Why I Am An Atheist

I think that there is a cultural difference between atheists in Canada and those south of the border for a good reason. Here we don't see the same extent of right wing Evangelical voting block: get creationism in the schools, anti gay marriage, anti abortion, etc. Harper may personally hold (some of) these beliefs but he is not pushing them.

The "Laissez-faire" mindset applies across the spectrum.

Aside from the fruit cake McVety, we don't have the likes of James Dobson, Charles Colson, Pat Robertson, Billy Graham having prayer breakfast with the country's leaders, George Bush and his faith based initiatives...
 
I didn't claim that religious texts had no relevance in establishing what morality is or isn't. I actually affirmed that fact.

There are lots of good lessons and fables in the Bible that tell people how to live a good and virtuous life, and our Charter and Constitution have probably adapted those lessons.

Nevertheless, archaic lessons that the religious right tend to follow still to this day, such as the prohibition of gays marrying, or on premarital sex, or on masturbation, just a few examples, are absurd. Lessons that their version of what sin is will lead you to an eternal life of damnation are also absurd and should and have been abandoned. Sex not for the reason of procreation? Why are you on this site? Hm? Are you beating up yourself every day for your lust? Seems counter-productive to me.

Just because a text has made an impact and has lead us to where we are today doesn't mean we still need to take everything it says as valuable. To do so is folly.

Suggesting that the law courts and legislation are a complete substitute for morality and ethics was just unwise.
 
I didn't claim that religious texts had no relevance in establishing what morality is or isn't. I actually affirmed that fact.

There are lots of good lessons and fables in the Bible that tell people how to live a good and virtuous life, and our Charter and Constitution have probably adapted those lessons.

Nevertheless, archaic lessons that the religious right tend to follow still to this day, such as the prohibition of gays marrying, or on premarital sex, or on masturbation, just a few examples, are absurd. Lessons that their version of what sin is will lead you to an eternal life of damnation are also absurd and should and have been abandoned. Sex not for the reason of procreation? Why are you on this site? Hm? Are you beating up yourself every day for your lust? Seems counter-productive to me.

Just because a text has made an impact and has lead us to where we are today doesn't mean we still need to take everything it says as valuable. To do so is folly.

Just because one disagrees with a text or an idea does not mean that other people who hold it are delusional or that they should all jetison their ideas because I tell them to.

For instance, I am not jewish, but I don't suggest that orthodox jews should dress differently, or think differently. It is called respecting your neighbour.

You seem to have a holier-than-thou attitude towards religious folks, which is certainly not justified by the quality of your ideas or arguments.

I kind of like my neighbours and I kind of like the fact that they think and believe different things than me.
 
The bible may not claim to be a science text book, but many of its followers do. That is because they beleive it is the inspired and inerrant word of god. If it is to be taken as inerrant in any sense then it does make many claims about nature, origins, etc. If you take this all to be allegory, non-literal, etc. then good for you, but it then calls into question other aspects of historicity, etc. and the very existence of the man Jesus, or at the very least the results of the teachings attributed to him. And every other aspect of the so called "revelation" of god to man.

The people who claim things like the bible says the world is X years old, or the bible says evolution is not possible, simply have not read it. However there is excellent historical evidence that Jesus existed, and that many of the historical events in the bible happened.
 
God is a man, make no mistake about that. The bible clearly states that a woman is on this earth to serve her man.

Not precisely. The position of the bible (or rather multiple positions in the bible) are a little more nuanced than that.

I used the he/she reference because IIRC one of the Hebrew words in the OT for god is feminine plural, not masculine single.
 
I agree. I thought rld's response was insightful. I respectfully disagree with his position on moral authority.

I appreciate the kind words from you and Kenzie. And I am cool with people who disagree with me. Civil disagreement is the basis of a good conversation.
 
I think that there is a cultural difference between atheists in Canada and those south of the border for a good reason. Here we don't see the same extent of right wing Evangelical voting block: get creationism in the schools, anti gay marriage, anti abortion, etc. Harper may personally hold (some of) these beliefs but he is not pushing them.

The "Laissez-faire" mindset applies across the spectrum.

Aside from the fruit cake McVety, we don't have the likes of James Dobson, Charles Colson, Pat Robertson, Billy Graham having prayer breakfast with the country's leaders, George Bush and his faith based initiatives...

I think you make an important point about our political and social culture. We are much less radical than our neighbours to the south or in the UK for that matter. We are a very tolerant culture and I think we should be proud of that.

And on the other side of the coin we don't have the equivilent of say Dawkins, Harris, or Hitchens, or that French atheist whose name escapes me.
 
there is that possibility that god/gods exist despite the complete lack of evidence
Some people would argue the incredible complexity of life is evidence enough the world was constructed by some type of Creator.

Take the human eye for example, something like a million chemical reactions go on each day just so we can see
 
There's things in the Bible that actually happened? So what? It's the extraordinary things in the Bible there is zero evidence for and that is mainly what we are concerned with. Supposedly this Jesus chap went around Judea for a few years doing wondrous things like walking on water, turning water into wine, magically increasing food supplies exponentially, curing lepers and blind people, controlling the weather, making dead people alive again and then performing the same feat himself for his final hurrah. Yet these magical deeds are only mentioned in the gospels and some christian apochrypha, all written at least 40 years after the fact by non witnesses. No-one else thought to record these miraculous events at the time they happened. There are zero contemporaneous accounts of Jesus and his life, and virtually nothing of any use outside of the gospels or apochrypha. I'm not saying Jesus didn't exist, he probably did, but extraordinary claims require solid evidence and there is none.

.... and most of what you've mentioned has been dealt with in earlier threads, especially the lack of contemporary records.
 
Some people would argue the incredible complexity of life is evidence enough the world was constructed by some type of Creator.

Take the human eye for example, something like a million chemical reactions go on each day just so we can see

Some people? Are you arguing that?
 
There's things in the Bible that actually happened? So what? It's the extraordinary things in the Bible there is zero evidence for and that is mainly what we are concerned with. Supposedly this Jesus chap went around Judea for a few years doing wondrous things like walking on water, turning water into wine, magically increasing food supplies exponentially, curing lepers and blind people, controlling the weather, making dead people alive again and then performing the same feat himself for his final hurrah. Yet these magical deeds are only mentioned in the gospels and some christian apochrypha, all written at least 40 years after the fact by non witnesses. No-one else thought to record these miraculous events at the time they happened. There are zero contemporaneous accounts of Jesus and his life, and virtually nothing of any use outside of the gospels or apochrypha. I'm not saying Jesus didn't exist, he probably did, but extraordinary claims require solid evidence and there is none.

You are missing the point I was making. I was just responding to the suggestion that an allegorical view of the bible could mean Jesus did not exist.

I would differ with you on two points. The first is that to historians, biblical scholars and classicists, the non-biblical references to Jesus are of significant importance.

Secondly, there are no extant contemporaneous accounts of Jesus and his life. Just like there are no extant contemporaneous accounts of say...Alexander the Great, or other historical figures. And while there are no contemporaneous accounts extant, most scholars believe that the canonical gospels are based on older documents that are now lost to us. Not an unusual fact situation for that period.

And I am not suggesting for a minute that there is any evidence for the miracles in the NT or the OT for that matter.
 
Some people would argue the incredible complexity of life is evidence enough the world was constructed by some type of Creator.

Take the human eye for example, something like a million chemical reactions go on each day just so we can see

I think the human eye example is a little out of date. Now the argument seems to be more of a cosmic fine tuning argument, which as I understand it, is still being hotly debated.
 
Now the argument seems to be more of a cosmic fine tuning argument, which as I understand it, is still being hotly debated
What the heck is the "cosmic fine tuning argument"?? You mean how the universe was created??
 
What the heck is the "cosmic fine tuning argument"?? You mean how the universe was created??

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fine-tuned_Universe



The fine-tuned Universe is the proposition that the conditions that allow life in the Universe can only occur when certain universal fundamental physical constants lie within a very narrow range, so that if any of several fundamental constants were only slightly different, the Universe would be unlikely to be conducive to the establishment and development of matter, astronomical structures, elemental diversity, or life as it is presently understood.[1] The existence and extent of fine-tuning in the Universe is a matter of dispute in the scientific community.
Physicist Paul Davies has asserted that "There is now broad agreement among physicists and cosmologists that the Universe is in several respects ‘fine-tuned' for life".[2] However he continues "...the conclusion is not so much that the Universe is fine-tuned for life; rather it is fine-tuned for the building blocks and environments that life requires".[2] He also states that "... 'anthropic' reasoning fails to distinguish between minimally biophilic universes, in which life is permitted, but only marginally possible, and optimally biophilic universes, in which life flourishes because biogenesis occurs frequently ..."[2] Among scientists who find the evidence persuasive, a variety of natural explanations have been proposed, e.g., the anthropic principle along with multiple universes. The proposition is also discussed among philosophers, theologians, creationists and intelligent design proponents.

I am pretty sure that the publications of Gould and Dawkins on the subject has laid the irreducible complexity of the eye argument to rest. But I stand to be corrected.

Gould also did an amazing job dealing with the "part of a wing is no good" argument.
 
Some people would argue the incredible complexity of life is evidence enough the world was constructed by some type of Creator.

Take the human eye for example, something like a million chemical reactions go on each day just so we can see

Then they would have a completely faulty line of reasoning which simply says 'I don't understand so it must be god'.
 
Despite having no faith in religion, I find self described atheists who feel the need to preach and convert ironically religiously dogmatic.



As a scientifically minded person, I can't call myself atheist since there is that possibility that god/gods exist despite the complete lack of evidence.

I am an atheist...and I and every other atheist I know have absolutely no desire to convert anybody to atheism. We don't want any particular religion to dictate how society should be...but that is far different than wanting to convert anyone.

In fact, if someone believes in God, or the tooth fairy, or Santa Claus...I have no desire to see them change their belief. I wish the same courtesy extended to me.

As for the possibility that some sort of god/gods exist...sure, it is possible. But since there is no evidence for it I am without belief in any theistic god...hence I am atheist.
 
I have no problem with that view but if the post was 'Why I love Jesus' many Atheists would get all uppity for having religion rubbed in their faces.
 
When people say that faith is belief that does not need proof or evidence I think of the Hitchen's quote that "that which is asserted without evidence may be dismissed without evidence." As for the idea of non overlapping magisteria that would be one way to function, but religion does not do that. Miracles are the physical intrusion of the supernatural into the natural world, and therefore can be measured, if we could ever study one.

The issue for people with faith is that while there are dozens of telvision shows about religion, and religion gets special status (no taxes etc) in society, they are very quick to take offense if someone says I think your story is a fairytale.
Holding a belief in the face of contrary evidence may show devotion to a cause, but at some point you need to be able to let go of wrong beliefs and accept evidence of reality.

And the religious people do not respect the idea of non overlapping. They take their beliefs into the social and political world. Commanded by God to convert people, to spread the word, yet say atheists are strident and shrill if any voices are raised in opposition to them. or they act on their unsupported beliefs and try to impose their beliefs on others, socially and politcally.
Is there a non-religious argument against gay marriage? Religiously they are an abomination according to leviticus, but if we lived in a world with no bibles or religions then what would the arguments against a union between two consenting adults be?

Religion is used to justify hatred of gays, of women, of children, of anyone 'other'. We have the Westboro baptist church picketing funerals, abortion doctors killed, civil rights argued against because of religious reasons. Children are blinded because they want to read a book other than the Koran. Cartoons cause the deaths of a dozen people. This is all justified on faith, and without a need for evidence. I think if you want to behead someone for sorcery which happened last week in Saudi Arabia, you better have evidence that the person killed was casting spells.

I put religion alongside belief in the Supernatural, along with angels, fairies and leprechauns. There's no evidence for any of those either. But if someone wanted to get a tax exemption to build a shelter for homeless leprechauns they would not get very far.

Sam Harris wrote "The president of the United States has claimed, on more than one occasion, to be in dialogue with God. If he said that he was talking to God through his hairdryer, this would precipitate a national emergency. I fail to see how the addition of a hairdryer makes the claim more ridiculous or offensive."
 
Just reading a new book by Victor Stenger called "God and the Folly of Faith: The Incompatibility of Science and Religion".

Some good opening quotes:

Science flies us to the moon.
Religion flies us into buildings.
- Victor Stenger

Quiettype you will like this:

That which can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.
- Christopher Hitchens
 
When people say that faith is belief that does not need proof or evidence I think of the Hitchen's quote that "that which is asserted without evidence may be dismissed without evidence." As for the idea of non overlapping magisteria that would be one way to function, but religion does not do that. Miracles are the physical intrusion of the supernatural into the natural world, and therefore can be measured, if we could ever study one.................

................. Religion is used to justify hatred of gays, of women, of children, of anyone 'other'.
We have the Westboro baptist church picketing funerals, abortion doctors killed, civil rights argued against because of religious reasons. Children are blinded because they want to read a book other than the Koran. Cartoons cause the deaths of a dozen people. This is all justified on faith, and without a need for evidence. I think if you want to behead someone for sorcery which happened last week in Saudi Arabia, you better have evidence that the person killed was casting spells.

I put religion alongside belief in the Supernatural, along with angels, fairies and leprechauns. There's no evidence for any of those either. But if someone wanted to get a tax exemption to build a shelter for homeless leprechauns they would not get very far.

Sam Harris wrote "The president of the United States has claimed, on more than one occasion, to be in dialogue with God. If he said that he was talking to God through his hairdryer, this would precipitate a national emergency. I fail to see how the addition of a hairdryer makes the claim more ridiculous or offensive."

You say this as if religion does nothing good for people, which of course is not the case. Since POTUS hasn't said that, the national emergency is laid to rest.