Why I Am An Atheist

David007

Member
Nov 23, 2010
143
9
18
I posted this on CL R&R, so thought I would put it up here as well...

Why I Am An Atheist

- The reason why bad things happen to good people is the same as why good things happen to bad people: Chance. The simplest solution to the problem of evil in nature is no God. Occam's Razor is satisfied.
- The multiplicity of religions clearly shows that religion is man made.
- The fallacy of Pascal's Wager. If I choose a Christian God might I go to Allah's hell? Vice Versa? Do I roll the dice and hope to get the winning religion?
- Perhaps you know someone like this: They live their whole life as abusers, alcoholic, selfish, and then just before they die, they say the sinner's prayer and presto they are saved - they will spend "eternity in heaven".
- On the other hand I was a born again Christian for 15 years, went to an Evangelical Seminary, and was an Evangelist. Now that I am an atheist, if I die today, I will spend "eternity in hell".
- Evolution is a scientific fact.
- Cosmology explains origins simply.
- I choose the "Magic of Reality", i.e., the scientific method and statistics, physics, cosmology, evolutionary biology, genetics, geology, and paleontology, rather than "God Said It, I Believe It, That Settles It".
 
I posted this on CL R&R, so thought I would put it up here as well...

Why I Am An Atheist

- The reason why bad things happen to good people is the same as why good things happen to bad people: Chance. The simplest solution to the problem of evil in nature is no God. Occam's Razor is satisfied.
- The multiplicity of religions clearly shows that religion is man made.
- The fallacy of Pascal's Wager. If I choose a Christian God might I go to Allah's hell? Vice Versa? Do I roll the dice and hope to get the winning religion?
- Perhaps you know someone like this: They live their whole life as abusers, alcoholic, selfish, and then just before they die, they say the sinner's prayer and presto they are saved - they will spend "eternity in heaven".
- On the other hand I was a born again Christian for 15 years, went to an Evangelical Seminary, and was an Evangelist. Now that I am an atheist, if I die today, I will spend "eternity in hell".
- Evolution is a scientific fact.
- Cosmology explains origins simply.
- I choose the "Magic of Reality", i.e., the scientific method and statistics, physics, cosmology, evolutionary biology, genetics, geology, and paleontology, rather than "God Said It, I Believe It, That Settles It".

Atheism is as valid a choice for worldview as any other.

However since you chose to post it, I would guess you do so in the spirit of discussing its contents. It does get me thinking and I do have a few comments about your post:

First is that so much of it is simply negative about other worldviews. Atheism seems to build itself principally on criticizing other worldviews and often suffers from a lack of positive elements (though the last point does deal with this). This makes me question the spiritual and practical utility of atheism. What does it add? What is it good for?

The vast majority of Christians in the world, and many Christian denominations including the RCC (the largest Christian denomination) also treat evolution as a fact.

You miss apply Occam's Razor.

You mis-characterize a great deal of Christian doctrine, or choose to define yourself versus the most radical Christian doctrine, kind of like arguing about evolution with someone who barely knows the science or still believes in pangenesis or Lamarkian biological evolution. You would be better off learning about more mainstream or intellectual elements of Christian thinking and considering those ideas in your worldview.

The multiplicity of religions does not prove that religion is man made any more than the multiplicity of primates proves that primates are man made. You have a better argument that the multiplicity of religions suggests religion has evolved. You use the word proof far too easily.

The argument on Pascal's wager is a very strong one indeed.
 
Why do atheists feel the need to spread their religion around? They're worse than Jehova's IMO.

I checked out the site reddit the other day, and it is filled with atheist vitriol and cartoons. Please get a life!
 
Atheism is as valid a choice for worldview as any other.

However since you chose to post it, I would guess you do so in the spirit of discussing its contents. It does get me thinking and I do have a few comments about your post:

First is that so much of it is simply negative about other worldviews. Atheism seems to build itself principally on criticizing other worldviews and often suffers from a lack of positive elements (though the last point does deal with this). This makes me question the spiritual and practical utility of atheism. What does it add? What is it good for?

The vast majority of Christians in the world, and many Christian denominations including the RCC (the largest Christian denomination) also treat evolution as a fact.

You miss apply Occam's Razor.

You mis-characterize a great deal of Christian doctrine, or choose to define yourself versus the most radical Christian doctrine, kind of like arguing about evolution with someone who barely knows the science or still believes in pangenesis or Lamarkian biological evolution. You would be better off learning about more mainstream or intellectual elements of Christian thinking and considering those ideas in your worldview.

The multiplicity of religions does not prove that religion is man made any more than the multiplicity of primates proves that primates are man made. You have a better argument that the multiplicity of religions suggests religion has evolved. You use the word proof far too easily.

The argument on Pascal's wager is a very strong one indeed.

Hey RLD, thanks for the discussion! Much appreciated.

Good point about RCC and Evolution. My point would be Evolution is necessary for atheism. I probably should have titled it "Why I Converted from Evangelical Christianity to Atheism".

To the other posters, I mean no disrespect. I'm not about to go stand on Yonge and Dundas and start preaching Atheism. The lounge is a discussion forum. This topic has been discussed many times in the past, so just a continuation of that theme.
 
:biggrin1:

atheism1.jpg
 
How about zero empirical evidence of the supernaural. That'll do me.

You are missing the point of religion. Religion is based on faith which is the absence of empirical evidence. It is believing the face of what may appear to be insurmountable contrary evidence. People of religion generally also believe that they cannot necessarily comprehend their god's plan and so when someone say why do bad things happen to good people although we may not understand why the faithful believe that it is nonetheless part of gods bigger plan.
 
Atheists are now going around spouting their belief system like it's a religion.

First of all I'm an atheist and secondly I agree with you and it bothers me that it is becoming like a religion. I'm an atheist because I don't believe in God, nothing religion tells me makes any sense to me, I don't have any deep philosophical reasons for not believing in a God, I just don't.

But I don't care if anyone or everyone is an atheist, believe what you want to believe just don't try and convince me you're right and I'm wrong, that I can't be a good or complete person unless I believe what you believe.
 
I have read the Bible 3 times (in 3 different translations) and the books of Isaiah and Ezekiel make absolutely no sense to me. So in that respect I agree with MrJake
 
I have read the Bible 3 times (in 3 different translations) and the books of Isaiah and Ezekiel make absolutely no sense to me. So in that respect I agree with MrJake

Would your view be different if you read them as parables rather than as an historical document?
 
Would your view be different if you read them as parables rather than as an historical document?
Maybe, but most of the Bible is highly symbolic. Its not an easy read in many parts. Its also open to different interpretations. One person interprets a certain verse one way, and the next person in another way
 
Maybe, but most of the Bible is highly symbolic. Its not an easy read in many parts. Its also open to different interpretations. One person interprets a certain verse one way, and the next person in another way

Very true but doesn't the effect change depending on whether or not the reader accepts it as literal truth?
 
If the Bible is so highly open to interpretation, I'm sure someone could interpret the idea of God being real as actually being a metaphor for nature, or maybe even interpret all of the Bible as a reason not to believe in it.

Probably not. The underlying premise of the Bible is that a) god exists, and b) he/she has revealed him/herself and his/her message.
 
I don't care to convert people to atheism, but the mandate of Christianity is to convert non-believers. That's what pisses me off. Unless you can interpret 'spread the gospel' to something else like, "I'm going to fuck off and leave you guys alone now," I'm going to continue to look down at people subservient to religion.

you are quite correct that the mandate of the NT is to spread the "good news."

Looking down on people is your choice. I don't think much of that approach to life. Sounds arrogant to me.

I guess you don't mind jews so much, they tend not to recruit.
 
People who believe in scripture that say things like that Jesus once raised a corpse from the dead after it was dead for four days are akin to people afflicted with mild psychosis/delusion.

Definition of delusion: False judgments held with extraordinary conviction and subjective certainty, resistant to contrary experience and counter-argument, whose content is impossible-or at least not verifiable.

Sounds familiar?


Definition of faith: belief in something for which there is no proof. In demanding evidence or logic or empirical proof you are simply misunderstanding the nature of religion.
 
People who believe in scripture that say things like that Jesus once raised a corpse from the dead after it was dead for four days are akin to people afflicted with mild psychosis/delusion.

Definition of delusion: False judgments held with extraordinary conviction and subjective certainty, resistant to contrary experience and counter-argument, whose content is impossible-or at least not verifiable.

Sounds familiar?

Do you think mental health professionals diagnose biblical literalists that way...or is it just you? I could say the same thing about Republicans. Neither group would I say is suffering from a mass delusion.
 
you are quite correct that the mandate of the NT is to spread the "good news."

Looking down on people is your choice. I don't think much of that approach to life. Sounds arrogant to me.

I guess you don't mind jews so much, they tend not to recruit.

In fact Jews discourage conversion and make it difficult to do so. Although it is common for some Jews to try and bring Jews back to faith it is not common to seek to convert non-Jews.