combined for 999 points in 7 years with God's team.
This deal is right up there with the Gilmour theft for fans of the Blue 'n' White.
 
Kev said:
b. VAN trades Trevor Linden to NYI for Todd Bertuzzi, Brian McCabe and 3rd round pick (Jarko Ruuttu)

Are you serious? Linden in his later years was a bum in Vancouver.

<snip>

Sorry shin... Canucks won this one..........BIG TIME. And his name is Todd (I may end up in jail) Bertuzzi. --- Kev

Yeah, I think Kev's a bit sensitive about his Canucks.
:rolleyes:
 
I can't believe nobody yet mentioned Courtnall for Kordick.
Yipes!
 
It was Kordic & a 6th Rd draft choice! Courtnall was a minus 35 on 'the hound line'. He could take the puck all over the ice but would usually end up blasting a slapshot wide of the net.
 
GlavaMan said:
It was Kordic & a 6th Rd draft choice! Courtnall was a minus 35 on 'the hound line'. He could take the puck all over the ice but would usually end up blasting a slapshot wide of the net.
Ain't that the truth!
Stellick gets slagged by some for making that deal but the fact is Courtnall was playing like Toller Fucking Cranston at the time.
No touch around the net..........didn't backcheck..........avoided anyone in an opposition sweater. He was useless.
In addition the Buds were getting pushed around nightly and were in desperate need of a major physical presence. Kordic was arguably the best fighter in the game. Absolutely wicked left hand.
I remember this era very well and I can tell you Leaf fans were thrilled at the time.
Drugs and booze were the only reasons Kordic didn't have a long career as an NHL tough guy.
 
Kathleen said:
Chicago Blackhawks traded Chris Chelios to the Detroit Red Wings for Anders Eriksson and 1st round selection (Steve McCarthy) in 1999 and 1st round selection in 2001
Chelios was involved in a trade even worse than that one Kathleen.
Montreal (where he'd already won a Norris trophy) moved him to Chicago for Denis Savard (a 170 lb. centre who smoked 3 packs a day!?!) in 1990.
Savard retired in '97.
Chelios was only 28 and in his prime, and went on to win 2 more Norris trophies in Chicago and 14 years later is still playing.

Speaking of Montreal........
Anybody recall who they got for Patrick Roy? LOL
 
Kathleen!

Speaking of Montreal........
Anybody recall who they got for Patrick Roy? LOL

Jocelyn Thibault - who hasn't lived up to his early promise.

But I can't believe how short the memories of the posters in this thread are! What about the Chicago Blackhawks trading Phil Esposito, Ken Hodge and Fred Stanfield to Boston for Pit Martin, Jack Morris, and Gilles Marotte in 1967?

Phil Esposito became the first player in NHL history to surpass 100 points when he scored 49 goals and added 77 assists for 126 points during the 1968-69 season. As a Bruin, Esposito led the NHL in goal scoring four times, including a startling 76 goals in 78 games during the 1970-71 season which absolutely shattered Bobby Hull's existing season's record of 58 goals. The following two years he tallied league leading totals of 66 and 55 goals.
 
Some bad baseball trades:

Baltimore trades Curt Schilling, Steve Finley, and Pete Harnisch for Glenn Davis

Boston trades Jeff Bagwell to Houston for Larry Andersen.

Montreal trades Brian Holman, Gene Harris and Randy Johnson to Seattle for Mark Langston in 1989. In 1990, Langston leaves via free agency to California, that ones gotta hoit.
 
GlavaMan said:
It was Kordic & a 6th Rd draft choice! Courtnall was a minus 35 on 'the hound line'. He could take the puck all over the ice but would usually end up blasting a slapshot wide of the net.

Maybe that was because Brophy was trying to turn him into a goon. Yeah, what a bad leafs trade, I think Rusty went on to put up some decent numbers with the habs.
 
ahhh the classic Leaf trade has to be Tom Kurvers to NJ for a first round draft pick which turned out to be Scott Niedermeyer :) heheheh
 
Cave Carson said:


But I can't believe how short the memories of the posters in this thread are! What about the Chicago Blackhawks trading Phil Esposito, Ken Hodge and Fred Stanfield to Boston for Pit Martin, Jack Morris, and Gilles Marotte in 1967?
Great call CC. I could only recall 2/3 of that trade. Couldn't remember Stanfield and I thought Morris was a good pitcher.

How did the Bruins get John MacKenzie from Chicago?

How about Ullman, Henderson and Smith to the Leafs and Mahovlich, Stemkowski and Unger to the Wings. Detroit didn't do well but Frank won Cups in Montreal and Unger was great with the Blues.

Leafs did well trading Tiger Williams and Jerry Butler to the Canucks for Vaive and Derlago.
 
How about this one the Sens screwed up & didn't make. They had a deal all done to send the '93 1st rd. pick(Alexandre Daigle) to Quebec for Peter Foresberg, Owen Nolan & Chris Simon + $$$. Someone high up in the Senators front office killed the deal. Foresberg had not played a game yet in the NHL.
 
Chara and Spezza to Ottawa from NYI for Alexi Yashin has to rank up there.
 
Kat,

On the Roy trade , Keane went with him to Colorado and coming back to them were:

1)Thibault as you mentioned.
2) Martin Rucinsky. Never panned out.
3) Andrei Kovalenko. Whaaa?

All in all this goes down as the biggest reason the Habs have spiraled.

The real issue was Tremblay couldn't or wouldn't "manage" Patrick's ego. He won the battle by getting rid of him but lost the war ... he got fired!
 
champ said:
Kat,
On the Roy trade , Keane went with him to Colorado and coming back to them were:
1)Thibault as you mentioned.
2) Martin Rucinsky. Never panned out.
3) Andrei Kovalenko. Whaaa?
All in all this goes down as the biggest reason the Habs have spiraled.
The real issue was Tremblay couldn't or wouldn't "manage" Patrick's ego. He won the battle by getting rid of him but lost the war ... he got fired!

Wrong....the 2 biggest reasons were :
Irving Grundman 78-83 (who can forget the Desjardins & Leclair trade for Mark Recchi) & Rejean Houle (95-00).
One player doesn't make a team.....Mtl would have kept on losing because of poor management and poor coaching. The Roy trade was the final nail in the coffin.
But better times are here with Bob Gainey.