Worst Trades in NBA

ice_dog

Member
Jan 13, 2002
667
1
18
TSN showed the worst 5 trades in NBA last night and I missed it. Here is a list from ESPN:

(1)Nets sell Dr. J to 76ers


(2)Golden State furnishes Celtics with Robert Parish and No. 3 pick (Kevin McHale)


(3)Bulls get Scottie Pippen from Sonics for Olden Polynice


(4)Blazers deal Moses Malone for draft pick


(5)Hornets give up rights to Kobe Bryant for Lakers' Vlade Divac

(6)Bucks trade Kareem Abdul-Jabbar to Lakers for Elmore Smith, Junior Bridgeman, Brian Winters and Dave Meyers.


(7)SF Warriors trade Wilt Chamberlain to 76ers for Paul Neumann, Connie Dierking, Lee Shaffer and cash in


I can see similarities between the Vince Carter trade and the Chamberlain trade( #7, above) in that

(a) the deal is one franchise player for a bunch of 'plumbers' and

(b) lots of emotion is involed. In each case, lots of hatred/anger is directed at the franchise player who has a temporary setback.

FYI: Wilt eventually beat the S.F. Warriors to win the NBA Titlle in 1967


Seems to me that those who think the Vince Carter is a a good trade are Cater-haters who are are not concerned about what the raptores got back in return.



Your thought ?
 
I've already voiced my displeasure over this trade in the other Raptors thread:
Quote "Carter demands a trade, quits trying for the team because in his mind he's already gone and forces the Raps to make a desperate trade- which BTW I thought was one of the stupidest and most lopsided trades in the history of sports. An all-star player for 2 has been BENCH players + a washed up guy who had no intention of ever playing here + 2 draft picks( I believe lottery protected).
Now the Raps are PAYING Zo to NOT play for the team and the other 2 players we got have now demanded to be traded. GREAT MOVE Babcock!!!!!

So in exchange for Carter- who is playing like man possessed, we might just end up w/ 2 lousy draft picks in years which there are no clear 'can't miss prospects'. Can you say swindled?"

Like I said, IMO this was one of the worst trades in all of sports (from T.O's perspective). I'm sure there were better offers out there than this one for VC. At the very least, Babcock could've waited longer for something better. Trading your franchise player for bench players and lottery protected draft picks plus an expensive bum was the best deal out there?!?!?! Just hanging on to Vince would've been better (at least we would've gotten more production than what the Williams' are currently doing). Obviously Carter was going to go eventually....but you don't trade your most valuable cattle for a handfull of un-magical beans!!!!!!
 
here's what I wrote in the VC thread

-Vince trade, so what did we get, eric williams( a very well respect vet) who told the NBA world he wants to be traded b/c the raptors are a joke(after what he witness in the locker room) and for lack of playing time....so this makes the raptors look great as a destination when a respected vet disses the franchise. Aaron williams hasn't done anything and will continue to do nothing.....Zo who the raptors paid 10 million not to play with us...but still count against the salary cap for the next 3 years and will be playing for Miami....and two lottery protected number one draft picks in a year when the draft is considered to be the weakest in the pass 10 years(best scenario is a 9 to low teen pick....which is not good since babcock's judgement of talent is suspect given he picked araujo at 8th when every scout projected araujo a high teen pick at best)

so new jersey dumped their garbage to the raptors in exchange for a all star player who avgs 26.6 pts (47% shooting), 6 rebounds and dropping 5.2 dimes and actually plays defense(not last night, but if you've been watching his games)

Some have said Babcock had his hands tied....but he could have traded Vince straight up for Shareef Abdur-Rahim and portland's number 1 pick.....at least Shareef's contract expires this summer giving the raptors cap space and a draft pick...instead of paying 10 mill for Zo and paying for aaron and eric williams for 3 more years. But Babcock forced the issue by trying to dump Rose along with vince to portland

yeah the trade sucks...not even with hind-sight....alot of the other GM's at the time couldn't believe or understand this trade

babcock is a foolio
 
IMO maybe that was the best deal we could get for V.C...
Think about it the last 3 seasons V.C was either plagued by injuries (knees, thigh's) and he has been exploited on his D by better players. I think his first 2 seasons were great because everyone including players/ coaches stopped and watched him do amazing dunks and not tried to fiqure a way to stop him. After those few seasons and Oakley calling him soft coaches figured him out and knew that if they played tight defense on him he was shut down.
V.C isnt a great dribbler and if you double team him early at the top of the key he's screwed and will have to either put up a off balance high risk shot or pass..

This is why I think that not alot of teams would really be interested in picking up that huge contract knowing that 80% of the coaches in the league know how to stop him. It's been proven that he's not a go-to playa in the clutch, he's more like a Scoty Pipen. The kind of guy that will have hot games now and then but never lead a team to a ring night after night..

Think about it, would you pick-up that big contract on a player that has had various injuries year after year and thats been proven to not take any responsibility for leading a team? I wouldnt, not even if you're the best dunker in the NBA....But thats just me
 
ice_dog said:
TSN showed the worst 5 trades in NBA last night and I missed it. Here is a list from ESPN:

(1)Nets sell Dr. J to 76ers
(4)Blazers deal Moses Malone for draft pick
(6)Bucks trade Kareem Abdul-Jabbar to Lakers for Elmore Smith, Junior Bridgeman, Brian Winters and Dave Meyers.
I would hardly call these deals the worst in history. They were lopsided for a reason. The teams that dealt these players knew what they were going to lose.

1. The Nets sold Julius Erving because the franchise was going bankrupt. Erving was the most marketable player in the ABA, and the NBA was willing to do anything to get him to play for their league.

2. Malone never played for the Blazers. He played for the Utah Stars of the ABA, and then Houston and Philly in his glory years. The trade I assume you are talking about is the ABA dispersal draft after the league folded. The Blazers didn't need a 20yr old Malone. They already had Bill Walton and won the title in 1977 proceeding the 1976 ABA dispersal draft. The draft pick wound up being the 2nd pick in the 1984 draft.

3. Jabbar was going to be a free agent. He wasn't going to sign with Milwaukee. He was going to play for his hometown of NY. He wasn't interested playing anywhere else. Wayne Embry did this deal because Jabbar didn't mind going to LA where he went to UCLA.

(7)SF Warriors trade Wilt Chamberlain to 76ers for Paul Neumann, Connie Dierking, Lee Shaffer and cash in


I can see similarities between the Vince Carter trade and the Chamberlain trade( #7, above) in that

(a) the deal is one franchise player for a bunch of 'plumbers' and

(b) lots of emotion is involed. In each case, lots of hatred/anger is directed at the franchise player who has a temporary setback.

I don't see any similarities at all. Chamberlain is the most dominant player to ever play the game. He is arguably the greatest player ever. Vince Carter, most likely, will not be inducted into the Hall-of-Fame. Chamberlain is a franchise player. Carter isn't. Carter belongs in the same group as Bob Love, Walt Bellamy, and Lou Hudson. They were good players, but couldn't lead their teams anywhere. Carter, half-man half-assed effort, mailed it in alot of times. Chamberlain played his ass off because he had something to prove to his many critics.

FYI: Wilt eventually beat the S.F. Warriors to win the NBA Titlle in 1967
Only when Alex Hannum convinced him that defense, rebounding, and setting up his teammates was best for the team instead of trying to put up 60+ points every game.
 
I didn't mean Carter is of the same calibre as Chamberlain. What I meant are

(1) Their impacts on their teams are similar- Carter is the only All-star Raptor ever had. He is the one who put Toronto on the NBA map. Wilt is the only guy(so far) to help the 76 ers to win a Title. Of course, nobody expected Carter to lead the Raptos to an NBA title. Not by a long shot. Carter has yet to learn to play defense, and

(2) Both the S.F. Warriors and the Toronto Raptors received lousy compensation for what they gave away.
 
ice_dog said:
(1) Wilt is the only guy(so far) to help the 76 ers to win a Title.

Julius Erving led the 1983 76er's to the NBA championship, sweeping the Lakers in the finals.
 
I believe V.C. "faked or exagerrated his last injury to go out of Toronto", as Bobcock pointed out after the trade to New Jersey, "He's fine", implying as "he doesn't need to get a medical clearance from the New Jersey doctor" to play for NJ. You can see how he played this season, he clearly wanted out of Toronto, but I understand his side, with the new management and a "rookie coach"(who says his way is the only way"), Toronto is geared for building up again and he sees himself not part of the building up process. I resigned to the fact that they did not improve the team through the trade( I would like to see a real point guard and a Center) Maybe next year. After the draft and some possible trades , we'll gonna see a clear picture of how the big bosses want for Toronto. AS a die hard fan Of the Raptors, I will be watching closely......
moneyshotz said:
IMO maybe that was the best deal we could get for V.C...
Think about it the last 3 seasons V.C was either plagued by injuries (knees, thigh's) and he has been exploited on his D by better players. I think his first 2 seasons were great because everyone including players/ coaches stopped and watched him do amazing dunks and not tried to fiqure a way to stop him. After those few seasons and Oakley calling him soft coaches figured him out and knew that if they played tight defense on him he was shut down.
V.C isnt a great dribbler and if you double team him early at the top of the key he's screwed and will have to either put up a off balance high risk shot or pass..

This is why I think that not alot of teams would really be interested in picking up that huge contract knowing that 80% of the coaches in the league know how to stop him. It's been proven that he's not a go-to playa in the clutch, he's more like a Scoty Pipen. The kind of guy that will have hot games now and then but never lead a team to a ring night after night..

Think about it, would you pick-up that big contract on a player that has had various injuries year after year and thats been proven to not take any responsibility for leading a team? I wouldnt, not even if you're the best dunker in the NBA....But thats just me
 
ice_dog said:
TSN showed the worst 5 trades in NBA last night and I missed it. Here is a list from ESPN:

(4)Blazers deal Moses Malone for draft pick

Even worse, the Blazers passed on both Larry Bird and Michael Jordan in the NBA drafts. Hard to believe.